5 ms·
This might seem calculating and cold, but that's basically how government agencies work. It doesn't make sense to spend unlimited amounts of money to save a lif
by gruez 3y ago
This might seem calculating and cold, but that's basically how government agencies work. It doesn't make sense to spend unlimited amounts of money to save a life, so government agencies have some sort of a dollar value on a life[1], above which where they won't bother doing interventions. For instance if it takes $15M to save a life, and that's above the DoT's estimate of $12.5M, then they won't bother. That's not to say that Boeing is in the right here, but if they were in the wrong it's not because "If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one", it's because they grossly undervalued a life in their calculations.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#United_States
- jollyllama 3y agoWe were taught as part of our CS curriculum that "often, the refusal to assign a dollar value to a human life results in it being terribly undervalued."
- skywal_l 3y agoPut some CEOs in jail and you won't need to do all those multiplications.
- mountainb 3y agoThere is no such reluctance to do this in law. I think in philosophy classes, professors feel shy about acknowledging the humdrum reality of insurance, the tax code, and our regulatory bodies continuously assigning dollar values to human lives. It feels good and makes you look like a better person to say things like "the value of a single human life cannot be expressed in money terms." Perhaps this is the case, and what the companies and the governmental bodies are really valuing is the economically meaningful activity associated with a person and not the totality of their person. Babies are worth a lot of money even at a low imputed earning potential just because they have so much life to live.
- HPsquared 3y agoIn practice, there's a difference between a hypothetical probabilistic death rate, and real people / news stories.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- burkaman 3y agoGovernment agencies use the statistical value of a life to weigh the benefits of a regulation against the costs to the public - the same people who would benefit from the regulation. Would a new safety requirement for cars be worth it if it added $500 to the price of every new car? They might use the value of a life to help answer that question. This is very different than the recall story, because in that scenario there is no cost to the public at all, only to the corporation. When government agencies make rules about product recalls, they do not try to balance the benefit to the public against the cost to the recalling company, that would be insane. See the DoT's own guidance here: https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2021-03/DOT%20VSL%20Guidance%20-%202021%20Update.pdf https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2021-03/D.... They do not at all use this figure in the same way that a profit-driven entity does. > The benefit of preventing a fatality is measured by what is conventionally called the Value of a Statistical Life, defined as the additional cost that individuals would be willing to bear for improvements in safety (that is, reductions in risks) that, in the aggregate, reduce the expected number of fatalities by one. The word "individuals" is very important in this definition.
- gruez 3y ago>This is very different than the recall story, because in that scenario there is no cost to the public at all, only to the corporation. ...assuming they don't pass it on to the customers
- burkaman 3y agoThat would be illegal, and "the public" is much larger than just the customers of a particular company. This is beside the point though. The government asks "would the average person be willing to pay $x to lower their chance of death by y%". The corporate executive asks "would I be willing to pay >$0 to lower their chance of death by y%". "Some of you may die, but it's a sacrifice I am willing to make."
- krisoft 3y ago> That would be illegal What do you mean it would be illegal? Obviously the corporation prices in all the expected future recalls into their prices. Yes they won't charge you for the recall, but the future costumers will pay higher prices if in the corporation's calculation the chance of recalls (or the cost of doing them) is increased.
- cced 3y agoThe problem with this type of thinking is that it often assumes externalized costs, and even at that, what price do you put on “I don’t want to use car of brand X because the car maker is doing sus things and people speaking out about it are dying.” ? Take for instance the recent train derailments. Are the costs of cleanup n>0 if the company can get their lawyers to successfully argue they don’t need to pay it? For the company it’s n=0 but for society it is n>0. Doing the maths is simpler when you can disregard many factors and leave only the ones that affect your bottom line.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoNo it's because they grossly underestimated the importance of brand trust and reputation
- crznp 3y agoOr: they had an accurate estimate for the importance of brand trust and reputation over the short term, and they've had that short term outlook for a long time. Perhaps since 1997.
- Spooky23 3y agoThere’s always a risk calculus that seems cold to an outside observer. The issue with Boeing and the MAX is that they sort of used the designation of the plane to for lack of a better term, avoid some of the risk calculations. With the early issues, a pretty cut and dry type training program would have likely prevented catastrophic incidents. They shaved pennys and set many dollars (and hundreds of people) on fire. If you run a company where low probability, high impact risks drive the operations of your products, setting trust on fire is going to have a real impact on your bottom line. You go from a trusted, admired company to target of memes about assassinated whistleblowers.
- everforward 3y agoMy very amateur understanding is that the MAX would have been dead on arrival if it required recertification. It was a marginal bump in fuel efficiency that still lagged behind Aerobus, so their only real marketing strategy was not having to recertify. Basically either it didn’t require recertification or it wasn’t worth making. I suspect somewhere along the line they realized that wasn’t practical and they either shipped a shoddy project and maybe burned a pile of money or they gave up and definitely burned a smaller but still sizable pile of money. Probably also some worry that if they didn’t have a competitive smaller plane, they’d lose market share and there’d be even less interest in their next plane.
- idontpost 3y ago[dead]
- salawat 3y ago...Actually it doesn't matter how relatively uncompetitive it would have been in the face of Airbus. Their (Airbus's) waitlist is so bloody long, you'd still have looked longingly at Boeing anyway. Despite that, they made a coscious decision to deceive airlines, pilots, and their regulators. All to "maximize shareholder value". That's what's criminal.
- Spooky23 3y agoExactly. End of the day, poor governance from product inception to execution to operation.
- stephenr 3y agoGovernment agencies in the form of rescue/emergency response organisations frequently spend huge sums of money to try to rescue indidivuals. The US Coast Guard explicitly stated that they "do not associate cost with saving a life" following that fateful Billionaires game of chicken with extreme water pressure.
- badpun 3y agoThe difference is that the government agency actions do not cause deaths (it merely prevents death from independent causes), whereas "major car manufacturer" kills people with their faulty rear differential.
- bastard_op 3y agoAnd what self-respecting congressman, senator, or president didn't have a pet CEO or three of any said major automotive cartel at the time sponsoring them? If they didn't, they're not doing it right.