4 ms·
The whole “if you criticise the Chinese government you must be racist against the Chinese” thing is getting really old. You don’t see the same national security
by audunw 2y ago
The whole “if you criticise the Chinese government you must be racist against the Chinese” thing is getting really old. You don’t see the same national security risk concerns when it comes to Taiwan which is mostly inhabited by exactly the same ethnicity so this accusation can be completely dismissed in this context.
Using the racism card, and trying to hijack the Asian anti-racism movement (don’t assume I’m ignoring the real problem of racism against Asians btw) for its own purpose, is a pretty blatant PRC propaganda tool. So I find it ironic that you complain about western propaganda (which is a real thing, I’m not ignoring that either) while falling completely for such blatant PRC propaganda talking points.
It feels like you’re also just dismissing the idea that PRC does represent a significant national security risk to USA? I mean, looking at recent history that’s objectively true.
How much it should be emphasised in the context of a commercial business that doesn’t involve telecommunication is arguable. But it’s worth talking about.
The fact that they’re “communist” (well, I’d argue they’re in reality authoritarian state capitalist.. but I think we have the same political structure in mind) is extremely relevant. China has a history of not letting American companies operate in China under the same terms as Chinese companies can operate in USA, precisely because they are “communist”. That’s objectively true. It’s fair to debate whether it’s OK to let Chinese companies operate freely in USA when they put up so many barriers for American companies in China.
To raise these very real issues is not just propaganda. They’re issues worth thinking about.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoTo criticise the Chinese government is one thing. The hysteria of some as soon as something is "linked to China" is quite another. The racism is not as open and "in your face" as it was during the 50s and 60s, when it was just appalling and the anti-communist propaganda of the time used racist tropes all the time (like the anti-Japanese propaganda had done during WWII), but it is still there to a degree. It's not the main driver but it 'helps' the propaganda, like "communist" does. In the end, though, the main problem the US have is that China is getting too powerful (the fact that they are "communists" and not white may make it even more unpalatable to some and, again, does help propaganda). The rest of your comment does not merit a reply.