3 ms·
>EU must demand US pay for its pollution. Carbon credits, but not for goods, but individuals. Tax the carbon of imports, too. I get the justification for a car
by gruez 3y ago
>EU must demand US pay for its pollution. Carbon credits, but not for goods, but individuals. Tax the carbon of imports, too.
I get the justification for a carbon border tax is to equalize the cost difference between a country that has a carbon tax vs one that doesn't, so manufacturers from the country with carbon tax isn't disadvantaged, but what's the justification for enacting taxes just because the country's citizens are polluting? Is it just a "we don't like what you're doing" tax?
- jijijijij 3y agoBecause pollution is of global consequence?
- gruez 3y agoYou can make the same argument for any other geopolitical reason, eg. "American imperialism" or whatever
- jijijijij 3y agoBegging the question. Obviously, some geopolitical issues are subject to trade agreements and legislation. While "American Imperialism" is an intangible concept, pollution very much is not. What can and cannot be made for an argument depends mostly on economic/geopolitical leverage, not faulty categorical thinking. With less adversarial framing, you could think of it as finding common ground for an intermingled future.
- gruez 3y ago>Begging the question. Explain? Countries invoking "American Imperialism" isn't exactly an unheard of concept. The point isn't whether "American Imperialism" or "pollution" is objectively true, it's whether other countries would invoke those reasons to set up retaliatory tariffs. >While "American Imperialism" is an intangible concept, pollution very much is not How about something more concrete like "EU/NATO enlargement", "Chinese spying", or "tech giants (who are mostly American) spreading misinformation"? >With less adversarial framing, you could think of it as finding common ground for an intermingled future. That's a nice thing to hope for, but isn't the world we live in. Countries who have the tariffs applied to them aren't going to interpret them as "common ground for an intermingled future", they're going to think it's the opening shot of a trade war.