3 ms·
> This is actually misleading. You’re only right if the US stops spending This is actually misleading, your statement is only correct if “spending” is replaced
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> This is actually misleading. You’re only right if the US stops spending
This is actually misleading, your statement is only correct if “spending” is replaced with “additional borrowing”. (Assuming the federal government has non-zero revenue, “spending” does not imply “additional borrowing”.)
Moreover, GP’s broader point – that the burden of federal debt can be reduced even if the total amount is not – applies more broadly than just the static-total-debt case, it can be true with additional net borrowing, so long as the debt service cost at year y+1 is a smaller share of the GDP than in year y (assuming debt service relative to debt for simplicity, this would hold if the debt: GDP ratio was the same or less, irrespective of the nominal, or even real, level of debt increasing.)
E.g., suppose the US has $25 trillion GDP and 37.5 trillion national debt. Over the course of one year, it reaches $26.25 trillion nominal GDP, $38.625 trillion nominal national debt, and has experienced 2% annual inflation, so that, in base year terms, real GDP is $25.735 trillion, real debt is $37.828 trillion. Nominal debt is up, Real debt is up. So is this worse? No, because debt:GDP dropped from 1.5 to 1.47, so – again, assuming constant debt service costs per $ of debt – the share of output needed to service the debt is reduced.