5 ms·
This line of reasoning is fallacious. See the following graph: http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/human_vs_machine_progress.html http://www.chrisstucchio.c
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
This line of reasoning is fallacious. See the following graph:
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/human_vs_machine_progress.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/human_vs_machine_prog...
So far, we've invented whole new things to work on. There is no compelling reason to believe that will continue to happen.
Incidentally, that scenario hasn't always left biological entities better off. When technology reduced the wages for travel below the level of horse subsistence, the result was massive deaths among horses. But humans are special, right? That can't ever happen to us.
- lincolnq 14y agoI get the argument, although the blog you linked to seems broken right now (the graph doesn't show the data that he claims it to show). I agree: at some point we'll run out of things to employ humans doing. The big question for society is, what will happen when we reach that point? The relevant evidence is that humans care much more about the continued existence of other humans, to a much stronger degree than they do (in general) about horses. I am trying this thought experiment: Imagine a human in a position to decide whether to spend a lot of money on saving their horse. Imagine the same human now facing the same choice for saving their neighbor. The arguments are quite different, and it feels morally wrong to apply the economic argument to humans.
- georgemcbay 14y agoI think you're being a bit naive in assuming that when the massive and sustained unemployment (by today's definition) happens, wealthy people will be in a position to "save" their neighbors by throwing a few bucks their way. If we don't deal with this situation before it happens (and, IMO, this shift has already started though it'll be decades before it takes full shape) there will be bloody revolution to the point of societal collapse. Having a bank account with a lot of zeros in it won't count for much by then.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe graph shows machines already overtook horses and will eventually overtake humans (even if it hasn't happened yet). No data is graphed, it's just a schematic diagram (as is evidenced by the lack of axis labels). You are correct that humans may feel more charitable towards each other than towards horses. But the point is that mass unemployment is likely to occur and this will be a completely new phenomenon. I.e., we can't look at the past to predict the future.
- batista 14y ago>You are correct that humans may feel more charitable towards each other than towards horses. If History (and PETA) are any evidence, probably the opposite.
- tmoertel 14y agoThe fallacy here is that machines “replace” humans. They don’t. They can displace humans from jobs, but the humans don’t disappear. The humans still exist and can still do all the things humans can do, including find ways to create value that other humans are willing to pay for. Horses, however, cannot. When horses are displaced from their “jobs,” they don’t have the option of finding other ways to create value for humans. Any causal model that ignores this distinction between humans and other ‘biological entities,’ entities which just happen to play a supporting role in human society, is a model we can expect to make poor predictions about the future of humanity.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThere is a finite number of things to do which create value and which humans are willing to pay for (just as is the case with horses). The only difference is that N_human > N_horse. The fact that N_machine < N_human doesn't mean that N_machine will always be less than N_human. I'm only pointing out that it is a fallacy to claim that it is.
- tmoertel 14y agoIn human society, there are a practically unbounded number of things that humans can do that other humans would be willing to pay for. The same cannot be said for horses, which have zero ability in human society to find new ways to create value for humans and thereby for themselves. To use your notation, when N_horse slumps toward zero, no horse can do anything about it. But when N_human declines, the displaced humans can. Humans can increase their N, horses cannot.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIn human society, there are a practically unbounded number of things that humans can do that other humans would be willing to pay for. Could you explain this statement further? Why do you believe the number of things humans can do is best modeled as being infinite?
- 14y ago