9 ms·
Polestar eliminates the rear window in latest electric car
- rbirkby 3y agoSat in the rear, it feels claustrophobic. I’m told they will solve that with extra daylight lighting installed behind the rear headrests.
- gherkinnn 3y agoExtra daylight lighting? I love it when problems that should not be are so highly engineered.
- surfingdino 3y agoOr, they could "solve" it by installing extra screens on the walls showing ads for package holidays. Of course, that would raise the temperature inside, but it's something that could be solved with extra AC, which would need large batteries and more frequent stops, but that could be solved by... seems to be the way of "innovation" these days, we no longer fix what's broken, but break what works and charge extra for it.
- nozzlegear 3y agoAre you inventing dystopian scenarios just so you can be angry, or do you have access to Polestar's internal plans?
- beretguy 3y agoThere’s no need to invent anything. We are already living in dystopia.
- nozzlegear 3y agoMaybe you are, I put my phone down every now and then though and choose to “touch grass” as the kids say. Things aren’t so bad.
- beretguy 3y agoMaybe I am? You enjoy being snarky?
- nozzlegear 3y agoJust pointing out that while you apparently feel you're living in a dystopia, I don't feel the same. Things aren't perfect but they're definitely not dystopian from my point of view. And come on, who doesn't enjoy being snarky now and then?
- talldayo 3y agoIt could be that you actually do live in dystopia, and lack the willpower or observational acumen to acknowledge it.
- nozzlegear 3y agoAnd it could be that you don’t live in dystopia, but lack the willpower or observational acumen to acknowledge it. Perhaps instead of slinging weak insults and complaining about dystopian life, you should go do something about it?
- talldayo 3y agoNeither of us know anything about how the other lives. It's entirely plausible that either of us could be in total denial of our surroundings (which is a recurring personality in the VC/entrepreneurial sphere).
- nozzlegear 3y agoThen I have to question why you wrote the message you did in the first place, because it’s hard not to take it as an insult from a random passerby.
- beretguy 3y ago
- surfingdino 3y agoI am not angry, I just observe trends that started with the realisation that raw materials can be sold for more if they are transformed into products. The unbound inventiveness of the human race never ceases to amaze me, but I also see how some of it develops along paths that result in solutions which are overly complex and require even more complex solutions to "fix" them.
- rvnx 3y agoActually these are more likely plans of Tesla to bring new revenues; ads displayed inside the cars.
- surfingdino 3y agoNot inside, but on the outside, remotely-delivered ads are now being displayed on food delivery scooters https://www.sixteen-nine.net/2022/08/03/london-dooh-start-up-touts-ads-that-deliver-with-screens-on-commercial-e-scooters/ https://www.sixteen-nine.net/2022/08/03/london-dooh-start-up... Another use of ad displays was seen in London around Christmas https://www.newsflare.com/video/606086/eros-in-piccadilly-circus-covered-with-hoarding-and-screens-to-prevent-people-from-climbing https://www.newsflare.com/video/606086/eros-in-piccadilly-ci... It was monetisation of denial of physical access. Clever.
- rvnx 3y agoClever, you are hired!
- chgs 3y agoAll large companies and cartels eventually bow to pressure. “If you don’t bombard your customers with adverts then you are leaving money on the table”
- Maken 3y agoDo you realise Uber and Lyft are already doing this, right?
- nozzlegear 3y agoActually no, I don’t, I’ve never used Uber or Lyft.
- NoPicklez 3y agoWhilst it feels strange initially and I caught myself thinking why? Most car reverse cameras for 360 degree cameras provide very good visibility outside of the rear of the car. I don't necessarily see the problem with having a rear windscreen, but that's up to the buyer
- troupo 3y agoApart from dirt, rain, snow, sleet, dust... mechanical and electrical failures, software errors...
- erulabs 3y agoRecessed with hydrophobic cover, heater element, mechanical redundancy (or better, zero moving parts), electronic redundancy, and software testing. Solved! These are all entire industries that already power society-vital functions. Embrace it!
- kpmcc 3y agoSo much complexity to do the same thing as a mirror and a window…
- bonton89 3y agoAnd 10 years from now when it fails it will be a $1200 repair.
- erulabs 3y agoSure - but as the article points out there are safety and efficiency wins by removing the rear window. Anyways if it’s a terrible decision I’m sure the reviews will point that out. My point was just that the Luddite “computers are bad” argument is silly when all modern cars and planes and everything else is fly-by-wire. If computers fail, the world fails - good thing engineering isn’t just a faf and reliability engineering actually works!
- dzhiurgis 3y ago
- photonbeam 3y agoThis feels like a regression, mirrors are really high resolution and are great with depth perception
- olliej 3y agoAnd better color response, no latency, getting some dirt or leaves splashed on your windscreen doesn’t take out the entire field of view…
- magicalhippo 3y agoOn my car the camera is placed such that it rarely gets blocked by dirt or debris. I sometimes flip back to the mirror only to find I can't see anything due to dirt on the rear window. Flip back to camera and I see just fine.
