Would ask myself these questions: Can he actually stir trouble with the 5%? His initial stake was worth $50k. How much has the company value changed during hi

Would ask myself these questions: Can he actually stir trouble with the 5%? His initial stake was worth $50k. How much has the company value changed during his incompetence? Is there anything else that can motivate him (such as a “left by mutual agreement” clause)? How much would that be worth for you? Does the investor have any advice or can support? If you offer a lower amount than 50, will that hamper your next financing round? Can such a deal be made confidentially?