6 ms·
Does mining for batteries erase the climate benefits of EVs? No, and here's why
- henriquez 3y agoThis article is a platitude with no hard data. Climate impacts can be measured, so it’s suspicious to not include actual measurements when comparing X against Y. Feel free to educate me in the comments, it’s more than this article did.
- dragontamer 3y agoACEEE has a methodology where they assign a $$ value to different kinds of pollution (NOx, CO2, PM2.5, etc. etc.), and then estimate the lifetime of pollution for various cars. https://www.aceee.org/greener-cars https://www.aceee.org/greener-cars EVs *do* have pollution associated with their creation. And its largely upon that battery pack. But with a small enough battery pack and clean enough chemistry, you'll see cars like the Nissan Leaf reach the top of these lists. But some battery packs, such as NCA-cells found in Tesla, get penalized. -------- ACEEE seems to have used an Argonne National Labs program to estimate the pollution of various raw materials. You can read about it here: https://greenercars.org/greenercars-ratings/how-we-determine-ratings/ https://greenercars.org/greenercars-ratings/how-we-determine... Everyone's methodology is different, which means everyone will reach different conclusions. We *SHOULD* figure out the lifetime pollution of various EVs, mostly because different EVs will be better (or worse) than others. Its not sufficient enough to just be an EV fanboy anymore, there's a huge difference from an EV Hummer (which has more lifetime pollutions than a typical car) and a Nissan Leaf. ------------ ACEEE shows that many Hybrids and PHEVs are competitive vs many EVs on a lifetime scale of pollution. Case in point: Toyota's Prius Prime is the greenest car according to ACEEE. The combination of very small battery pack (13kW-hr) and very efficient driving (130MPGe when in electric mode, 50+ MPG in gasoline mode) means very little emissions in practice. The bigger 70kW-hr battery packs emit more pollution upon creation and never catch up to the Prius or Prius Prime.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoMany countries have committed to zero-carbon electricity by 2035. Any car you buy today will likely still be on the road then. The EV's emissions will have dropped to essentially 0 per mile whereas the Prius hybrid will still be at current levels.
- dragontamer 3y agoA huge chunk of EV emissions is in the dirty and expensive mining/refining process of Li-ion. Lifetime emissions are the best way to measure the difference from an "upfront" emissions (like a Li-ion battery) vs an "over time" emissions (like a Hybrid engine).
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNo it's not. Manufacturing a battery creates 2-5 tons of CO2 emissions, which is about 1 year's worth of emissions from a gasoline car. And Lithium is a small fraction of those 5 tons from the battery.
- dragontamer 3y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10683946/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10683946/ > The reported GHG emissions range from 39–196-kgCO2eq/kWh battery due to differences in many factors including battery specifications and technologies, geographical locations, and life cycle inventory data; and material, energy, and processes emission factors; making direct comparison of results very difficult Assuming a 80kW-hr battery pack, I'm seeing anywhere from 2.7-tons to 15-tons of CO2, which is a bit more variance than you initially pointed out. More specifically, we can breakdown per country and get better estimates. > Several of these studies focus on individual countries. For instance, Kim et al. (17) focused on South Korea and found an emission intensity of 141-kgCO2eq/kWh battery. Sun et al. studied China and reported an emission intensity of 124.5 kgCO2eq/kWh (20), while Dai et al. examined the United States and found an emission intensity of 72.9-kgCO2eq/kWh battery (6) Assuming 75 kg-CO2 / kWh for USA and 80kW-hr gives me ~6-tons of CO2 per battery pack assuming relatively clean US Production. Its approximately 20lbs of CO2 per gallon of gasoline. So 6-tons of CO2 is equivalent to 600 gallons of Gasoline, or ~24,000 miles in a typical Corolla Hybrid. A Prius Prime is around 70% electric and 30% gasoline at 50mpg. That makes the crossover point at nearly 100,000 miles for the Prius Prime. (30,000 Mi gasoline, 70,000 Mi electric), assuming the electricity used was zero greenhouse gasses (unlikely: most electricity these days are Natural Gas in the USA). Needless to say, the Hybrid equation is strong even in a hypothetical 100% green electric grid. Move to ~60% fossil fuel electric grid (like what we have right now in the USA) and the math goes screwy, but clearly in favor of ICE/Hybrid/PHEV. Change the math to South Korean's dirtier 141-kgCO2/kWh and we're looking at nearly 50,000 miles before the EV (on 100% green / zero-emissions) beats a Corolla Hybrid (40mpg), and nearly 200,000 miles before the EV beats a Prius Prime.
- mint2 3y agoThe article provides citations to studies with hard data backing up the statements so I’m not sure what you’re looking for.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atonse 3y agoOnce we have a critical mass of electric vehicles and they become the default/norm, would that dismiss the argument that cars are bad for the environment? Of course there’s still some fossil fuel use (tires, some mining, etc) but overall, is there anything inherent to cars that we would continue to suggest that people just try to not use cars and use public transportation instead?
