4 ms·
If you like another language that's a bit like Haskell-but-more-practical, give OCaml a try. They even have a for-loop in OCaml!
by eru 3y ago
If you like another language that's a bit like Haskell-but-more-practical, give OCaml a try. They even have a for-loop in OCaml!
- habitue 3y agoThere's... forM_ in Haskell. that's basically a for loop, right?
- eru 3y agoYes, you can implement your own loops in Haskell and OCaml (and Scheme and even the GCC-variant of C). However, I meant specifically that OCaml is so 'pragmatic' that they have a for-loop as a built-in syntactic element in the language. They also have mutable variables built-in. In eg Haskell those are 'only' available as part of the standard library.
- habitue 3y agoSorry, bad attempt at humor. I knew what you meant, I was just poking fun at forM_ for being bizarre and unergonomic
- tome 3y agoWhat do you find bizarre and unergonomic about it?
- habitue 3y agoIf you're quite used to Haskell, it's nbd. If you're coming from another language with for loops and someone tells you it's a for loop, you might be surprised that you need to use $ and the loop variable comes after the sequence for x in range(10): print(x) forM_ [0..10] $ \x -> putStrLn x
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoI'm convinced the people who came up with Haskell syntax were on some sort of bath salts.
- nequo 3y agoThe reason it looks the way it does is that forM_ is just a function like any other, not a keyword in a dedicated syntactic construct.
- karmakurtisaani 3y agoYep, and then there's the $, \ and PutStrLn. As a non-Haskell programmer none of those mean anything to me.
- nequo 3y ago$ is short for “put everything to the right inside parentheses” and \x -> y defines an anonymous function. Why do you expect to understand the syntax of a language you never studied?
- karmakurtisaani 3y ago> $ is short for “put everything to the right inside parentheses” There's, you know, also the actual parentheses that everyone already knows. > Why do you expect to understand the syntax of a language you never studied? Because most languages have a syntax that you can grasp almost immediately, since they conform to a common syntax, rather than invent everything all over again. Then you can focus on the actual features of the language and are not bogged down by syntax.
- nequo 3y agoIt doesn't take more than two minutes to understand what $ and \x -> y do, and if you start writing out those parentheses, you will also realize why $ is part of idiomatic Haskell.