13 ms·
This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation
- arethuza 14y agoReminds me of the BMW C1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_C1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_C1
- excuse-me 14y agoAnd will be killed for the same reason. Country A will insist that it's a motorbike, require you to wear a helmet and have an enhanced heavy bike licence (because of it's top speed) Country B will insist that it's a car and require seatbelts, airbags etc. Country C will only allow electric bikes that have a top speed of 15m/h
- arethuza 14y agoNot to mention looking distinctly dorky.
- Luc 14y agoI see them around Antwerp fairly often. Especially estate agents (wearing a suit) seem to like them. It's no different than seeing a Smart car the first time - the novelty wears off rather quickly.
- merraksh 14y agoCountry C will only allow electric bikes that have a top speed of 15m/h You certainly mean km/h.
- phreeza 14y agoor m as in miles
- ktizo 14y agoTo be honest, I wasn't sure about the whole gyros thing and thought that it was unneeded complexity, until I realised they were also using them for regenerative braking/power. Then I went ooooo... If they are really smart with this, and if the gyros are up to the task, they could use them for ultra fast charging as well.
- tmuir 14y agoThe gyroscope keeps the vehicle from falling over when stopped. Even without regenerative braking, thats pretty necessary complexity when you can't stick your foot out to add a third point of contact.
- ktizo 14y agoA lever attached to a hinged stand is all the necessary complexity required to stop it falling over when stopped.
- tmuir 14y agoAre you talking about an automatic kickstand? What if you stop next to a pothole?
- ktizo 14y agoI'm thinking about some metal tubing welded a bit like a splayed out capital 'H', that is the width of the bike and hinged along the middle bar of the 'H', which you can push forward with your foot and has a spring on it. Attach rubber ends if you want to make it fancy.
- vannevar 14y agoIf they added two more wheels instead of the gyros, they'd get passive stabilization and lower cost. They'd also get more room for a larger battery and cargo or passengers. And since roads and parking lots are already designed for 4-wheel vehicles, the extra width wouldn't be much of a disadvantage.
- lambersley 14y agoThat sounds familiar; electric car
- jdietrich 14y agoTwo-wheeled vehicles have a party piece - they keep moving when traffic stops. In a city like London or Paris, a pedal cycle is faster than a car for most journeys. In a city like LA, a motorcycle can be twice as fast as a car during rush-hour. This has effects beyond the two-wheeled rider; Remember, you're never stuck in traffic, you are traffic. A recent study suggested that if 10% of car drivers switched to two-wheeled vehicles, congestion would reduce by 40%[1]. Currently, riders of motorcycles are at an exceptionally high risk of death or serious injury. A fully enclosed two-wheeler could be every bit as safe as a car. There are also substantial efficiency savings to be made, due to the C1's very small frontal area. A faired two-wheeler with a recumbent seating position is naturally very close to the aerodynamically ideal dolphin-shape. A four-wheeled vehicle could only achieve similar aerodynamic efficiency by being very long and low, with single or tandem seating, as in the Volkswagen 1L concept[2] or Shell Eco-Marathon competitors. This substantially compromises visibility and turning circle, making such a vehicle very poorly suited to its obvious use as an urban commuter. [1] http://www.acem.eu/publiq/PTW_Belgium_Study_FEBIAC_ENG.PDF http://www.acem.eu/publiq/PTW_Belgium_Study_FEBIAC_ENG.PDF [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_1-litre_car http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_1-litre_car
- vannevar 14y agoI'm not sure how safe it would be to split lanes in the C1; it's wider than a motorcycle, and it's being marketed to non-cyclists who may not be so skilled at weaving through tight spaces even with gyros. It would be more aerodynamic, no doubt, but I think we're a long way off from comparing the relative efficiency of electric vehicles. I think range and carrying capacity are bigger consumer concerns.
- 10dpd 14y agoI'm sure they've considered this, but being able to tilt while cornering at speed is vital for 2-wheeled vehicles. I guess there will be some flexibility to allow the vehicle to tilt without falling over.
- jmillikin 14y agoAccording to the article, the gyros will allow up to 45 degrees of tilt during turns.
- TylerE 14y agoRemember the last two-wheeled, gyro-stabilized future of transportation? The one that was largely a commercial flop, and which the company president (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Heselden http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Heselden) _drove off a cliff_.
