14 ms·
Dumb rules prevent Silicon Valley from building needed houses and offices
- medusa666 14y agoGoogle "urban planning." The "dumb rules" may not be convenient for you or me in the short run, but they exist for a reason: water, sewage, traffic, pollution, supporting a sustainable quality of living for the long term. I don't have the answer - and I notice that you don't really offer one - but I know that the answer is not to throw out all our laws in a short-sighted imitation of some polluted Chinese metropolis.
- jseliger 14y agothey exist for a reason: water, sewage, traffic, pollution Not really. See Edward Glaeser's The Triumph of the City, Matt Yglesias's The Rent is Too Damn High, and Ryan Avent's The Gated City for more; pay particularly close attention to the sections about how urban life tends to be far more sustainable than alternatives.
- steventruong 14y agoI got these books simply because of this recommendation. Will check them out, thanks.
- jseliger 14y agoYou're welcome! They're all impressively researched while being relatively easy to read. If you want to add one more, Tom Vanderbilt's Traffic is good too. As all four books point out, there's basically no intellectual case to be made in favor of low height limits, strict parking requirements, and lot setbacks in urban or heavily urbanizing places. The only "case", such as it is, comes from NIMBYism and existing landlords or landowners who are seeking to nominally protect their perceived investment.
- medusa666 14y agoHey, I (much) prefer urban life. Starting from the ground up, I wish they'd built Palo Alto and Menlo Park to be real cities. I wish I lived in a city with a real subway, and the people density to support it. And women. But all that's not the same thing as adding skyscrapers today's mid-Peninsula. Most of these responses are coming from an idealistic blank-sheet mindset. In the real world, we don't have the option to start from scratch.
- otterley 14y agoThere are plenty of examples of cities that are prosperous, clean, and not stifled by pollution: Montreal, London, Paris, Zurich, Munich, Berlin, Vienna, and Sydney to name a few.
- zalew 14y agoMunich is the most polluted German city, also, fun fact, city with the slowest average speed in EU (at least some time ago) because of traffic jams.
- maurits 14y agoZurich (and Geneve for that matter) consistently lead the list for the most expensive places on earth to live in not to mention that it is damn near impossible to find a place to live. Geneve's rental market currently has less than 2 promille vacancies.
- shin_lao 14y agoAll of these cities you list are actually stifled by pollution and are (very) far from being clean. I happen to live in one of those and visit regularly others in the list. The problem is far from being solved. However, it's true that the pollution per inhabitant is much lower than in the Silicon Valley.
- thrownaway2424 14y agoYou must be crazy. You can lick the sidewalks in Zurich, although you'd probably be arrested. It's certainly the cleanest major city I've seen. And the tram come every minute.
- enko 14y agoThat's either a pretty silly troll or you haven't travelled much outside of affluent Western Europe. I've also been to most of those cities and can only say, if you think they're "stifled by pollution" then your first 10 minutes in Beijing are going to be rather eye-opening (or is that eye-watering).
- tge789 14y agoGoogle "Europe".
- shin_lao 14y agoNo silver bullet, however with high density it's possible to find solutions for traffic and sewage more easily. For water, the problem is the same.
- ChrisLTD 14y agoIt's not a binary situation. There is a medium between the high rises of Manhattan and the large single family homes of the suburbs. More to your point, dense cities can be much more sustainable than suburbs. Money spent on infrastructure benefits more people. People living in apartment buildings use less energy for heating and cooling. Commuting doesn't necessarily require a car so you use less fossil fuels.
- gibsonf1 14y agoActually, they are "dumb" rules designed to create suburban sprawl. There is a new movement to create pedestrian friendly neighborhoods with higher density at transit nodes: SmartCode. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SmartCode http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SmartCode
- phamilton 14y agoThey compare the growth in Detroit as though Silicon Valley were missing out. I for one wouldn't live in Detroit today.
- jakozaur 14y agoMaybe instead of getting rid of rules, lets find a better ones?
