4 ms·
Putting your Myers-Briggs personality type in your CV suggests to me that you probably believe in horoscopes, too. At the very least, you think it's relevant so
by peteretep 14y ago
Putting your Myers-Briggs personality type in your CV suggests to me that you probably believe in horoscopes, too. At the very least, you think it's relevant somehow and reflects positively on you (or why would you include it?). It's twee, self-indulgent, and pseudo-science - I want more from my developers.
- sitetechie 14y agoI think it's an accurate description of me, so thought it would help. I don't believe in horoscopes, of course, INTP's don't do pseudo-science ;-)
- mechanical_fish 14y agoThe problem with including the MBTI on your resume has nothing to do with its accuracy, precision, or scientific basis. It's about relevance. Flip the problem around: If your interviewer asked you for your MBTI type, would you think that was a good sign? Is that the kind of company that you want to work for, the kind that spends valuable interview time quizzing you about being an INTP? Let me venture to guess that the answer is "no". So why provide such detail? (If the answer is "but I would never want to work for someone who doesn't know, and care, that I identify as an INTP", then I withdraw my observation. Good luck to you.) My more general advice is: A resume isn't a dossier that summarizes one's entire life. You're not trying to adopt a child. You're trying to score a six-month gig. Focus, focus, focus.
- peteretep 14y agoYou put this much better than I did. The risk I see with hiring someone who lists their MBTI on their CV so prominently is that one day I'm going to ask them to do something, or work with someone, or communicate in a certain way about something, and they'll claim they can't or won't, based on that.
- sitetechie 14y ago> Flip the problem around: If your interviewer asked you for your MBTI type, would you think that was a good sign? No, that would not be a good sign, point taken, although I'm not sure it's that bad when you mention it as an applicant. The relevance for me was describing what kind of guy I think I am (somewhat of an introvert), but maybe I should downplay it or leave it out completely.
- casca 14y agoFor some reason, there's a popular myth that Myers-Briggs has any scientific basis. It doesn't. Please don't use it and thereby perpetuate this insult to the genuine social science research that is done.
- sitetechie 14y agoThanks, did not know I was insulting an entire industry with this. Will now seriously consider taking it out.
- Alex3917 14y agoThat's not entirely true, some of the factors and some of the profiles do have empirical backing. E.g. I think the INTP type has been found to underperform in school relative to IQ, and both introversion and extraversion have been validated as well.
- wamatt 14y agoMBTI and the MBTI test are two different things although often confused as one. If you want to be scientific, then a more accurate statement is: The MBTI test, may have weak validity and precision across all it's dichotomies. Albeit even this matter seems to be contended. "CPP Inc., the publisher of the MBTI instrument, calls it "the world's most widely used personality assessment",with as many as two million assessments administered annually. The CPP and other proponents state that the indicator meets or exceeds the reliability of other psychological instruments and cite reports of individual behavior. Some studies have found strong support for construct validity, internal consistency, and test-retest reliability, although variation was observed. However, some academic psychologists have criticized the MBTI instrument, claiming that it "lacks convincing validity data". Some studies have shown the statistical validity and reliability to be low. The use of the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator as a predictor of job success has not been supported in studies,[15][16] and its use for this purpose is expressly discouraged in the Manual.[17]" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers-Briggs_Type_Indicator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers-Briggs_Type_Indicator
- wamatt 14y agoWow, it's great to be so confident. You must be correct then. /sarcasm If you dig a little deeper into the foundation of analytical psychology, you might be surprised. Carl Jung popularized the terms Extravert and Introvert, and there have been at least 2 studies (that I know of) in neuroscience showing that dichotomy to exist, physically in the brain. I'm hyperrational, started 2 successful companies, majored in CS, atheist, don't believe in horoscopes, or any bullshit for that matter, but do believe not all brains process information in the same way. Now to say the MBTI test does not have some validity issues, would be delusional. But on the other hand, only an arrogant fool, would conclude that therefore there is a fundamental problem with the theory. For example, if I construct a test that asks 500 people (assuming highly randomized sample) if they like sugar. And 250 people say "yes". One cannot conclude 50% of people like sugar. The best you can hope to conclude is that 50% of people, self report as "liking sugar". So what this means is that the test makes some flawed assumptions: eg 1. people are honest (consciously and/or subconsciously) 2. people know themselves enough, to give accurate responses There may be more, but those appear to be the major flaws accounting for validity and reliability issues (engineering synonyms are, accuracy and precision). It is also plausible, that these challenges are not insurmountable.
