4 ms·
Is dark matter's main rival theory dead?
- Gunax 3y agoMy very casual understanding is that Mond really has been mostly discarded. The article says it's 'in trouble'. We see some galaxies whose gravity is near the baryonic prediction and others where it is not. - explaining this with dark matter is easy: some galaxies have a lot of dark matter and some have little. - explaining this with Mond seems impossible. If there is some gravity law we don't understand, how can it have different effects on different galaxies? - how do we explain the famous bullet cluster finding?
- User23 3y ago> - explaining this with dark matter is easy Well, attributing it to dark matter is easy. It's not really explaining anything though, until you can say what dark matter is and why it's there. At this point it's basically just an abstract parameter that we assume, without any direct evidence, is in fact some kind of matter and not, well, something else. Maybe spacetime just have different geometry in different places? Maybe the assumption that it would be flat in the absence of matter is wrong? It could very well be that the neutral shape of spacetime in some places is more or less curved than we currently assume. Then there are fun ideas like large masses permanently deforming spacetime. Going with the famous rubber mat analogy, what if the mat gets permanently stretched and even once the mass that stretched it is dispersed the sag remains? That's of course assuming there even is such a thing as spacetime. Which, btw, sounds like a reasonable assumption. However, just because the math works doesn't mean it's a physical reality, it merely points to it.
- ffhhj 3y agoNice theory! That would help explain the Great Attractor. The Universe could actually be a deformed blob of spacetime and the Big Bang and its development just happens to be the result of this blob's movements. There are rogue blackholes, maybe they leave spacetime deformations behind them that could be observed?
- User23 3y agoI wouldn’t expect to find any “empty” spacetime deformations, since by their very nature they would attract matter. I would however expect more gravity than the presently observable matter could explain. I wonder if that can explain some of the large scale filament type structures we see.
- wruza 3y agoIsn't all that the same idea? If you ignore nomenclature and interpretations, DM basically says there's "a thing", opposed to "a law". Like actual trees vs aerodynamics. "There's trees" doesn't explain anything either, but if there's no trees and spacetime just remembers something, that is a thing as well, not a law. Just dark. A thing is a memory of spacetime.
- XorNot 3y agoThe analogies literally don't matter though. If it behaves "matter-like" enough, then it's matter. We generally regard this to mean entities which can have an independent momentum and position. Hence: dark matter - because the effect we observe seems to behave that way. MOND is distinct because it declares what we're seeing is not a bunch of entities with that character. It's worth noting we also talk about a lot of things like this even though strictly speaking they're not: i.e. electron-holes in semiconductors can be perfectly well modeled as their own form of matter - they can't just leave the semiconductor environment. But they do have momentum and position. Dark matter could literally be the same type of effect, but if you're a wrinkle in space-time then it doesn't matter unless that description has some sort of experimental reality, and we currently do not observe it to do so. It is not like physicists would not rush to test any experimental formulation of dark matter as such that was accessible with current or near-future instruments.
- hi-v-rocknroll 3y ago> It's not really explaining anything though, That's the problem. It lumps unexplained phenomena into a luminiferous aether 2.0. The most likely explanation is our model of gravity isn't yet good enough and so perhaps RelMOND is worth a look.
- mkl 3y agoI (not a physicist) had the impression that it was mostly discarded too. This article from 2022 seems to contradict that: https://theconversation.com/dark-matter-our-review-suggests-its-time-to-ditch-it-in-favour-of-a-new-theory-of-gravity-186344 https://theconversation.com/dark-matter-our-review-suggests-... It doesn't mention the Bullet Cluster though.
- beezle 3y agoThere is at least one MOND that is still kicking around not affected by recent observations. MOG I think its called.
- mhh__ 3y agoWas it ever seriously alive?
- chefkd 3y agocan CERN create dark matter in particle accelerators? how do people go about reasoning about it if it can't be created on earth
- jfengel 3y agoProbably not. There were hopes that dark matter might arise from supersymmetry, and that if so the LHC might be able to create it. Thus far they haven't found it, which is a big strike against supersymmetry, as well as a loss of an avenue for exploring dark matter. So back to the drawing board. At that drawing board, they have other tools to look at. Often, they're astronomical and cosmological. One big clue is the "Bullet Cluster", where two galaxies collided, and the regular mass smashed into each other but the dark matter kept going. And they can look at the distribution of the Cosmic Microwave Background, which would show the influence of early dark matter. Using that they know that dark matter must be "cold", i.e. not moving near the speed of light. So it must be fairly heavy -- heavier than neutrinos, at least, another particle that's maddeningly hard to detect. (They do have neutrino detectors that also hope to spot a dark matter collision event, but it's unlikely.) If supersymmetry doesn't cut it, they'll need a new way to fix other problems with the Standard Model. Those would hopefully predict another dark-matter-like particle (massive, weakly interacting), which in turn would point in the direction of a detector. But there aren't any front-runners at the moment.
- thezipcreator 3y agoDark matter is more of an observation than a theory. The gravitational motions of galaxies doesn't really make sense without it (and with dark matter + General Relativity, it fits perfectly, so we have good reason to believe it exists). There are a few different theories on what dark matter is; there's axions, supersymmetry (from string theory), cold dark matter and more.
- number6 3y agoDark Matter is not the same as antimatter, which CERN did produce. There are speculations if there are antimatter galaxies out there and that they are in fact the dark Matter that we search for. But dark matter is in essence matter that should be there, e.g. because a solar system behaves like it is in its gravitational field, but cannot be detected by our instruments. Maybe it is a flaw in our theory, like the time we found out that newtons physic has some flaws, or we can't detect it because it is made of stuff that we can't measure yet.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Protostome 3y agoStrange they didn't mention in this article that the discrepencies in the galactic rotation curves can actually be explained without any novel physics or particles ("dark matter"): https://www.mdpi.com/2075-4434/9/2/34 https://www.mdpi.com/2075-4434/9/2/34
- amai 3y agoThis paper is very weird. They basically assume we are rotating with respect to the center of a galaxy and that is why the see different rotational velocity compared to when we would not be in a rotating frame. This could be the case for a single galaxy. But how can we be in a rotating frame towards the center of all galaxies? That doesn't make sense to me. So the math would be correct for a single galaxy, but this cannot happen for all galaxies at the same time. What is interesting though, that they basically find a model with a single additional parameter per galaxy (angular velocity omega) that fits most of the rotation curves very well. However the most simple explanation how we get this omega is not by assuming fictitious forces from rotation frames, but simply real forces from dark matter.
- Protostome 2y agoSo, actually the paper isn't saying that we are all spinning in sync with the center of every galaxy out there. What it's really getting at is that each galaxy might be spinning or moving in its own special way because of the specific gravitational forces acting on it locally.
- ynniv 3y agoIt isn't surprising to me because the standard of journalism seems to be one of "debunking". In this approach you start with something that you don't like, in this case Mond, something you do like, usually the status quo, and then throw a bunch of pasta at the wall in the hope that something will stick with the reader. There is usually little to no attempt at an honest review, only a biased statement salad. It's pretty depressing, but I guess it sells ads and doesn't bother the establishment.
- lostmsu 3y ago