- amalag 14y agoThe segway does what it's supposed to do. I think it has it's useful niche. It was marketed as a replacement for all transportation, but that is silly because only because of the cost.
- untog 14y agoWell, no- it was supposed to revolutionise personal transportation. At least, that's what they said when it launched. And the "future of transportation" sounds eerily similar.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoSpeaking of cost, this vehicle will start for ~$24,000. I mean, I'd buy it for... maybe $5000ish, if I were feeling particularly spendy?
- WiseWeasel 14y agoThey did mention that rev two would be around $16,000, assuming they're still in business. That's getting closer to a realistic price relative to competing products. Keep in mind that this is competing with commuter cars, not motorcycles. You can also deduct the cost of fuel over the vehicle's lifetime. For someone commuting one hour each way to work five days a week, the cost of gas for a big car can exceed $200/month, $2400/year, or $12,000 over the course of five years. That makes the up-front price seem quite a bit more competitive with gas-powered alternatives.
- TylerE 14y agoYou need to factor in the medical bills, though. With a loaded weight of under 1000lbs, in any sort of collision, this thing will lose. Doesn't really matter how strong the frame is, it's just simple physics. Similar situation with the "Smart" car. The passenger cell can take a 60mph impact into a barrier just fine. The passengers - not so much, the g-forces inflicted are much higher than a traditional vehicle. Even 12-18 inches of crumple zone would make a BIG difference.
- amalag 14y agoWill this need redundant gyros? Otherwise isn't it too risky if one blows out while you are driving?
- freehunter 14y agoI would hope that in case of a gyro failure the computer would stop listening to the gyros, display a warning light on the dashboard, and you'd be able to bring it to a stop based on the same principles that keep a normal bike upright. You might have to dump it on its side when it comes to a stop, but you shouldn't have to spin off. The dangers of that are roughly similar to a blowout in a normal car, momentary but nearly complete loss of control.
- excuse-me 14y agoIt's a gyro-wheel not a gyro-sensor. The angular momentum of the wheels is what keeps it upright (laterally). This is different to the Segway which used the motors to control the forward-backward tilt with position input from a gyro (actually an accelerometer)
- jules 14y agoThat can't be the (only) reason bikes stay upright. The gyroscopic effect is way too weak to keep it upright. Here is an article explaining why bikes do stay upright: http://ruina.tam.cornell.edu/research/topics/bicycle_mechanics/stablebicycle/StableBicyclev34Revised.pdf http://ruina.tam.cornell.edu/research/topics/bicycle_mechani...
- excuse-me 14y agoThis isn't an ordinary cycle - it has a pair of reaction wheels running at some fantastic number of RPM below the seat. "In final production form, the combined force of the pair of gyros will max out at around 1,300 pound-feet, enough to keep the C1 vertical while stopped"
- 14y ago
- timdiggerm 14y agoI bet the future of transportation will remember that many people have children they want to transport with them.
- jdietrich 14y agoIn southern Europe, motor scooters and light motorcycles are a substantial part of the transport mix. Scooters are a fast, economical, traffic-beating option. With fuel at over $8 per US gallon, a 100mpg scooter has tremendous appeal. It's quite common for dad to ride a scooter to work, while mum takes the kids to school in the car. A young adult is just as likely to start motoring on a scooter as in a car; Towns and cities in Spain and Italy are overflowing with scooters on weekend nights. Most of those towns were never designed for cars and have a desperate shortage of parking - you can get five or six scooters into one parking space. A vehicle like this has most of the advantages of a scooter, without the obvious shortcomings. It could fill the same role in the vehicle mix in countries where weather, safety concerns or cultural factors make motor scooters unpopular. Most car journeys involve a single occupant. That's a luxury we've been able to afford until now, but lugging around four empty seats is seeming ever more wasteful.
- dsr_ 14y agoIf it were much, much cheaper, a one-seater plus room for groceries would make a fine commuting vehicle. The problem, as always, is cost. My family manages with one vehicle plus public transit, but that vehicle has to be big (people and cargo and distance). Most of the time we could use something smaller, but the minority use case is enough to require the behemoth. If it were cheap enough, we could really use three vehicles: a commuter, an efficient four-seater, and a seldom used cargo/distance vehicle. That's not how the economics work out, though, so one vehicle has to serve all the purposes.
- coenhyde 14y agoAwesome, I hope this gets off the ground. It would be ideal to become an autonomous vehicle. Most people drive to work by themselves and use a car instead of a motorbike for protection from the elements and collisions. Imagine how much more efficient the road network would be if it was filled with autonomous gyro-stabilized motorbikes/whatever this is.
