4 ms·
> I can't work with plastic. Why not? If you can machine it from metal, it is easier to machine it from plastic. I fabricate plastic replacements often with a
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
> I can't work with plastic.
Why not? If you can machine it from metal, it is easier to machine it from plastic. I fabricate plastic replacements often with a drill, files, and saw.
- throwanem 3y agoYeah, I was gonna say. Not that I'd necessarily want to cut a gear with hand tools even in nylon, considering how exacting the profile would be to get right, but it's doable.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI'd rather hand cut a gear in nylon than one in steel. If you arent doing it by hand, who cares what it is made of.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoIt's an... unusual skill to have, I'd say. Maybe it's the issue of education or culture, but I'm with GP here: in my mind, metal parts can often be repaired by hand, or an improvised replacement can be made; plastics break too easily, and you can't make new ones without a 3D printer or something.
- Freak_NL 3y agoYup. Same with wood and fabric. Those kind of parts or components I can replace and work with. Plastic? That's a whole different ball game due to the potentially low tolerances in terms of dimensions and the nature of the type of plastic used. With wood, metal, and fabric it is much easier to gauge the correct replacement material.
- kbenson 3y agoI'd say education and culture might be right on the money. I'm not sure it's occurred to me to take a small block of some type of plastic and cut it to shape using knives, planes, chisels and files like someone could with wood, but now that I'm thinking about it, it seems like it might be considerable easier to work with than wood in some cases, especially with how easy it is to join two parts afterwards with some epoxy or maybe even through heat. Additionally, it looks like you can possibly re-melt the shavings into another block (I'm not sure if specific plastic types are required).[1] That's like woodworking but being able to easily gather and compress your bits and ends and sawdust into more wood. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34wPmcgDRmg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34wPmcgDRmg
- skjoldr 3y agoIt's because plastic injection molding has different constraints and trade-offs in parts design compared to metal machining. E.g. injection molding, after the mold is done, doesn't really care about machine time, complexity, or the availability of specific cutters and drills. So sometimes the geometry and tolerances of an injection molded part is a pain in the arse to replicate manually -- it's just not made to do it, unlike metal machining, which at scale is still a rough approximation of the manual process.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI get the manufacturing Tradeoffs. What I was responding to was not an issue with part complexity, but part material. They said "I can work with metal. I can't work with plastic." Sure, nobody is going to machine a plastic replacement complex injection molded housing. You probably werent going to re-create a complex press-formed metal part either. IT seems like it is more of a design complaint than a material issue.
- ElevenLathe 3y agoHow often do you encounter mass-produced consumer goods that include parts made of machined engineering plastics?
- MeImCounting 3y agoI have a pocket knife in my pocket (perhaps not quite as mass produced as what you were imagining) whose handles are made of G10 which is a composite material made partly of epoxy. It has been 3d machined into its current shape.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThat's not what Im saying. Machined plastics are rarely encountered, but many molded plastic products can be trivially machined. Im saying that the fabrication difficult is driven by design, not material. almost nobody is going to home fabricate a spline gear at home, and it doesnt matter if it is metal or plastic. If something is like a plate or flange, it is trivial to fabricate and doesnt matter if it is metal or plastic. For any given design, I think refabrication is the same or easier for plastic.