4 ms·
Consciousness doesn't really exists, it is just an illusion. It is both scary and amusing to me that there are entire (expensive) conferences dedicated to some
by Tichy 18y ago
Consciousness doesn't really exists, it is just an illusion.
It is both scary and amusing to me that there are entire (expensive) conferences dedicated to something the participants can't even give a definition for.
- yan 18y agoI have very similar feelings toward "web 2.0" conferences.
- Tichy 18y agoBut at least for Web 2.0 it is possible to give a definition of what it is supposed to be. I have yet to see such a thing for consciousness.
- tocomment 18y agoIf it's an illusion, who is it illusioning?
- Tichy 18y agopeople?
- yters 18y agoWhy do people find the "illusion" response helpful? "How do Newtonian physics, quantum physics, and relativity work together? Don't worry about it, the physical world is just an illusion, and illusions aren't rational."
- rodrigo 18y agoConceptually, its an illusion in the sense that theres "something" doin interpretation between the "real" things and our brain; in the zen koan of the tree that fells, it migth not be doing any sound because theres no brain processing the wave and telling someone that a tree falled.
- Tichy 18y agoWhat I mean by "consciousness is an illusion" is that consciousness does not exist. It is a non issue. Again in this thread as in any other discussion on consciousness, nobody has given a definition of consciousness. There is nothing meaningful to talk about. On the other hand, the physical world exists, or at least out perception of it exists. You might say that you also perceive consciousness, but honestly, what is it you perceive? I don't think it is the same as perceptions of physical things.
- rodrigo 18y agoWhat do you mean by consciousness does not exist? How do you define consciusness? you have to have a definition so you can deny it.
- Tichy 18y agoWell the whole discussion is rather useless then, isn't it? Perhaps we should discuss the Spaghetti Monster instead?
- yters 18y agoDo you have to define red to discuss it?
- rodrigo 18y agoIt migth help.
- yters 18y agoDefinitely, but the point I'm getting at is that there are loads of things we discuss without having to define them. Especially the basic terms of whatever you happen to be defining. I.e. do I need to define the words I use in this question for you to understand what I am asking?
- 18y ago
- mrtron 18y agoI don't think the world is an illusion - but rather our perception of the world is. We only see a very limited spectrum of light, but we don't realize the massive gaps we cannot see. All of our senses are a tiny pinhole into the world, and we base our reality on them. Our sense of smell is a fraction of other mammals, we really don't notice that a dog could be smelling 20 things in a room that we don't notice. Not that we really have any other option, but I am just trying to explain the 'illusion' of it.
- Tichy 18y agoAnother way to put it: if you ask "how can we build a bridge", I am not going to respond by saying "the physical world is an illusion, so building bridges is useless". On the other hand, if you ask "how can we build a conscious entity", I will say the question is meaningless. If you ask instead "how can we build an entity that can have a discussion on Hacker News", we have something to talk about.