- rmc 14y agoHow much force would it take to knock the C1 on its side? According to Lit, a small elephant would have to hit it broadside to put the C1 on the ground. So… a car hitting the side then?
- kokey 14y agoWhat I really like about this is that because it's like a motor bike, you actually have time for the airbags to deploy, when it's being tipped over, shoved along, skidding on its side or flying through the air.
- RowanH 14y agoHaving seen the end result of a low speed collision last night between motorbike and car, with said dude on motorbike tail between legs, and one very raw burnt calf, very much agree there is a lot of merit in this. For all the arguments of a motorbike, even at low speeds, no matter which way you slice or dice it, you still get the wrong end of the stick if you get hit/drop it. I myself would make the leap to one of these in a heartbeat when they're production ready. Huge win for small commutes in and around the city, just myself.
- slavak 14y agoTo be fair, the big issue with current two-wheeled vehicles is hardly their bad safety against side collisions. There's a (different) reason medical personnel refer to them as "donorcycles"...
- dchest 14y agoAnd the past too http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gyrocar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gyrocar
- eslachance 14y agoThe first one was commissioned in 1912? Sounds like it would have been a great opportunity for Lit to actually release it this year... They won't miss the mark by much, though. No wait, scratch that, just looked up the word "commissioned"... So if they release it in 1914, they'll have hit the nail straight on. Good on them!
- DanBC 14y agoIt'd be great if this is road-legal in the UK. We like little vehicles - see the original Mini or the fiat Panda or some Renault 5's or the Fiat 500 or the Smart cars. There is a lower limit though. The Tango Commuter car hasn't taken off. (http://www.commutercars.com/ http://www.commutercars.com/) The Sinclair C5 was mocked and hated when released. (Surely a concept 30 years before its time?) Bikes are great, and more sensible cyclists are needed. These things could encourage people out of cars and into small personal vehicles. I'd be gently concerned by the amount of stop-go you need in UK town driving.
- rbreve 14y agoThey had one of these in Maker Faire
- tmuir 14y agoI talked to one of the guys in the Lit tent, and I remember him saying that they were aiming for the mid teens as a price point, and that they were planning for a higher capacity vehicle that was closer to the price listed in the article. I wonder what changed in the last 10 days.
- jff 14y agoAll the seating and cargo capacity of a motorcycle, with the visibility of a car! There's no way in hell I'd split lanes on that thing; when I'm on my motorcycle, I have no obstructions and can see all around me, and definitely know where the edges of my bike are. This looks like a low-slung claustrophobic nightmare. Even if it is a very technically cool thing.
- WiseWeasel 14y agoMaybe you can split two lanes occupied by other similar vehicles.
- ajross 14y agoI don't think the target market is existing bikers. The idea isn't that you "split lanes" trying to get places faster in a car-dominated environment, it's that you have a reasonable commute vehicle to use as a car replacement. Note that it was designed to have a windshield and roof (although this one doesn't seem to have the windows installed).
- mbenjaminsmith 14y agoI don't think they'll tap any market but motorcycle drivers. The cost -- even their lowered "target" cost of 16k -- will put you in a car of sorts (either a city car or a used one). I sincerely doubt anyone who can afford a four-wheeled alternative would consider this. It's just too small and too dangerous. Also, the gyroscopes will keep you upright even if you're hit? Yeah right. Let's see how that works out when an SUV hits you at 60. If it were way cooler -- and remember a Ducati, BWM, or just about any premium bike can be had for under 16k already -- I might consider it as a motorcycle driver. But like the OP said I would feel less safe in it because it's lower to the ground and has much less visibility.
- ajross 14y agoYou're not controlling variables. Of course you won't sell these into the existing market. But the existing market is unsustainable (fuel costs alone would change your calculus about "same cost as a car" today), so what will you sell in the future? Bikes, or these? I know what I'd buy. And I don't see anywhere where it claimed that the gyros would work in a collision that would destroy the vehicle; that's silly. The point is they won't tip over in a fender bender.
- jaggederest 14y agoThe gyro-stabilized, two-wheeled future of transportation is the bicycle, people. Seriously. If you're really into it, you can throw an electric assist motor on.
