3 ms·
As you can imagine, a cloud of NIMBY is breaking out about this, and with no site picked, and elections in states and federal level this has about as much chanc
by ggm 3y ago
As you can imagine, a cloud of NIMBY is breaking out about this, and with no site picked, and elections in states and federal level this has about as much chance of coming to fruition in the next electoral cycle as Fusion power has of delivering power to the public networks.
I am not personally opposed to a dump. The income stream for what is basically passive income as rent would be astronomically beneficial to the location, and the economy. We have some obligation to take back the products of our uranium mining, and compared to other choices Australia is a good pick to store radionucleotides in. We're stable politically, economically, and geologically.
I would be entirely happy for the dump to be dug underneath my house. I live on a floodplain with acid sulphate soils but I imagine at some depth, there's a good structural basis to do it. There are probably far better locations.
it may be in AUKUS, but can I point out that the US has already refused to confirm if Australia will have sole control of the Virginia class subs we've been half-promised, nor has the promise been kept in any real sense because there is already a supply chain crisis behind the subs, we've paid the US to keep the factories alive, and we don't know what the AUKUS class will look like or who will actually make them or when.. yet.
This deal is half-baked, at best.
- defrost 3y ago> This deal is half-baked, at best. You're being generous. :-) To be clear I have no objection to the nuclear aspect if handly well, it's the entire debacle from start to end that's on the nose .. I don't accept the case for hugely expensive nuclear subs over the pre existing French order (which had other, albeit lesser, issues). In an entirely unrelated aside; see: https://www.crikey.com.au/2024/05/14/scott-morrison-memoir-review-plans-for-your-good/ https://www.crikey.com.au/2024/05/14/scott-morrison-memoir-r...
- XorNot 3y agoStrategically nuclear submarines are an excellent choice for Australia though - the problem is ScoMo was a terrible prime minister and I have no idea what the hell he was thinking with that surprise announcement and it's resultant costs. But it would make a lot of sense for Australia to get a fleet of ballistic-missile capable subs, put conventional warheads in them, but ensure they could become "nuclear capable" with a munition switch: these are 30+ year assets in most cases with long lead times. How comfortable we should feel about being under the US/NATO nuclear umbrella is a fluid thing over those timeframes.
- ggm 3y agoWe could have asked the French. Morrison tore up a strategic alliance outside of US and UK to meet a goal. The subs on order he cancelled were in effect de-nuclearised french designs. He shat on Macron for kudos.