3 ms·
Taxpayers Are About to Subsidize a Lot More Sports Stadiums
- rayiner 3y ago> Economic research is unequivocal: These subsidies are a boondoggle for taxpayers, who have spent nearly $30 billion on stadiums over the past 34 years, not counting property-tax exemptions or federal revenues lost to tax-exempt municipal bonds. Stadiums do not come close to generating enough economic activity to pay back the public investment involved in building them—especially when they’re coupled with lease agreements that funnel revenue back to owners or allow teams to play in the stadiums rent-free. It’s interesting they evaluate the cost benefit of stadiums without considering the actual benefit that drives these decisions: people like having sports teams in their city.
- stefan_ 3y agoSo there is no need for them to be taxpayer subsidized?
- rayiner 3y agoIt’s not a subsidy, it’s paying to keep a franchise in the city versus the franchise going somewhere else. Voters in Baltimore care a lot about having the Orioles in Baltimore, even if they only watch the games on TV, because of the tribal aspect of team sports.
- nickthegreek 3y agoso extortion?
- tptacek 3y agoOnly in the sense that any market clearing is extortionate.
- janalsncm 3y agoA billion a year is actually pretty small compared with the size of the budget. When considering how central sports are to American culture, it seems like a steal. This is like someone who makes $200k a year and asking them if they’d spend $10 to have sports stadiums in their country.
- ec109685 3y agoThe Oakland example at the end laments the 350M spent by Oakland. That works out to 1k a person or $33 a year. It’s a lot of money but it should definitely be put in context around length of stadium longevity and size of population.
- lesuorac 3y ago> It’s interesting they evaluate the cost benefit of stadiums without considering the actual benefit that drives these decisions: people like having sports teams in their city. Plenty of times when a vote goes up for if a new stadium should be tax-payer funded it gets voted down [1]. It seems that for many cities; they'd rather pay less in taxes than have that sports team. [1]: https://apnews.com/article/royals-chiefs-stadiums-taxes-public-funding-f1381c8916144371b3037ebc5b2dcc47 https://apnews.com/article/royals-chiefs-stadiums-taxes-publ...
- rayiner 3y agoSometimes that happens. But many of these expansions are paid for with bond referendums, and they usually pass: https://law.marquette.edu/assets/sports-law/Referenda.16.pdf https://law.marquette.edu/assets/sports-law/Referenda.16.pdf
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- projectileboy 3y agoIt’s pretty simple: Americans value having sports teams over most other things.
- janalsncm 3y ago> American cities would all be better off if stadium subsidies disappeared. The author seems to believe that all publicly funded things need to pay for themselves. I disagree. Some things are good in their own right. Sports stadiums add culture to cities in the same way that aquariums, museums, music venues and art galleries do. The questions for me are do sports stadiums need to be rebuilt every 30 years? And how can we prevent sports stadiums from becoming just another wealth transfer from the middle class to the ultra rich? On the second, I would submit that a proper progressive tax system handles it nicely.
- TheCleric 3y agoI think the difference is for me (even as a sports fan) is it’s all to save a billionaire owner some cash. I don’t mind spending/losing money on culture; I’m not a fan of doing it to line the pockets of someone who is already stupidly rich.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoSports stadiums don’t need to pay for themselves, but they certainly shouldn’t be owned and managed by an entity that isn’t beholden to the taxpayer. We don’t expect that tax funded enterprises need to be profitable, but we do expect that if they are, the profits should accrue to the taxpayer.
- piotrkaminski 3y ago> Sports stadiums add culture to cities in the same way that aquariums, museums, music venues and art galleries do. Citation required.
- rayiner 3y agoGo outside and talk to any regular person in Philadelphia and ask them whether they’ve been to an eagles game or the art museum.
- cosmotic 3y agoGoing somewhere doesn't mean it adds culture. Is anything new or interesting happening at the eagles games? Anyone gaining new incite or having revelations over the human condition? Seems more like people are just eating the same-old food and yelling at one another.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoThis article mentions both Chicago and Cleveland as about to publically finance new stadiums. Time will tell, but so far neither state government is interested.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoAs a followup to this comment, apparently while I was typing this comment the mayor of Chicago was down in the state capital giving the legislature a list of demands that included money for a new stadium. The state senate responded by bringing to the floor unrelated legislation that the mayor strongly opposed, skipped debate and held a vote. It passed unanimously. While the mayor was standing there. That's really not a good sign for the stadium plans.