4 ms·
>This stuff feels magical. Magical. Sound like the people who defend Astrology because it feels magical how their horoscope fits their personality. "Don't bot
by croes 3y ago
>This stuff feels magical. Magical.
Sound like the people who defend Astrology because it feels magical how their horoscope fits their personality.
"Don't bother me with facts that destroy my rose-tinted view"
At moment AI is a massive hype and shoved into everything. To point at the faults and weaknesses is a reasonable and responsible thing to do.
- hsavit1 3y agoyea, we don't want or need this kind of "magic" - because it's hardly magic to begin with, and it's more socially and environmentally destructive than anything else.
- lannisterstark 3y agoSpeak for yourself, my workflow and live has been significantly improved with these things. Having easier access to information that I sorta know but want to verify/clarify rather than going into forums/SO is extremely handy. Not having to write boilerplate code itself also is very handy. So yes, I absolutely do want this "magic." "I don't like it so no one should use it" is a pretty narrow POV.
- oblio 3y agoBoth your use cases don't really lead to stable long term valuations in the trillions for the companies building this stuff.
- lannisterstark 3y agoWonderful. I don't need them to. It works for what I need it to do.
- oblio 3y agoYou should be worried because this stuff needs to make sense financially. Otherwise we'll be stuck with it in an enshittification cycle, kind of like Reddit or image hosting websites.
- lannisterstark 3y agoProblem is that by that time there would be open source models (the ones that already exist are getting good) that I can run locally. I honestly don't need _THAT_ much.
- oblio 3y agoFair enough, if we get there. The problem for this stuff, where do we get the data to get good quality results? I imagine everything decent will be super licensed within 5-10 years, when everyone wakes up.
- ewild 3y agopeople like you are the problem. the people who join a website cause it to be shitty, then leave and start the process at a new website. Reddit didnt become shit because of Reddit it became shit because of people going on there commenting as if they themselves are an LLM repeating enshittification over and over and trying to say the big buzzword first so they get to the top denying any real conversation.
- oblio 3y agoI've been on Reddit for more than a decade and I didn't make them create crappy mobile apps, crappy new web apps as well a policy of selling the data to anyone with a pulse. Do you even know what "enshittification" means? It has nothing to do with the users. It's driven by corporate greed. Reddit should be a public service managed by a non profit. Edit: Also LOL at the 6 month old account making that comment against me :-)
- helicalmix 3y agoi legitimately don't understand this viewpoint. 3 years ago, if you told me you could facetime with a robot, and they could describe the environment and have a "normal" conversation with me, i would be in disbelief, and assume that tech was a decade or two in the future. Even the stuff that was happening a 2 years ago felt unrealistic. astrology is giving vague predictions like "you will be happy today". GPT-4o is describing to you actual events in real time.
- demondemidi 3y agoMaybe you just haven't been around enough to seen the meta-analysis? I've been through four major tech hype cycles in 30+ years. This looks and smells like all the others.
- HelloMcFly 3y agoI'm 40ish, I'm in the tech industry, I'm online, I'm often an early adopter. What hype cycle does this smell like? Because it feels different to me, but maybe I'm not thinking broadly enough. If your answer is "the blockchain" or Metaverse then I know we're experiencing these things quite differently.
- threeseed 3y agoIt feels like the cloud. Where platforms and applications are rewritten to take advantage of it and it improves the baseline of capabilities that they offer. But the end user benefits are far more limited than predicted. And where the power and control is concentrated in the hands of a few mega corporations.
- whimsicalism 3y ago> the end user benefits are far more limited than predicted How have you judged the end user benefits of the cloud? I don't agree personally - the cloud has enabled most modern tech startups and all of those have been super beneficial to me.
- whimsicalism 3y ago> Sound like the people who defend Astrology because it feels magical how their horoscope fits their personality. Does it really or are you just playing facile word association games with the word "magical"?
- arisAlexis 3y agoWhat is the point of pointing faults that will be fixed very soon? Just being negative or unable to see the future?
- idopmstuff 3y agoAstrology is a thing with no substance whatsoever. It's just random, made-up stories. There is no possibility that it will ever develop into something that has substance. AI has a great deal of substance. It can draft documents. It can identify foods in a picture and give me a recipe that uses them. It can create songs, images and video. AI, of course, has a lot of flaws. It does some thing poorly, it does other things with bias, and it's not suitable for a huge number of use cases. To imply that something that has a great deal of substance but flaws alongside is the same as something that has no substance whatsoever nor ever will is just not a reasonable thing to do.
- dogcomplex 3y agoIf you want to talk facts, then those critics are similarly on weak grounds and critiquing feelings more than facts. There has been no actual sign of scaling ceasing to work, in medium after medium, and most of their criticisms are issues with how LLM tools are embedded in architectures which are still incredibly early/primitive and still refining how to use transformers effectively. We haven't even begun using error correction techniques from analog engineering disciplines properly to boost the signal of LLMs in practical settings. There is so much work to do with just the existing tools. "AI is massive hype and shoved into everything" has more grounding as a negative feeling of people being overwhelmed with technology than any basis in fact. The faults and weaknesses are buoyed by people trying to acknowledge your feelings than any real criticism of a technology that is changing faster than the faults and weakness arguments can be made. Study machine learning and come back with an informed criticism.