4 ms·
X now treats the term cisgender as a slur
- riow 3y ago[flagged]
- ftyhbhyjnjk 3y ago[flagged]
- palata 3y agoI genuinely don't get it. How is that a slur to non-trans people? Do you think that "non-trans" is a slur as well?
- ftyhbhyjnjk 3y ago[flagged]
- palata 3y agoHmm you seem to be saying two different things here: 1. Words describing concepts you don't like are "slurs". Would you say that "genocide", "murder", "mobbing" are slurs, too? 2. Merely using a word means "forcing an ideology". If I talk about a genocide, would you think that I am trying to force my ideology (which would be... I guess an ideology of genocide, somehow)? Do I get that right? I'm genuinely trying to understand. The way I see it is this: there are people in the world who identify themselves with a gender that differs from their sex societally designated/assigned at birth. That is not an ideology, that is a fact. Instead of using this whole sentence when referring to them as a group, the word "transgender" (or "trans" for short) can be used. It is just a descriptive word. Now if someone wants to refer to the group of people who are not trans, they can say "non-trans". I don't really see that as a word, but rather as a language construct ("not trans"). Instead of saying "non-trans", one can say "cisgender" ("cis" for short). In my view, those words just describe factual groups of people. I genuinely don't see how they force an ideology (what ideology would that be?).
- ftyhbhyjnjk 3y agoWe should start calling all "normal" people as "non-murderers" since they don't murder people. Obviously since we have the word murderer, there needs to be a word for other section too. Isn't it. Calling them "normal", I guess is too much to absorb by fragile made-up trans egos.
- rsynnott 3y ago> Why in the first place u need a separate word for that? 'Cis[whatever]' means 'Non-trans[whatever]', essentially. 'Non-trans' is an incredibly awkward phrasing; there is already a way to say that, and it is 'Cis'. I wonder, in the more right-wing-aligned US universities, do history lectures have to talk about Julius Caesar being made governor of Non-Transalpine Gaul, to avoid offending the snowflakes by using the Forbidden Prefix. Cislunar space? Surely you mean Normal-lunar space, praise be to Musk.
- refurb 3y agoPretty sure you can have preferred group identity name? I mean, Native Americans don’t like “Indian”, so we stopped. Common courtesy seems like a nice thing to do? If cis people don’t want to be called “cis” then we should use the label they prefer?
- palata 3y ago> Common courtesy seems like a nice thing to do? If cis people don’t want to be called “cis” then we should use the label they prefer? That is completely fair! My next question is: what proportion of cis people are offended by the word? I personally couldn't care less, and I can't think of anyone around me who cares more than me. I'm all for common courtesy, but it has to be based on something. "I don't like being called cisgenre and therefore I can conclude that all cisgenre dislike it too" seems a bit wrong to me.
- proc0 3y ago[flagged]
- ZeroGravitas 3y ago[flagged]
- proc0 3y agoIt's not because of any "conspiracy theory". It's just parasitic ideas that infect young minds and spreads like a religion. This collection of ideas have evolved to appeal to people's emotions and paints a cynical picture of history which is then used to justify extreme actions. Like I said, a lot of people are blind to this and take these parasitic ideas on good faith, when in reality we can have equality, human rights, etc., without thinking there is another group of oppressors that have been keeping humanity back... as you have just illustrated with your own opinion there. If you think there is such a group of "horrible" people, you might want to reflect to what extent you have been affected by these pseudo-religious ideas.
- jjgreen 3y agoQuite, keep it polite, "pedo guy" is fine
- ClassyJacket 3y ago[flagged]
- rsynnott 3y ago> I just identify as normal Oh, my god, they said it, they said the thing! As I mentioned elsewhere in the thread, this is exactly what the more sensitive right-wing snowflakes were professing to get upset about in the late 90s and early noughties, only about the term 'straight'.
- dom96 3y agoHistory is such a powerful way to see through the bullshit. And yet, it doesn’t matter. Plenty of idiots out there that continue repeating history’s mistakes.
- rsynnott 3y agoIt's astonishing to me, as a (WARNING: slur coming up if you happen to be Elon Musk) cis gay just how much they're copy-and-pasting 90s and noughties anti-gay tropes to go after the trans people. Extremely lazy hate movement. (Obviously it's not like transphobia is new, but 20s-transphobia seems modelled after noughties-homophobia in a way that noughties-transphobia wasn't.)
- ftyhbhyjnjk 3y ago[flagged]
- viraptor 3y agoIt reminds me of the time when gay people were not that visible. Once the term "heterosexual" got more common, many people were freaked out to be described that way. I guess similarly others are so afraid of the transgender topic, they are scared of even being described as the groups at all. We'll just have to wait until they get over that too.
- refurb 3y agoWhat do you mean “get over it”? Aren’t people allowed to have a preferred label?
- viraptor 3y agoThis is a factual description. Is your gender on the same side as your biological sex? That's all cisgender means today. Like tall, or blonde, or young. Sure, you can have another preferred label. You can even try to make it popular - maybe others will like it too. It wouldn't be the first time there's a shift like that. By "get over it", I mean realise nobody's using it to insult them and there's zero impact on their lives due to the term existing. (For many, if they don't actively seek out conversations about this topic, they may not even realise it exists)
- bloak 3y ago> This is a factual description. Is your gender on the same side as your biological sex? That's all cisgender means today. That may seem reasonable, and I certainly wouldn't want to argue against it, but I've seen enough discussions around these questions to know that what's written there is not entirely uncontroversial. Firstly, even an indisputable fact can be offensive if you mention it in a context in which other people consider it to be entirely irrelevant. Secondly, some activists vehemently deny the existence of "biological sex". They insist on talking about "gender assigned at birth" instead. I can tell you from experience that arguing with those people is not always productive. Thirdly, although standard English uses two different pronouns for people, "he" and "she", so gender is an undeniable social fact in any community that speaks standard English, some languages (probably most languages) don't have gender so "gender" isn't such a simple factual thing in those communities. You may be able to infer gender from roles in society, behaviour or clothing styles but it's less clear.
- rsynnott 3y agoBloody hell, what a sensitive snowflake. I remember back in the 90s, certain weirder straight people getting upset about the term 'straight'; after all, they weren't straight, they were _normal_! It's extremely weird to see this playing out again 30 years later.
- insectivore 3y agoI don’t remember it for straight but I definitely remember it for heterosexual, and abled. I think it’s not weird though, I think having so many examples proves it’s “normal” (ha!) It’s something about the updated language or discussions around it implying (or outright stating) that having not used it previously makes one morally wrong that gets people upset perhaps? As an aside: I do think it’s reasonable to use the word “normal” when referring to a trait that, say, 90% of people share. It’s just that not having the trait shouldn’t be treated as bad, broken, or abnormal. For instance, it’s ok to think of being right-handed as normal or the default, just don’t treat being left-handed as bad or wrong.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y agoIt was born Twitter and I'm still going to call it Twitter /s
- Ekaros 3y agoIt is used as one. So it should be treated as one. Sounds like reasonable step towards safety and inclusivity.
- archagon 3y agoBut white nationalism is wholly inoffensive: https://www.axios.com/2024/05/03/elon-musk-nick-fuentes-x-account https://www.axios.com/2024/05/03/elon-musk-nick-fuentes-x-ac...
- awareBrah 3y agoAs much as I like Elon and think the term cisgender is stupid, this is such a bad look for him if X is meant to truly be the free speech platform. This is just woke but inverted.