- startupfounder 14y agoThey already have them on kids bikes. Now they just need to upgrade to adult size, lower the weight, strap on an electric motor... http://www.thegyrobike.com/category-s/93.htm http://www.thegyrobike.com/category-s/93.htm
- WiseWeasel 14y agoAnd they should build the batteries into the wheel rims for extra stability.
- tincholio 14y agoNo, it isn't!
- jahewson 14y agoReminds me of the Sinclair C5... and looks equally dangerous on a road which also features real cars.
- georgieporgie 14y agoIt's kind of weird that they called it the C1, given that BMW came out with a similar vehicle (minus the gyros), also named the C1, years ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_C1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BMW_C1 This thing looks technologically very neat, but I don't see a point. It has all of the disadvantages of a motorcycle (small, vulnerable, noisy, non-intuitive steering, rounded tires that wear flat in the center quickly, unstable when sliding), combined with all of the disadvantages of a car (too wide to lane split, poor visibility due to low height and roof pillars, cost). I notice that it uses hub-centered steering. While nifty, it doesn't give a very good turning radius, which is another key advantage of a motorcycle in the city. Swingarm-style hub centered steering solves two problem inherent to traditional fork designs (front-end dive during braking, which alters the geometry and reduces suspension travel, and static friction), but introduces a host of other problems (complexity, joints that need lubrication, cost, limited turning radius). Through constant iteration, motorcycle forks have reached a stage of development (see nitride coating and now 'diamond' coating) where it's unlikely that any competing design will ever win. As a motorcyclist of 18 years, If it's too wide to lane split, then I see no advantage. Then again, Can Am seems to be selling well enough, which boggles my mind: http://en-us.spyder.brp.com/home.aspx http://en-us.spyder.brp.com/home.aspx If someone wants the convenience of a two-wheeler without the stability and steering issues, then a simpler idea like the Piaggio MP3 is probably the ideal mix of practicality, complexity, and cost: http://www.piaggiousa.com/innovation.html http://www.piaggiousa.com/innovation.html
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThis is a cool concept, although I doubt it will be ready by 2014 at their current rate. My reasoning on that is that you have to have a complete pre-production vehicle before you can even start safety testing. But that isn't a knock, I like optimism as much as the next person. The horizontal flywheel concept is quite cool, and I'm glad they avoided the problem of earlier attempts which just had one (cars that did this would change their front/back weight balance going around turns in a non-helpful way) Having both (and running them in opposite directions!) means you can cancel out that effect. I'd worry a bit about the need to keep them spun up at 'idle', its a work load that electric vehicles don't normally carry, but you do get some of that back in efficiency gains when using them as dynamic energy storage so perhaps it is a wash. Would love to see the math on that. If they wanted to hit the tri-fecta of buzzword viral bingo they should use a 3D printer to print the body out of carbon fiber or something :-)
- lloeki 14y agoAmusingly the problems you mention are inherent to a two-wheeler, and given the necessary dimensions of the egg-shaped outside you might as well add some more wheels at the corners to solve the stability problem. Then you end up with something like Renault Twizy [0] (look at the top view on page 2 to get an idea of its dimensions), currently sold today starting at 7000€, plus 50€/month of battery rent. I would not have bet on that vehicle but it seems to be selling, since I already encountered a bunch of them. A bunch of stats (for the topmost model, as the lower one is limited in power and does not require a driving license): 13kW/17ch 80km/h top speed 0-45km/h in 6.1s 100km range 6.1kWh battery 473kg with battery (~100kg) [0] http://www.renault.fr/media/e-brochures/att00409285/ebrochure-twizy.pdf http://www.renault.fr/media/e-brochures/att00409285/ebrochur...
- ahi 14y agoIIRC, two and three-wheeled vehicles dodge a lot of the safety and licensing regulations of four-wheeled automobiles. Partly why there are so many more custom motorcycle builders than custom car builders. I don't know what two-wheels gets you over a three-wheel version except the expense of cool gyros.
