6 ms·
To be very clear: not for transplants, but for training med students. > The students were told the removal of organs were part of autopsies required by law for
by ceejayoz 3y ago
To be very clear: not for transplants, but for training med students.
> The students were told the removal of organs were part of autopsies required by law for prisoners. They were told that using them for teaching future physicians “benefits future patients,” and if organs weren’t used they’d be thrown away and would serve no useful purpose.
- consumer451 3y agoBut money changes hands?
- soks86 3y agoMedical students can't be learning for free now.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIs there a line in the article I'm missing saying this?
- consumer451 3y agoI meant to ask the question, and phrased it poorly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hammock 3y ago"The prison system and UAB have an agreement for UAB to perform autopsies as an independent contractor. That agreement was filed as an exhibit in the new lawsuits. According to that document, the prison system pays $2,200 per autopsy and $100 per toxicology test. "According to the lawsuit, UAB Division of Autopsy publications from 2006 to 2015 show that 23% of their yearly income comes from Department of Corrections autopsies" https://www.al.com/news/2024/04/uab-stealing-dead-alabama-prison-inmates-organs-after-autopsies-families-claim-in-lawsuit.html#:~:text=The%20families%20of%20five%20men,week%20by%20three%20Alabama%20lawyers https://www.al.com/news/2024/04/uab-stealing-dead-alabama-pr....
- ceejayoz 3y agoThey'd be having the autopsies regardless. They're not the issue. > All people who die in custody have an autopsy, multiple prison officials testified in a federal court hearing earlier this year.
- g00gler 3y agoI’m not sure if $2,200 is a lot or a little but isn’t there some non-zero cost associated with facilitating, transporting, storing and performing the autopsies regardless of whether the examiner is paid or is a student? Eg clerical work, drivers, equipment, use of a vehicle, refrigerators, etc.
- hammock 3y agoThat's correct. I guess a benchmark we could use is $60, which is apparently what Planned Parenthood gets paid for the aborted fetuses that it gives away. Each fetus is reimbursable for reasonable costs incurred in the "transportation, implantation, processing, preservation, quality control, or storage of human fetal tissue." https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/planned-parenthood-fact-v-fiction https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/planned-parenthood-fact...
- ceejayoz 3y agoThat would be a very silly benchmark, as no one has to conduct an autopsy there. Autopsy pricing isn’t hard to find. https://www.etsu.edu/com/pathology/forensic-center/documents/etsu-private-autopsy-fee-schedule.pdf https://www.etsu.edu/com/pathology/forensic-center/documents... says $4k; https://www.hamiltoncounty.in.gov/Faq.aspx?QID=302 https://www.hamiltoncounty.in.gov/Faq.aspx?QID=302 says $2.5-5k.
- Jimmc414 3y agoThe argument that organs would be thrown away otherwise doesn’t justify bypassing clearly defined consent and ethical standards.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 3y agoI agree entirely; they're two separate things. Was this unethical? Yes. Is it the darkly hinted about conspiracy to procure black-market organs some will read into the headline? No.
- Jimmc414 3y agoYou'll need to point out this darkly hinted conspiracy in the headline. Nowhere is it implied that someone was killed for their organs. If this was happening at Johns Hopkins, it would certainly be a story. The fact that they are prisoners should be irrelevant.
- jeremycw 3y agoIt omits that the prisoners are deceased and uses the term "vanish" which implies it's not known where the organs have gone. "Alabama prisoners' organs vanish, and there's a whole lot of passing the buck" could easily be "Deceased prisoners' organs taken by University of Alabama against families wishes" but that's not going to get the clicks.
- alwa 3y agoAnd also to be clear, “vanish” from people who died in state custody, post-autopsy—not from people who are currently prisoners. And “vanish” to the same medical training uses as non-prisoners’ donated organs. The (very reasonable) question being whether it’s appropriate for the warden rather than the family to authorize the donation, when family is in the picture. The title seems to willfully invoke the far more sinister “organ-harvesting” trope that’s alarmingly a live issue in other carceral systems to this day [0], but that’s not what the article’s actual allegations describe. [0] e.g. https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2021/06/china-un-human-rights-experts-alarmed-organ-harvesting-allegations https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2021/06/china-un-hum...
- ziddoap 3y ago>The title seems to willfully invoke the far more sinister “organ-harvesting” No place on earth is more annoyingly finicky about headlines than HN. Black market organ harvesting of live prisoners didn't even cross my mind when reading this headline. What makes you think they are willfully invoking that trope? The use of "vanish"? Could you illustrate a better, but still concise, title?
- ceejayoz 3y ago"used after death without family consent to train medical students" is much more accurate than "vanish". Quite a few people hold conspiratorial opinions of organ transplantation, like that doctors won't work as hard to save people flagged as donors. https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health/in-depth/organ-donation/art-20047529 https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health...
- ziddoap 3y agoI believe that "Alabama prisoners' organs used after death without family consent to train medical students" exceeds HNs title character limit, and it also leaves out the fact that the blame for it is being shifted around -- an important component (arguably the most important component) of this story.
- fransje26 3y ago> To be very clear: not for transplants, but for training med students. And that is less worse because..?
- ceejayoz 3y agoBecause "we took organs to divert into the black market" and "we let the med students poke around during the routine autopsy for training" are very different things?
- segmondy 3y agoNever can be sure, plausibly deniability. If there was a trade going on were 5% were traded for transplants, it would be covered up that it's used for training med students.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThese are people who died in prison and were sent off-site for autopsy. Organ transplantation is… unlikely.
- servus45678981 3y agoBoth is unethical and criminal at the same time. Only because someone was accused of a crime, that doesn‘t give you the right to steal from their dead bodies like this