4 ms·
The important part is not just efficiency, it's also capital cost of the electrolyzer system. It can make sense to reduce efficiency (say, by increasing curren
by pfdietz 3y ago
The important part is not just efficiency, it's also capital cost of the electrolyzer system. It can make sense to reduce efficiency (say, by increasing current density) if that reduces capital cost per kW. I don't see the cost/kW here, although it claims "low capex". Low capex is particularly important when driving the electrolyzers with sources with intermittency.
- epistasis 3y agoExactly, capital cost (which is a function both of upfront cost and the lifetime) is the dominant cost of electrolyzed hydrogen right now. Right now in California a bunch of organizations are prematurely adopting hydrogen tech that is not ready to be deployed, for buses and trains, despite failed pilots of these all over the globe. Decision makers are using the wrong parameters to make investments that last decades, and it's extremely disheartening. Pretty much all hydrogen hype out there feeds into these bad decisions but the inappropriateness of the metrics is somehow being ignored.
- pfdietz 3y agoYou can view the hype as trying to drive up interest in projects to move electrolyzers (and other hydrogen technology) down their experience curves.
- philipkglass 3y agoFor intermittent sources it's also important to be able to cycle on/off (or throttle to partial power) frequently. In reading about green hydrogen projects I saw it mentioned that traditional alkaline electrolyzers could not safely run in an intermittent fashion, although proton exchange membrane electrolyzers could. Unfortunately, the source that mentioned this did not say why alkaline units were unsafe to run this way, and my searches for more information were not successful. My guess is something like "it relies on a certain outflow rate of gases to prevent hydrogen/oxygen mixing" but I'm not sure why that is a particular issue for traditional alkaline electrolyzers, or how difficult it is to mitigate. The alkaline units otherwise require only common materials, have been manufactured forever, and seem like the natural thing to build more of for coupling to intermittent renewables.
- pfdietz 3y agoInability to cycle rapidly can be dealt with by including batteries, and/or by having a bank of electrolyzers that are not all operating at the same time.
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoI hear people talking about intermittent operation of electrolyzers, but this sounds to me like the stupidest thing to do: * Intermittent operation means you need to either build a huge buffer tank, or overprovision your transport infrastructure compared to your average production rate * Your customers need to deal with a less reliable supplier * Intermittent operation means shorter maintenance intervals, more stress on your electrolysis units and higher demand on your BoP * When you've put down a huge capex, the marginal cost of not running the plant is quite high, so it makes sense to run 24/7 even at high energy prices
- pfdietz 3y agoIt's talked about because the sources are intermittent. There will be large price swings in the grid of the future; hydrogen can act as a source of dispatchable demand. For dispatchable demand you want a reasonable application with minimal capex per watt (and also low fixed opex), and hydrogen fits that bill. What other application do you think has as low a capex per watt as electrolysis? Maybe heating thermal batteries? But that's not useful for long term smoothing. Data centers have something like 100x the capex/watt of hydrogen.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- belter 3y ago(2023): "...Currently, the production cost of renewable hydrogen (using renewable energy) is at least twice that of hydrogen produced from fossil fuels. Hysata says its technology will slash costs and produce hydrogen “well below” a competitive target price of $2 per kilogram (approx. US$1.50/kg)..." - https://arena.gov.au/blog/hysata-to-build-next-generation-hydrogen-electrolyser/ https://arena.gov.au/blog/hysata-to-build-next-generation-hy...