3 ms·
Well it looks like the link is down and the only archive snapshot I see is a loading screen: https://archive.is/obzJ9 https://archive.is/obzJ9 ----- BEGIN EDIT
by godelski 3y ago
Well it looks like the link is down and the only archive snapshot I see is a loading screen: https://archive.is/obzJ9 https://archive.is/obzJ9
----- BEGIN EDIT -----
I can see it from the mastadon app but not in browser. I took a screenshot for others: https://i.imgur.com/q3DA7wQ.png https://i.imgur.com/q3DA7wQ.png
Text is:
Our university deployed a mail filter that rewrites URLs in emails to redirect them via a service that checks for bad websites. Somebody clever worked out that PGP-signed emails are exempt from the rewrite rule, so now people are starting their emails with "BEGIN PGP MESSAGE" even though they haven't used PGP at all, just to fool the filter
Anybody sending malware links has probably also worked out that trick by now, thereby rendering the entire filter pointless
@martin@nondeterministic.computer
----- END EDIT -----
But I have an interesting issue which is (presumably) related. I keep getting obviously spam emails in my gmail and Google has refused to do anything about it (after finally getting through to support). These are embarrassingly bad emails. Ones you'd expect a naive bayesian classifier to get near 100% accuracy on!
In the "to" address is something that's not even remotely my email. Suppose I'm godelski@gmail.com, the "to" has something like "robbert01@gmail.com" and always has a CC with a different number. Subject lines will be things like "confirmation of receipt" but in non-standard and inconsistent fonts. And the message body is that all too typical single image and claim of something like winning a home depot gift card. The "from" address is always some scammy looking address. So Naive Bayes should get it on just this alone!
But the weird thing is when you show the original message. There's PAGES of stuff in here (about 20 pages or 9.5k words)! All kinds of email conversations, things including stuff like "here is your one time <account> password", stuff in other languages, survey questions, conversations, and a lot more. I actually did a diff on a few of these and they're almost identical too! I can't help but think that these are some weird prompt injections. It looks like it is written by a madman, but it it's probably some "throw shit at the wall and see what sticks" kinda thing.
But the message ID always comes from some Microsoft (something like microsoftstore1.microsoft.com). This is where Google support said it isn't their problem and moved on. I'm pretty critical of LLMs and their ability to reason, but I feel often we're trying to turn humans into machines instead of letting them complement one another. And I think this is why so many business people like LLMs, because they think everything can be figured out with clear immutable rules. But the thing is that the environment always changes and you need something that's not only adaptable, but can reason AND understands the actual desired outcome that humans want.
I hope someone at Google pays attention. Because you can't just hand all thinking over to humans. We're not there yet and it's why everything is going to shit (not just Google)
- cesarb 3y ago> In the "to" address is something that's not even remotely my email. Suppose I'm godelski@gmail.com, the "to" has something like "robbert01@gmail.com" and always has a CC with a different number. You probably already know this, but the content of these headers is not relevant for email routing. The list of email addresses which will actually receive an email message can be found on the SMTP commands, which precede (and are independent from) the email headers and body. If you look closely at all headers, you can probably find it, since most SMTP servers AFAIK add one or more header fields containing the email address found on the SMTP command. That's how BCC can work: the list of emails in the BCC is never sent within the email message (unlike TO or CC), they are only sent on the SMTP commands.
- godelski 3y agoYeah it is under the SMTP that the microsoft email appears and that's why Google says it isn't their problem. Which I'm still just not sure how in any world a customer receiving spam is considered not their problem. But I was suggesting that the actual content in the headers should be providing a hint at spam. Because if something like being "from" home depot shouldn't match with an edu domain. Still, these emails are just wild and I'm very upset that google will do nothing about them. I get them at least once a week. And it is unfortunately hard to switch emails... I'm in the process by trying to create unique emails with a relay service so I can just redirect, but still....