- knowtheory 14y agoIt's not like myers-briggs is administered under anything resembling controlled conditions. It really is useless except for self-identifying that you like the myers-briggs categorization scheme and which of the 16 boxes you think that you are in. Also, if you're going to cite scientific studies to rebut someone else's point, it goes much further to making your case when you actually dig up references or links to them.
- wamatt 14y agoWow you really didn't get the entire point I was making then. The test in it's current form, has significant issues. But the test != the theory.
- wamatt 14y agoHere is another: Neuroanatomical Correlates of Extraversion and Neuroticism Christopher I. Wright, Danielle Williams1 et al, Oxford JournalsLife Sciences & Medicine Cerebral Cortex (2006) http://cercor.oxfordjournals.org/content/16/12/1809.full http://cercor.oxfordjournals.org/content/16/12/1809.full If you're interested, perhaps a good place to start is Carl Jung's Psychological Types (1921), here it's in my dropbox. I had it digitized into electronic form https://www.dropbox.com/s/hrf6whb66fbmaux/Psychological%20Types.pdf https://www.dropbox.com/s/hrf6whb66fbmaux/Psychological%20Ty... Many very intelligent, rational people believe introverts and extroverts exists in the population. Here is a great talk by Susan Cain on introverts http://www.ted.com/talks/susan_cain_the_power_of_introverts.html http://www.ted.com/talks/susan_cain_the_power_of_introverts.... Look forward to further discussion...
- raquo 14y agoMB is not magic. It does not produce new information out of thin air like horoscopes. You give it your psychological traits in pretty much clear text, and all it does is reduce these to a few categories. Strictly scientific? Probably not. But neither are a lot of useful things in psychology. Anecdotally accurate? Check. Has a reasonable model? Check. Works for me. I know, there's probably a crazy cult about MB somewhere, but such things are around pretty much anything remotely interesting.
- peteretep 14y ago> Anecdotally accurate? Check. Has a reasonable model? Check. To the former part: horoscopes are also anecdotally accurate, and hence the comparison. Good horoscopes and other forms of cold reading are specifically designed to offer people given situations they can relate to: "sometimes you feel like you're the life and soul of the party, but it's interesting, because you represent a contradiction - there are times when really you just want to be alone" (source: I just made that up)... Compare and contrast to: "As an INTP, your primary mode of living is focused internally, where you deal with things rationally and logically. Your secondary mode is external, where you take things in primarily via your intuition." (source: first line of first result for INTP on Google) You mean ... INTPs are sometimes rational and logic, and sometimes intuitive? ;-) To the latter part: the model is a big part of the problem. It polarizes personality traits that are necessarily context-dependent, mood-influenced, and exist on a scale in to binary Yes/No. If you're not Introverted, you're Extraverted. Not: "you're in the middle, and occasionally tend to one or the other" - simply: "you are x".
- tokenadult 14y agoPutting your Myers-Briggs personality type in your CV suggests to me that you probably believe in horoscopes, too. That was harshly said, but the OP appeared to be looking for constructive criticism, so that comment is warranted. The unvalidated Myers-Briggs Type Indicator® is no more useful to employers than horoscopes, and likely to expose employers who use it to legal liability. Here are some standard references on the subject: http://www.skepdic.com/myersb.html http://www.skepdic.com/myersb.html http://www.psychometric-success.com/personality-tests/personality-tests-popular-tests.htm http://www.psychometric-success.com/personality-tests/person... "Overall, the review committee concluded that the MBTI has not demonstrated adequate validity although its popularity and use has been steadily increasing. The National Academy of Sciences review committee concluded that: ‘at this time, there is not sufficient, well-designed research to justify the use of the MBTI in career counseling programs’, the very thing that it is most often used for." http://www.indiana.edu/~jobtalk/HRMWebsite/hrm/articles/develop/mbti.pdf http://www.indiana.edu/~jobtalk/HRMWebsite/hrm/articles/deve... http://www.amazon.com/Cult-Personality-Testing-Miseducate-Misunderstand/dp/0743280725/ http://www.amazon.com/Cult-Personality-Testing-Miseducate-Mi...
- mattmorgan 14y agoSpeaking on Myers-Brigg. One thing I am realizing is that they put ISTJs/ESTJs in the interviewer seat. Your liked minded INTPs are all developing, not interviewing. They don't find certain fluffy things as impressive. They like concrete, palpable information. That's why you have to take it off to increase your chances...you'll be with your other INTPs after your hired...just have to make it through those SJs...