- hexagonal 14y agoHow much power do the gyros consume? And, of course, if you're using them for regenerative breaking, then they'll have less headroom to counter tilting forces. If you saturate them with regen load then they won't provide any stabilizing force at all. I hope it has a couple of really beefy power resistors in case the ECU suddenly has to bleed off gyro load in a way that won't cause an uncommanded acceleration.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThis is a non-starter. This fills the same niche as an electric moped at 6% or less of the cost. And people can drive electric mopeds on city streets legally today. For less than half the price someone could buy a used, low-mileage sedan (such as a Civic, Corolla, or Accent), with a trunk, seating for 5, seatbelts and airbags. And then use the other $8k to pay for gas at $5 a gallon for the next 48,000 miles. Or, they could buy 2x brand-new 150cc Honda motorcycles and use the extra money to pay for the gas (at $5 a gallon) for the next 50,000 miles for both vehicles (100k total). Doesn't make economic sense. Doesn't make safety sense. Doesn't make logistical sense. Doesn't make practical sense. Doesn't make environmental sense. What's the value add?
- katabatic 14y agoI don't really see this being comparable to a moped. A moped is like a teeny tiny motorcycle - it's an exposed 1 or (at best) two seater with barely any cargo capacity, no protection from the elements, and no crash protection. This should appeal to someone who wouldn't be comfortable on an exposed two wheeler in traffic. And considering that 80% of trips taken in cars today have a single occupant, the "seating for 5" argument probably doesn't matter to plenty of people. Obviously, it always will for people with kids and dogs to transport, but there are enough people without those encumbrances to make up a very healthy market.
- cjensen 14y agoI'm just as skeptical as you, but... Electric mopeds cannot go on freeways. An electric motorcycle is better for nontrivial distances. On the other hand, an electric moped which cannot travel faster than 20mph also has an advantage: in California it is treated as a bicycle and can travel on bike paths on major bridges. My main complaint: if neither electric motorcycles nor self-balancing motorcycles are currently popular, why would an electric self-balancing motorcycle be popular?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoWell, if you want a highway vehicle then you can buy an electric motorcycle for half or a quarter the cost of this thing (such as the Brammo Enertia or the EMC GPR-S). Electric motorcycles seem to have some degree of minor popularity, but are certainly a tiny niche even compared to plug-in hybrid cars. But the value-add of a self-balancing motorcycle seems highly dubious.
- puivert 14y agoMotorcycles don't have "amazing fuel economy": small cars do <100 g/km and sadly few motorcycles beat that.
- mcguire 14y agoThis. Admittedly, the aerodynamics of this thing should be better than most motorcycles.
- studio816 14y agoI may have missed something, but how does it stay upright when parked? Is there a kick-stand of some sort?
- katabatic 14y agoThere was a brief moment in the video where they pulled a support out from under it to demo the gyro-stabilization. Clearly, the rolling prototype doesn't have a kick-stand, but I would suspect some kind of auto-deploying twin-leg kickstand would be added for production. Something that deploys when you turn the ignition off, for example, since you wouldn't want those gyros running all the time just to keep it upright in storage.
- drobilla 14y agoFor half a century, especially in America, we've been hearing about the "future of transportation" in the form of some car, or car-like non-mass transit device. The numbers don't work out, the logistics don't work out, and the infrastructure doesn't work out. The future of transit is obviously not cars: not normal 4 wheeled cars, not flying cars, not fancy gyro stabilized two wheeled cars. Ideas otherwise are quaint turn of the century throwbacks that ceased making sense anywhere in non-rural a very long time ago.
- jrockway 14y agoThe problem is that we've poured so much money into roads that any technology that doesn't use them is at a multi-billion-dollar disadvantage.
- cypherpunks01 14y agoReminds me of a recumbent bicycle, which I was always bewildered by - I live in nyc and can never imagine riding around on one because I wouldn't be able to see anything except the backs of vehicles. I feel very comfortable bicycling and motorcycling around the city precisely because I can see very far ahead by being higher up than most cage drivers. I could see this gyro bike suffering from the same problem in the city, which is probably where it was designed for?
- geogra4 14y agoI always liked the Velomobile concept. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velomobile http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velomobile
- bitsoda 14y agoWhile gyros are way cool, adding them for stability reeks of overengineering when simply adding another wheel could achieve the same effect. This reminds me of the urban myth of the Russians using a pencil instead of spending money to develop a zero-gravity pen.
- jrockway 14y agoWhy do you need another wheel? I don't see a lot of tipped-over motorcycles lining the sides of roads, after all...
- jrockway 14y agoWhy do they need gyros to balance the bike? I can do that myself.
- bane 14y agoLooks not that far removed from http://outcaststudios.com/forums/uploads/monthly_04_2011/post-1606-0-56859500-1303191860.jpg http://outcaststudios.com/forums/uploads/monthly_04_2011/pos... which makes me very excited.