4 ms·
The usual theory is that developers would underspec the number of private parking spaces relative to residence requirements (and of course residents and require
by ghaff 3y ago
The usual theory is that developers would underspec the number of private parking spaces relative to residence requirements (and of course residents and requirements can change over time). Common parking would then be oversubscribed including for residents/visitors in the area who don't have private off-street parking.
- alistairSH 3y agoWouldn’t a prospective tenant ask about parking, and if there isn’t enough, look elsewhere? Or find a commercial lot to park?
- ghaff 3y agoInformation is often imperfect especially during a quick buying/renting process. A buyer could easily figure they'll use the private spot for one car and they can always use on-street permit parking for the second car even though there are a bunch of houses that depend on that parking for their vehicle. (Or whatever scenario--don't get hung up on the details of that specific one. The general concern is that new construction may lean on a shared resource to keep its own costs down.)
- CalRobert 3y agoSo.... They can buy or rent a parking spot, then. Or even build a garage.
- ars 3y agoIf every house needs two spots - on off street, one on street right in front of the house, all is well. Then someone says "Why should I pay for a parking spot or a garage? I'll just park on-street by my neighbor!" That only works if a couple people do it. Once too many do it you have unhappy residents - they paid for their off-street spot but the other guy didn't!
- alistairSH 3y agoWe probably shouldn’t provide “free” on-street parking everywhere either. Make car users pay for that choice. [yes I realize that’s a change to 70+ years of urban design and can’t happen ovrrnight]
- ghaff 3y agoThe alternatives are not necessarily free to the neighborhood as a whole. A lot of places would have to build a bunch of garages if they were to eliminate any on-street parking. So now you have more garages everywhere. Maybe that's a good tradeoff. Maybe it's not. But I'm familiar with urban neighborhood with on street (mostly permit or metered) parking that have very few garages or parking lots at all.
- alistairSH 3y agoPaid permits and meters are fine - that solves the “stealing all the free spaces” problem mentioned above. The point is a some close to a market solution should be feasible and desirable.
- ghaff 3y agoIn the cities I’m familiar with essentially all street parking is metered or resident. There’s a cost for resident parking but it’s typically a lot less than a monthly garage spot would be. When a lot of people talk about “free” parking I think they’re mostly lumping those in. Resident parking spots are certainly an oversubscribed common resource in many areas.
- lokar 3y agoEveryone pays, either in time or money. The point is to decouple this from the payment for housing. If every apartment comes with two spots, why not have two cars (and drive more). If you have to pay a market rate (in time or money) to park each car you may well decide to make due with one car.
- jltsiren 3y agoAnd the usual answer is eliminating free on-street parking. Developers will build whatever parking is cost-effective to build. Residents will need a permit for on-street parking, while visitors pay hourly rates. The prices vary by area, and they are set to a level that ensures a high occupancy rate, while people with a permit can still find a space near their homes. What usually happens is that parking will be cheap enough to make dedicated parking structures commercially unviable. But even that cheap enough price will be too expensive for some people that they decide to get rid of their cars instead.