- mint2 3y agoThere’s a lot of sociological problems with a car dominated society. Reducing the green house gas impact of cars fixes none of those.
- atonse 3y agoCan you expand on this a bit? I am curious. Because most of the time people talk mostly about the fossil fuel impact (which will be greatly reduced in our lifetimes). But are you confirming my guess, that we would no longer be able to say cars are bad on environmental grounds?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mint2 3y agoNo, I am not. Car dominated cities and transport have many issues. All EVs do is mitigate the tailpipe CO2 issue. Take for example the phrase “They paved paradise and put up a parking lot.” Cars definitely are ideal for certain things, but designing society and the built environment with car transport at the primary concern is highly misguided and bad for the environment even if tailpipe emissions are no longer a thing.
- yowzadave 3y agoCars are bad for urban environments, independent of their impact on CO2/energy production--they result in traffic, too-wide streets, pedestrian danger, and generally less pleasant cities.
- orthecreedence 3y agoWhere are the numbers? It just says batteries are an upfront cost, gas is ongoing. Well, yeah, duh...but how many gallons of gas (or how many miles) does an ICE car need to cover before it overtakes the carbon cost of the same car with a battery pack? And are we adjusting for energy generation and loss in transit? There's a carbon cost to produce/deliver gas, and there's energy loss in transmission lines. So what's the carbon cost of the oil rig, refining, delivery and what's the carbon cost of the solar plant (including all of its batteries) amortized over its lifetime and the coversion of that cost into Kw adjusted for loss in transmission? I'm not necessarily against EVs at all, but so far I've yet to see a good, deep analysis as to how much of an improvement they are. This article is running away from that anlysis as fast as it can.
- mint2 3y agoThe article links to the actual studies. This is an NPR article! not a scientific thesis.. As far as pop articles go it’s far more well referenced than the average.
- orthecreedence 3y agoThanks, I guess I missed the links. For reference, here's one that answers some of what I'm asking: https://theicct.org/publication/a-global-comparison-of-the-life-cycle-greenhouse-gas-emissions-of-combustion-engine-and-electric-passenger-cars/ https://theicct.org/publication/a-global-comparison-of-the-l...
- ortusdux 3y agoThis is too dense! Can anyone link to a more readable article??
- mint2 3y agoSo Like the original NPR article that gives a high level explanation? (while establishing credibility by providing supporting references for cross checking) https://text.npr.org/1250212212 https://text.npr.org/1250212212
- xnx 3y agoIf the lifetime cost of the vehicle saves money vs. the alternative, it is better for the environment. Since fossil fuel is an input to all sides of the equation (mining, transportation, and processing of raw materials. fuel for ICE vehicles), it is convenient and approximately correct do use dollar cost as a measure of environmental impact.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoSolar panels are sometimes built at factories powered by coal. But they are a greatly net producer of energy, returning many thousands of times that input. Under your arguments, we should just assume $100 of fuel will pollute approximately the same as $100 of solar. This is grossly misguided. That fossile fuels are involved somewhere doesn't create an equivalency. It matters where the dollars go. Jfc I can't believe that needs to be said.
- xnx 3y agoI probably need to explain more as that is not what I meant. Dollar cost is a good measure of environmental impact when comparing two options. An EV has more environmental impact on day one than an ICE because it costs more. After 200K miles (pick a number) the EV has less environmental impact (to a good first approximation) because the total cost of ownership (vehicle, fuel, maintenance, tires, insurance, etc.) is less. $100 of gas and a $100 solar panel do have about the same environmental impact at first, but 10 MWh of electricity produced by a $100 solar panel has much less environmental impact than however much fossil fuel it would take to generate the same.
- user568439 3y agoEven if today’s situation would still favor fossil fuels, in the long term I have zero doubts about battery win. They are improving significantly every year: density increase which allows weight and volume reduction or longer range; cheaper and less contaminant materials are used for still evolving LFP and sodium batteries; Electric engines without rare earths are also appearing; loading charge from only renewable sources will be the norm; production escalation will reduce pollution per manufactured unit; recycling processes will appear
- readthenotes1 3y agoThe study after study studies seem to only look at greenhouse gas emissions, not the full life cycle retirement costs of lithium and other toxic elements.
- timbit42 3y agoThe crisis is air pollution. Ground and water pollution are also issues but less critical than air pollution. I'm OK with putting more focus on reducing air pollution for now.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoThe bad thing is not as bad as the very bad thing. If you must have a car, then sure, an EV is better than a ICE vehicle. But our local, state, and federal governments should stop subsidizing highways and fossil fuels, and invest in public transit and cycling infrastructure. Solid bus /train service + a bike/scooter is a powerful combination.