3 ms·
> Gracemont is actually roughly equal to Golden Cove on integer workloads, and it's quite a bit smaller. If intel widened the FPU to 256bit, their "mont" cores
by toast0 3y ago
> Gracemont is actually roughly equal to Golden Cove on integer workloads, and it's quite a bit smaller. If intel widened the FPU to 256bit, their "mont" cores would probably get roughly equal IPC on FPU workloads too.
How much smaller would their 'core' cores be if they optimized them for a low max clock? Zen4c is roughly half the size and it's nearly the same as Zen4, just with a low max clock (and a tweaked cache)
- phire 3y agoYeah, that's a good question. However, I'm not sure the size comparison of Zen4c to Zen4 is very useful, because AMD didn't just optimise Zen4 for performance, they also optimised it for an earlier release date. My understanding is that AMD could have made Zen4 quite a bit smaller, but capable of the same clock speed, if they were willing to spent a lot more time and effort optimising for area. And while AMD has a reputation for not optimising their layout for area and relying on simpler floorpans and automated routing (at least until Zen4c), Intel has the opposite reputation of going overboard with their layout optimisations when they perhaps wen't needed. So the "cove" cores are probably already area optimised. The delta of a Golden Cove core optimised for a lower clock speed should be much lower than the 35.4% delta that AMD got for Zen4c.
- websg-x 3y agobecause area density is not the point, power efficiency is. That where zen4c gone wrong. https://www.anandtech.com/show/10025 https://www.anandtech.com/show/10025 The clustered instruction decoders is more scalable and power efficient than the coventional approach. The "mont" cores is just so much more interesting with much higher potentials.
- adrian_b 3y agoThat old link from 2016 has little relevance for the current microarchitectures. I have not seen yet any good benchmark comparing the energy efficiencies of the Crestmont cores from Meteor Lake (which are made with the new Intel 4 process) with any product containing Zen 4c cores, so which of them is more efficient is unknown for now. It is pretty certain that for any problem that can use AVX-512 or even 256-bit AVX, the Zen 4c cores will have significantly better energy efficiency than Crestmont. Only for integer workloads Crestmont might be more efficient, but even that is uncertain. Crestmont should consume less energy in its instruction-decoding frontend, but how efficient are its execution units is unknown. The older Gracemont cores had worse energy efficiency than Zen 4c, but they were handicapped by the inferior Intel 7 process, so that does not demonstrate anything about the relative merits of the Gracemont microarchitecture, had they been made in a competitive manufacturing process. Only after the launch of the Intel Sierra Forest server CPUs (expected in a few months), a direct comparison with AMD Bergamo will show whether Intel has succeeded to design a CPU core with better energy efficiency than Zen 4c.