4 ms·
NATO countries rely on massive air superiority. Something neither side in that war has, hence their stalemate. NATO armed forces have comparatively small amou
by eru 3y ago
NATO countries rely on massive air superiority. Something neither side in that war has, hence their stalemate.
NATO armed forces have comparatively small amounts of armoured ground vehicles and artillery.
They need to and want to learn from the current war, but still keep in mind that their circumstances are different.
- riku_iki 3y agoUS has air superiority. Other NATO air forces are likely weaker than Russians.
- eru 3y agoMaybe weaker than Russia before the war? They have been bled dry since. But it doesn't really matter: collective defense is the whole point of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization.
- riku_iki 3y ago> But it doesn't really matter: collective defense is the whole point of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. I am not certain US will enter war with Russia in case of some escalation with European countries, especially if Trump will be elected.
- unclebucknasty 3y ago>US has air superiority. Other NATO air forces are likely weaker than Russians. A superior air force and air superiority are different concepts. The latter refers to a conflict-time status in a particular theatre.
- somenameforme 3y agoThis isn't what air superiority means. It occurs when one side is able to safely fly, and their opponent isn't. It's likely to be an obsolete concept in any sort of peer to peer war due to widespread anti-air weaponry, yet it's very near an assumption in NATO war doctrine, because that doctrine has been developed over decades of invading countries with no ability to defend themselves.
- dilyevsky 3y agoNATOs doctrinal reliance on air is precisely the reason why russia has tremendous amount of aa systems deployed
- cm2187 3y agoDoesn't it depend on how stealthy is the F35? That will soon be almost the only game in town in Europe (outside of France).
- throwup238 3y ago> It's likely to be an obsolete concept in any sort of peer to peer war due to widespread anti-air weaponry, yet it's very near an assumption in NATO war doctrine, because that doctrine has been developed over decades of invading countries with no ability to defend themselves. That's too strong an assumption. The USAF 's bread and butter is supersonic stealth jets that can enter a territory, fire RF missiles to take out anti-aircraft radar, and leave faster than anything can catch it. Repeated hit and run attacks that wear down ground defenses until they can fly unchallenged. That's on top of the massive arsenal of precision guided missiles that will take out any static installation identified by constant global satellite surveillance. NATO doctrine has always been geared towards countering the Sovet Union/Russia, despite the counter-terrorism detour the US took.
- pigpang 3y agoSupersonic missiles are very vulnerable to a debris in the sky. Instead of catching of a missile, a drone can be blown up in advance on predicted trajectory of the supersonic missile.
- riku_iki 3y ago> The USAF 's bread and butter is supersonic stealth jets that can enter a territory, fire RF missiles to take out anti-aircraft radar F-35 can't super-sonic cruise. The choice was to be slow but stealthy.
- somenameforme 3y agoThis is not really how it works in practice. The fastest craft ever made, by an extremely wide margin, was the amazing SR-71 Blackbird - yet another marvel from the Apollo era! [1] It hit mach 3.3 (2200 mph)! For contrast the F-35 hits mach 1.6, and Russia's SU-57 hits mach 2. Russia's workhorse anti-air system is the S-400. It has a range of 400k with a max speed of mach 14! It's also a mobile system. Even MANPADs, which are extremely cheap (relative to an aircraft) pose a major threat. For instance the now somewhat dated FIM-92 [2] can hit mach 2.2. This is why even though Ukraine's air defenses are overall somewhat limited, Russian aircraft rarely if ever go for deep missions. Air superiority is probably just impossible in modern times against a peer adversary. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_SR-71_Blackbird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_SR-71_Blackbird [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIM-92_Stinger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FIM-92_Stinger
- dilyevsky 3y agoThat’s not what air superiority means - it’s not a relative measure of opposing air capabilities
- riku_iki 3y agoYou can deduct that NATO countries except US won't achieve air superiority against capable opponent(Russia, China), and their doctrine is not effective if new US president elect will decide so.
- delfinom 3y agoAir superiority means nothing when the opposing side has meat for the meat grinder and it's widely spread out. The West has gotten ridiculously invested in "smart bombs" which cost a fortune and as a result we have less of them. Meanwhile the enemy has no problem sending tens of thousands of waves of small squads to their death. In fact a study came out in 2022 that made the Pentagon panic because it's estimated in a war with China, the US will deplete its entire anti-ship missile stockpile in only a week.
- CamperBob2 3y agoWe didn't think that we were going to have to fight Russia, or to help our allies kill Russians by the hundreds of thousands. Generals are often criticized for wanting to "fight the last war," but it seems that contrary to all conventional wisdom, that is exactly where the West is headed. At least, if somebody doesn't take Putin out.
- smegger001 3y agounfortunately war with russia would very likely be the last war as we and they would be nuked back into the bronze age
- pigpang 3y agoGlobal warming can be stopped by nuclear winter only.
- lawn 3y agoThis isn't that probable actually. Russia doesn't have nearly the amount of nukes they used to. Apart from the dismantling, all signs point to many of them being unusable due to lack of maintenance (due to corruption). What they have left are smaller bombs. The fear is overblown.
- somenameforme 3y agoNuclear arsenals and capability are regularly assessed by the FAS. The latest numbers leave Russia with around 1,710 currently actively deployed strategic nuclear weapons. [1] And somewhere around 4,000 nuclear warheads beyond that. These figures are just estimates, but do account for dismantling, obsolescence of dated capabilities, and so on. The reason strategic weapons are generally tracked is largely because these are the massive weapons, both literally and in terms of capacity. For instance a modern strategic nuke on the smaller end would generally be around 500kt of yield. The largest bomb ever detonated, Czar Bomba, was 50,000kt of yield. For contrast, the nuke dropped on Hiroshima had a yield of 15kt. Even if our estimate is wrong by 90% in the happy direction, that's enough power to effectively destroy any country countless times over, including the US. Furthermore, those 4000 'rando' warheads are indeed going to be small relative to strategic nukes - but "small" in this case again means sizes of up to ~100kt, once again several times the power of Hiroshima. I find the propaganda gradually trending towards 'nuclear war wouldn't be so bad' to be quite disconcerting. Let's at least wait until we're a multiplanetary species before we decide to start offing ourselves on a massive scale. Or even better, never do it in the first place. The Fermi Paradox is a real thing, and could be easily explained by people's inability to escape their own self delusions. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia_and_weapons_of_mass_destruction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia_and_weapons_of_mass_des...
- cm2187 3y agoNATO I believe isn't really setup for a long and wide ww1 style conflict like in Ukraine. I understand the plan in case of a russian invasion was always to use nukes at one point.
- dilyevsky 3y ago> NATO countries rely on massive air superiority. Something neither side in that war has, hence their stalemate. Vks has superiority at least along the front line since this spring maybe winter. What they dont have is supremacy
- yencabulator 3y agoWhat happens when the drones are used to target airplanes? The drones are too small, cheap and numerous to use a modern fighter jet's weapons against.