10 ms·
You are forgetting one point about the current AI technology. No creativity. Yes you can ask models to generate music, video, images. But they are rehashing the
by belter 3y ago
You are forgetting one point about the current AI technology. No creativity. Yes you can ask models to generate music, video, images. But they are rehashing the content of somebody else. Asking to create a video of Michael Jackson dancing at the style of Fred Astaire with music similar to a Metallica song, is rehashing, not creativity. There is nothing in the current GenAI that is not a rehash.
It will stop when they run out of data, or when the training data needs to be isolated from the datasets created by GenAI.
So create something based on human creation. Sell it to the LLM trainers. It's the new business model....
- baal80spam 3y agoI think the creativity is now in the prompts...
- thorum 3y agoA creative prompt can do new things with existing art styles. It can’t make new art styles.
- mindcandy 3y agoIf you don't think new art styles have come out of AI art, you haven't looked for them. Or, you are putting your requirements for "new art style" too high for even humans to achieve moving forward indefinitely.
- belter 3y agoShow an example...
- thorum 3y agoMaybe? My definition of an art style would be something distinct and recognizably different like say, Van Gogh, Picasso, synthwave, or the aesthetic of one of Wes Anderson’s movies. I’ve seen AI blend, remix and do slight variations on these styles, but I haven’t seen AI make something that I’d consider a new style in that same sense. Can you share an example?
- mindcandy 3y agoWell, if the standard is "A group worked on a style for decades, it changed the field widely, and decades later it is recognized and studied worldwide" then nothing made in the past four years can possibly qualify :P Because random people with and without AI make all kinds of new styles every day. It's only in grand retrospectives that they are declared "A New Movement In The World of ART!" I don't think it's hard at all for AI to create new styles. Will one of those become a new art movement? We'll have to wait a while for the retrospective. Meanwhile, I'd recommend reading https://twitter.com/halecar2/status/1731612961465082167 https://twitter.com/halecar2/status/1731612961465082167 And, checking out https://twitter.com/misterduchamp/status/1785009271010148734 https://twitter.com/misterduchamp/status/1785009271010148734
- belter 3y agoLook at the images in your last link and look at the work of the following artists and you will see, just the rehash... Top Left: Gerhard Richter, Mark Bradford. Top Center: Beeple (Mike Winkelmann), or V0idhead Top Right: Wassily Kandinsky, László Moholy-Nagy Middle Left: Benjamin Von Wong Middle Center: Maurizio Cattelan Middle Right: Takashi Murakami, Hayao Miyazaki and so on....
- mindcandy 3y agoOK then. Your turn. Show me some humans that in the past four years have made new styles that you honestly cannot find references for in the same way.
- belter 3y agoShow me an LLM who can compose, paint, write after just going to school and without a large dataset. I am sure any Human could, even if never seen a painting before, or read literature or seen a famous musician. And 4 years is nothing in Art. If you look at Renaissance, Baroque, Rococo, Neoclassicism you got around 100 years between each and 50 years between Impressionism , Modern Art and so on. For Jazz, Blues Hip Hop its around 20 to 40 years. Maybe when LLMs have their own Cultural background they are ready to attack creativity :-)
- xandrius 3y agoI think you do not understand how "new" artstyles arise, it's extremely rare for something not to be influenced by something else. With AI I could merge an anime style with a hyper-realistic photo of a spider and see what style could come out. And if the AI doesn't quite work for this, I could get it to generate a base and one can then finish it up by hand.
- Animats 3y ago> But they are rehashing the content of somebody else. Asking to create a video of Michael Jackson dancing at the style of Fred Astaire with music similar to a Metallica song, is rehashing, not creativity. That's most real-world bands.
- belter 3y agoYes, but the point still remains. Most are inspired but once in a while you get The Beatles, Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, The Velvet Underground and so on. I guess we can use that to define when we achieve AGI. You mumble an input prompt and get a new Rolling Stones, U2 or Queen, a new Gabriel García Márquez or James Joyce. Currently if it's not in the Dataset then...404 Creativity Not Found
- tharmas 3y agoAI should be applied towards the mundane tedious tasks that people dont want to do or would rather not do. Example: cleaning public toilets. While this is more a robot thing it does require AI. AI is a tool. I feel its the attitude of the big players wielding those tools that is more the problem. Instead of applying AI to tedius unpleasant tasks they seem to want to go for the more creative tasks that we would classify as "The Arts". It seems the big players were applying AI to purely cut Labor costs.