- ssl-3 3y agoCounterpoints: I can't see shit out of the back window without some work on my part on many cold mornings (with electric defrost), but a tiny little camera-heater could be both fast and efficient (which is more important for EVs). I can wipe a small camera lens off faster than I cash wash a uselessly-filthy back window enough that it is better than a streaky opaque mess, as I've had happen to the back window on fairly mundane (if long) road trips with regular road grime. Fewer windows means a cooler interior when it has been baking in the sun It's a lot harder to get distracted by light and glare from phone screens or whatever that back-seat people are using when there's no interior mirror pointed in that direction to begin with It doesn't sound all bad. And since it's got rather good cameras, that sure does sound better than the vehicles I've spent time driving that had neither rear windows nor any cameras.
- noufalibrahim 3y agoI can't think of many real negatives. Since I got a parking camera in my car, I don't use the rear view mirror at all during parking. If there is some way I can get more accurate information about the blind spots around my car (and this camera seems to be one such thing), I'd much prefer that. There will be cleaning and electronics problems but every technology comes with its own set of issues. The only thing I can think of is the general idea that low tech. often has less moving moving parts and is more resilient but I'm not sure that applies here.
- culturestate 3y agoDriving without a rear window isn’t a big deal - see, for example, nearly every cargo delivery van on Earth. I have to imagine the stubborn refusal to add standard physical controls back to the cockpit has more potential for trouble than an impeded rear view. I wonder if there’s NHTSA data on this specifically for passenger cars? Maybe incidents caused by blocking the driver’s rear view (with furniture or people or whatever) versus fumbling around with a touchscreen or a joystick?
- toast0 3y ago> Driving without a rear window isn’t a big deal - see, for example, nearly every cargo delivery van on Earth. Yeah, it's totally fine, as long as you have both side mirrors. It'd be nice if they put bigger mirrors on the side if they're killing the rear window though. Although they're pushing a screen to replace the mirror, I guess. I haven't used one of those in a while, but I did have a rental with a screen / mirror and found it really strained my eyes to change from far focus on driving to near focus on the screen... Might be better when the screen is not also a mirror, I could kind of see the mirrored image if I was far focused even if the screen was on... it was pretty distracting until I figured out how to turn off the screen part.
- dieselgate 3y agoThe “long as you have both side mirrors” is kind of interesting nuance. My 1980 civic back in the day only had driver side mirror from the factory which seems common-enough in older cars - it isn’t totally necessary anyway if there’s visibility. assume modern cars would only lack them if it’s damaged or similar.
- lancebeet 3y agoI think driving a car without a curb side mirror would be frowned upon in countries with a lot of bicycle traffic.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoBut it had a rear window and a rear view mirror.
- tra3 3y agoFirst, they came for my volume knob and I didn’t speak out..
- rvnx 3y agothen they removed the stalks and I didn't speak out...
- philjohn 3y agoThat's why I love my EV6 - physical knobs.
- jamiek88 3y agoMy ev6 is my fav car I’ve ever owned and when I was young and stupid I had some very nice cars some of them almost three times the price.
- aaronbrethorst 3y agoAh yes, because automobile ergonomics are just like a fascist autocracy that murdered six million Jews.
- chgs 3y agoI did. I only buy cars with volume knobs (and physical heating etc)
- blendo 3y agoOT: carbuzz.com estimated its curb weight as about 5,500 lbs. That’s good when you’re driving 80mph on the freeway, but way too big around town. I’d like to see drivers in US cities have the option for something smaller, like Renault’s new Duo, the replacement for the Twizy: https://insideevs.com/news/615402/renault-mobilize-duo-is-new-twizy-adds-bento-cargo-version/ https://insideevs.com/news/615402/renault-mobilize-duo-is-ne...
- beretguy 3y ago> Mobilize Duo will be available on subscription or long-term leases only. No thank you. Also, it’s ugly.
- dgan 3y ago>> all-electric quadricycle that will be offered on subscription or long-term leases only Lol finally! Auto industry catching up with the latest and greatest software trend!
- yumraj 3y agoTwo comments: 1) Driver's rear view is solved by using a camera, but what about rear passengers. Rear window provides natural light to come in. It might get pretty dark inside without it. 2) How will it impact the DMV driving test? In a recent driving test for a kid, the instructor explicitly said that if the kid reversed by looking at the camera view in the screen, she will fail the kid. With this car, there is no rearview window, so reverse can only be done by looking at the camera view, there's no looking back while reversing.
- syslog 3y agoAd 1: the glass roof might take care of that.
- Toutouxc 3y ago> if the kid reversed by looking at the camera view in the screen, she will fail the kid That's interesting, my compact sedan doesn't have a camera, and you can still see something in the rear view mirror, so I feel perfectly comfortable reversing into tight spaces or over longer distances. Sometimes I drive rentals (different Toyotas) that have cameras, and I vastly prefer the camera for reversing. When leaving a parking spot, you can immediately see the cars in the lane you're reversing into. You can see directly behind the rear bumper (kids, dogs, forgotten baggage). Running over someone's kid in a busy parking lot is something I'm really terrified of, and the camera eases my mind a lot.