- ianrandall 14y agoI live in Sydney & for a city of over 4.6 million people, most residents would consider it a great place to live, with great entertainment & night life, good public transport, low unemployment, good schools & recreation facilities. That being said we also have a housing rental shortage that keeps rents high, some pollution problems, seriously bad crime statistics and horrendous traffic conjestion in many parts of the city. Australia is one of the most urbanized countries in the world and like Canada most of our population lives in a narrow 100km band (in our case from the coast). Most parts of the world are livable if you find your urban village. If you are not in a village the lifestyle is crap, if you are in the village, life is great.
- narrator 14y agoThe anti-growth stuff is so that when the inevitable bust comes the whole place doesn't clear out and turn into Detroit. Las Vegas is a great recent example of too much over-optimistic growth being followed by a devastating bust and urban decay.
- woodpanel 14y agoSure, the Valley won't Detroit-enize. But that doesn't mean that decay isn't at work already. Zoning like that mentioned in the article leads to 1) urban sprawl, which means 2) more land being used inefficently (wasted) and 3) more hours of life commuting (wasted), which leads to 4) more need for cars, leading to 5) more hours in congestion (wasted) 6) poorer people getting the worst of those points above, making 7) building public transport even more political feasable, while 8) public transport is the least efficient in low-density areas (wasted) One could say that the decay of Detroit is at least contained in terms of space. Also, just because a bust is to be expected, it doesn't mean that people should be deprived of Jobs that never come to existance due to handicapped growth.
- roc 14y agoThe emptying out of Detroit is contained almost entirely within the low-density residential neighborhoods. The downtown area stubbornly clings on in large part because density makes it easier to serve with new business and core infrastructure. Low density is what made the emptying so contagious and the costs so unsustainable. Low density requires continual growth to pay for the long utility runs and the long service routes for everything from busses to police patrols to trash pickup. And because service erodes as buildings empty, more buildings empty. And when the remaining 20 or 30% of your population is scattered, it's very hard to introduce new businesses or retrench old ones to serve them. The erosion is almost impossible to contain without Flint-style abandoning of large swaths of area and relocation programs for anyone who remains. (Detroit has been trying similar, but it's expensive and slow.) I don't know much about SF and the valley and I'll refrain from commenting there. But you guys know demonstrably nothing about Detroit and you may want to follow the example.
- jandrewrogers 14y agoMost areas of Silicon Valley are militantly opposed to anything that looks like high-density construction. The government won't issue permits. The unsurprising result is that it has a really bad case of suburban sprawl, constrained by geological boundaries. Unfortunately, this means that even if you don't want to live in suburban sprawl and commute a long distance, it is pretty much mandatory in Silicon Valley because the city planners have essentially outlawed all other arrangements. The insanity runs deeper when matched to their obsession with having more people use public transit. Public transit doesn't work in a low-density suburb larger than some states in New England. In typical fashion, the left-hand bans all development that would allow public transit to be usable and the right-hand insists that people should stop driving and take public transit. This is just one example; Silicon Valley is full of fundamentally inconsistent bureaucratic mandates. This is one of those classic denial-of-reality cases that give Americans their famously low opinion of government. In some cases, it is entrenched special interests demanding these things; the sum of these policies may be insane but the politicians do not care as long as the special interests are happy.
- rwmj 14y agoIsn't this, in fact, democracy at work? The older people who already live there, and vote in greater numbers than the young, don't want the development, and the politicians merely reflect that.
- sneak 14y ago> This is one of those classic denial-of-reality cases that give Americans their famously low opinion of government. I regret that I have but one upvote to give to this amazingly focused and insightful comment you've written.
- mahyarm 14y agoI too agree. I finally understood when I moved here why americans have a streak in them that dislikes government. It's because theirs can be so bad and huge sometimes.
- beachgeek 14y ago
- lisper 14y agoThese "dumb rules" are one of the main reasons that, by some people's quality metric, the Valley is such a great place to live (if you can afford it, of course). Oakland, San Jose (at least the downtown area), and San Francisco all have pretty high density. Some people like cities, but I think most people would prefer, all else being equal, to live in Portola Valley or Woodside.
