3 ms·
That listing of people seems pretty comprehensive. If that’s not the “whole world” it comes pretty close! And to be clear, us parents think that being “childfre
by rayiner 3y ago
That listing of people seems pretty comprehensive. If that’s not the “whole world” it comes pretty close! And to be clear, us parents think that being “childfree” is shallow and selfish, like being one of those sovereign citizens who doesn’t want to pay taxes. It’s basically being the ultimate hipster—thinking of oneself as being too special for something hominids have been doing for millions of years.
- gizmo 3y agoWhen people who don't want to be parents become parents out of obligation they tend to f up their kids.
- rayiner 3y agoThe idea that parenting makes a huge difference in kids is 20th century anti-Catholic propaganda perpetuated by WASPs. Outside the extremes, parenting doesn’t make much of a difference: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/04/parenting-anxiety-happiness-children/677960 https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/04/parenting-.... For the vast majority of people, biology will kick in and make them love and adequately raise their kids, regardless of their individual “wants.”
- loeg 3y agoI don't think that's true, or at least, overstates it. I think there are a lot of people who don't feel strongly about becoming parents that end up being great parents.
- silverquiet 3y agoThe selfish/selfless thing has never made much sense to me apropos of children; they seem to be about fulfilling some personal want. Is the woman who has 3 kids from 3 different dads being selfless? I've never heard anyone say they want to have kids to go onto work menial jobs and pay taxes; frankly that's my every day and I don't have much interest in inflicting it on some poor, unsuspecting child.
- rayiner 3y agoFor society to continue existing, which let’s say is axiomatically desirable, on average each person must reproduce themselves. Those kids, moreover, must be raised and socialized into the rules of the society, which requires labor. By having kids, therefore, you’re performing a function that enables society to keep existing. It’s a contribution to society in kind, similar to how taxes are a contribution to society in money. Someone who doesn’t play their part in that is selfish, in the same way as someone who doesn’t pay taxes or perform other obligations that enable society to exist.
- silverquiet 3y agoIf a society structures itself in such a way that no one wants (or is able) to continue it, then it will die and others may arise in its place. For myself I don't believe I have the wherewithal for it regardless of my view on the matter of selfishness. >The recent proliferation of studies examining cross-national variation in the association between parenthood and happiness reveal accumulating evidence of lower levels of happiness among parents than nonparents in most advanced industrialized societies. Conceptualizing parenting as a stressor buffered by institutional support, we hypothesize that parental status differences in happiness are smaller in countries providing more resources and support to families. Our analyses of the European Social Surveys (ESS) and International Social Survey Programme (ISSP) reveal considerable variation in the parenthood gap in happiness across countries, with the U.S. showing the largest disadvantage of parenthood. [0] [0]https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28082749/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28082749/
- rayiner 3y agoI agree with your first point. Societies that socialize people to prioritize individual “happiness” over fulfilling social obligations will die out and better societies will take their place.
- silverquiet 3y agoI don't think it's about happiness (scare quotes or otherwise), I think it's about avoiding ruin. In a society where you have to run as fast as you can to keep up, children will slow you down and you might end up consumed by the predators that surround you. That's why the line from the abstract "Conceptualizing parenting as a stressor buffered by institutional support" rings so true to me. The response to the above tends to be something like, it's not so bad, kids don't really need that much anyway. Which always leaves me with the question - how much money do you make? Could it be expressed as "several times the median US household income"?