Judges don't enforce bad contracts. Imagine if a landlord sued a tenant after 1 year for a new roof of an apartment because the contract stated that "tenant wi

Judges don't enforce bad contracts. Imagine if a landlord sued a tenant after 1 year for a new roof of an apartment because the contract stated that "tenant will be responsible for all repairs" but the tenant pointed out that the contract also said "the house is in perfect and new condition". Both things cannot be true, so the judge throws it out. Same thing here, you can't grant someone a license to use something and then immediately say, "You can't use this without checking with us first" it is contradictory.