- bad_username 3y agoMaybe its not a big difference long term, but a camera is 2D, whereas a mirror provides a 3D image with depth, allowing to assess distances naturally. It also has a much better resolution and dynamic range, works much better in the dark, etc.
- KeplerBoy 3y agoMeh, a mirror might have a better resolution but my eyesight is limited and I can make out more details in a camerafeed presented on a large display. Haven't seen a 20" rear view mirror yet.
- inejge 3y ago> the world's first mass-market car to have no rear window Tatra 87[1] would like a word. I'm sure there are more if you're versed in automotive history. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tatra_87 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tatra_87
- postepowanieadm 3y agoNow wait for the front window to be eliminated. Just give the driver driver Apple Vision Pro.
- eCa 3y agoIt also disallows drivers behind the vehicle to see through it to see what’s in front. Of course there are plenty such vehicles on the road already (trucks, RVs, etc), but it would probably be detrimental to road safety if this feature becomes popular among automakers.
- bayindirh 3y agoMany SUVs' rear glass are already so high and tinted out of the factory. I rarely get to see what's beyond these vehicles when I'm in traffic. Nothing beats having a proper following distance for safety.
- rob74 3y agoActually, this got progressively worse over time: older cars have really big and non-tinted rear windows, so no problem to "see through" (but I wouldn't want to land on the roof after an accident with one of those). Newer cars, even non-SUVs, are already worse in this regard (smaller windows, often tinted, bigger headrests). If you add SUVs, pickups, vans etc. to the mix it gets even worse.
- maxglute 3y agoQueue replacing rear "window" with screen to show what's in front... wait a few years for companies to monetize with ads of course. https://news.samsung.com/global/the-safety-truck-could-revolutionize-road-safety https://news.samsung.com/global/the-safety-truck-could-revol...
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoI can switch the camera in my car to replace the normal mirror. This is useful when the trunk is full. I hate it, though, because it forces your eyes to quickly and repeatedly adapt to short vision (the image is close to you), then again on the road etc. There is no such a problem with the normal mirror which shows objects far away so you you don't need to adapt when switching between forward and back view
- Someone 3y agoReading https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2908311/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2908311/, it can take half a second (for the oldest age group, in the dark) before an eye even starts to accommodate and, if I’m interpreting RTI correctly, easily another half a second to accommodate. Makes me wonder how sharp an image one needs to see in the rear view mirror to drive. Or do drivers really look to such a screen for over a second while driving? And of course, getting rid of the front window, too, would get rid of the accommodation issue, but I do not see that being accepted by car drivers soon.
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoI would be fine with switching to a closed cockpit, provided I get augmented information, removal of distractions etc. We are I guess 30 years short of such features so that driving with such a cockpit is safer and more efficient
- rlv-dan 3y ago> it forces your eyes to quickly and repeatedly adapt to short vision Sounds like a big nono for "older" people. I'm having difficulty focusing on the dashboard nowadays. Progressive glasses could fix it, but the short distance area is at the bottom, so you would have to tilt your head alot to see the mirror.
- unixhero 3y agoInteresting and well spotted
- bonton89 3y ago
- Doctor_Fegg 3y ago> Polestar says this allows for "a new kind of immersive rear occupant experience" where passengers are "cocooned" away from the world That sounds awful. (But then I always take the window seat in trains.)
- voidUpdate 3y agobeing cocooned away from the world in a moving car sounds like a recipe for motion sickness to me...
- culopatin 3y agoIndeed. I hate the last row in SUVs for this reason
- IanCal 3y agoYou probably don't spend a lot of time staring out of the rear window though. The windows at the side are still there and the glass roof now goes further back.
- blitzar 3y ago> "a new kind of immersive rear occupant experience" where passengers are "cocooned" I am familiar with this design, the passenger is cocooned by a ceiling height designed for a person less than 5'6 (because the car looks way cooler on the outside). If you are any taller you get the transformative experience of a ride in "landscape mode" with your head rotated 90 degrees.
- killingtime74 3y agoI find it interesting that it's called a Swedish car company when it's owned by a Chinese car company and none of its cars are produced in Sweden. Is national attribution of companies meaningless? Maybe every company should open an office in Sweden and call itself Swedish.
- blitzar 3y agoApple doesnt make its products in the US, people consider that a US company.
- killingtime74 3y agoI guess Steve Jobs and Woz are both American, listed on Nasdaq and the staff are in the US.
- blitzar 3y agoPolestar was founded by Swedes, listed on the Nasdaq and the cars are "Designed in Sweden" by the staff in their Swedish HQ.
- killingtime74 3y agoWell there you go, it fully qualifies