- quatrevingts 14y agoLow density suburbia is what makes the Valley appealing? You can get that anywhere in America for a fraction of the price. What distinguishes the Valley is obviously its status as a tech hub. And most people may prefer to live in a mansion on the hills, surrounded by other rich people, just like most people would like to live in the Hearst Castle. But back in reality, people are choosing between a 1000 sq.ft. million dollar house in the Valley, and an hour long commute to something more affordable. The people who like the status quo are frequently those who bought a house in the 90's or earlier and saw a 500% return on their 10x leveraged investment, and don't want to see that price drop even a little. But even they complain about traffic.
- underwater 14y agoBeing a nice place to live is a luxury that the rich enjoy and everyone else suffers for. Silicon Valley is the biggest tech hub in the world and home to billions of dollars worth of industry. Zoning should reflect that, rather than the whims of the lucky few who can afford to buy into the current inflated market.
- jseliger 14y agoby some people's quality metric, the Valley is such a great place to live And, by other people's, it's a terrible place to live because you have to drive everywhere. As "The Soul of the Commuter" describes, driving makes people unhappier in almost every possible way: more socially isolated, fatter, and less connected to their communities: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/04/16/070416fa_fact_paumgarten?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/04/16/070416fa_fact_... .
- unim 14y agoHere's a smart idea : Build homes and offices elsewhere in the U.S. I never understood the constant swimming against the tide in the Valley. Expand elsewhere... It's becoming uncomfortable and unreasonable for a great deal of people. On a grand scale this is bad for the U.S : > More expensive to hire people here > More concentration of wealth ... > Wealth gets pissed away into the inflated shoebox called Silicon Valley. Think outside the box .. but the nature of the valley is that everyone thinks inside it .. Go figure. After some observations, A visiting friend commented : You have some of the highest paid/intelligent people in the U.S located here yet they live no better than the garbage man in other states... I don't know if this is incredibly stupid or smart.
- sneak 14y agos/elsewhere in the U\.S\./elsewhere/; All of the good places to live in the USA are balls-expensive, because there aren't very many of them. Berlin's great this time of year.
- michaelochurch 14y agoAll of the good places to live in the USA are balls-expensive, because there aren't very many of them. The Upper Midwest (Chicago, Madison, Minneapolis, Ann Arbor) is great if you can get an interesting job there. The weather isn't as bad as it sounds and the cities themselves are beautiful (although I wouldn't recommend most of the suburbs).
- mattdeboard 14y agoYou have a funny definition of "isn't as bad as it sounds." I live in Indianapolis and that's about as close to Chicago and all points north as I wish to go during the winter.
- sneak 14y agoAnn Arbor has absolutely no nightlife that doesn't involve young kids and drinking too much. Chicago's bar and club scene is full of the hyper-douches that (for the most part) weren't smart enough to make it to the coasts. And almost every major urban center in the US requires a car to live. I grew up in Detroit and spent a lot of time traveling and working around the midwest, and those kinds of places are exactly what I envision when I think of unlivable American cities. They simply don't have the density to support the kind of scenes that make living in a city fun. Chicago is borderline, but the car thing and the snow thing totally ruin it. The parts of the city that are close to anything fun are expensive to live in. Fact is, any state with a default 2AM bar/club time is at a severe disadvantage. I think the list for the US at the moment is NYC, SF, and perhaps maybe Seattle or Portland - but I haven't been to the northwest so I can't comment directly.
- gavanwoolery 14y agoI suspect I'll be down-voted for saying it, but Silicon Valley does not need housing or offices. People need to move out of SV. Software can be done from anywhere...why bother doing it in an undesirable area? Everything in the Bay Area is overpriced, and most of it is pretty boring. SF certainly is not boring, but it has also turned into a dump (was way cleaner when I was a kid, not sure what happened). And yes, there are VCs outside of SV, believe it or not -- not that proximity to VCs should be a deciding factor of where to base your company. (For the record, I grew up in the Bay Area, if it matters.)
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoEdward Glaeser explores this phenomenon in some depth in his recent book Triumph of the City. Over time, cities that refuse to let the market meet the demand for affordable housing through height/density limits and so on tend to transition from dynamic engines of economic development into exclusive boutiques for the very wealthy.
- msellout 14y agoNot the most scientific of books, btw.
- crististm 14y agoI don't know about dumb rules but (for a change) he should come and see some properties in my area with practically no space between buildings. However, 30% of a lot seems small for a high density area.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]