4 ms·
In Japan, there's a really symbiotic relationship between unions and corporations. Unions are very powerful, but they also take stakes in the corporations. I'm
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
In Japan, there's a really symbiotic relationship between unions and corporations.
Unions are very powerful, but they also take stakes in the corporations. I'm pretty sure that union reps often sit on corporate boards.
Japan has a long culture of employee relations, but they also work their asses off. I don't think Japanese unions would cover slackers, which is a popular view of US unions.
- Frost1x 3y agoJapanese work culture is another beast. I don’t think US unions are so much about covering ‘slackers’ but I would say enforcing healthy work—life balance is a component.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoLike I said...popular view. However, I have many friends that are quite pro-union, and the reality seems different.
- whamlastxmas 3y agoIt’s a popular view of anti union propaganda. No one wants to work with lazy people and unions don’t especially want them either
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThere's a lot of anti-union propaganda, and some of it is self-inflicted. Anyone that has ever participated in a trade show at the Javits Center, has seen unions do serious damage to their own cause.
- alistairSH 3y agoYeah, LV and NYC convention sites are probably the worst/most-obvious examples. Plenty of stories of presenters being disallowed from plugging in their own equipment without a union employee there to assist and other things like that.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThe worst I heard, was one of our sales reps (a woman) came in, with a "weekender" purse (big purse). She was stopped at the door, and wasn't allowed to enter the main hall, for about five minutes, until someone was called over, with one of those huge, hydraulic skateboards they use for moving big furniture. They put her purse onto the center of the cart, and escorted her to the booth. Then, they got upset she only tipped one guy $5. I know these are "one-off" stories (and she probably gave attitude), but there's so many of these anecdotes, that it causes huge damage.
- 93po 3y agoI think the problem is that the fast majority of workers in the US would probably have better work conditions, job security, or compensation if they were in a good union. So on one hand we have an extremely niche union that sucks, but also however many hundreds of millions of Americans as the other example of why unions are needed.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThe problem with pulling this crap at convention centers, is that the people that they are pissing off, are the exact people that they want on the side of the union.
- sensanaty 3y agoI'd rather work with a million "lazy slackers" than kiss the ass of some soulless corporate stooge who'd kill his own family if it made him 0.01% more profit YoY.
- novariation 3y agoGiven that I've worked in consulting for years I've seen a good amount of soulless corporate types, but they're usually not that far from the average human being in most respects. Your understanding of the world isn't workable when you think tens of thousands of people are acting as unhinged mass murderers and society just accepts it.
- sensanaty 3y agoSociety doesn't really accept it. Most normal people have a strong distaste for your average corpo, it's just that the corporate types are also the ones with the power and resources to fuck over everyone else, and will often use their positions to do exactly that, as can be seen with any case of union busting ever, or all the mass layoffs, or the conditions in Amazon warehouses and so many other similar situations.
- trollbridge 3y agoMy friend’s brother was in the pipefitter’s union. Those guys worked so hard, I don’t think I would have lasted a week on the jobsite. He eventually quit after saving enough money because of the long hours and hard physical work. He did get paid very well, got good overtime for those long hours, and safety came first. The benefits of a union. It may be better to say “Unions cover workers whom management accuses of being slackers.” In my experience, the worst “slackers” are often in management (my view on this is from when I was in management myself).
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoUnions are why people that do difficult, dangerous, dirty work, can afford to live in cities like New York. The apprenticeship system is just as difficult and time-consuming as college (maybe more so). The issues with unions often revolve around corruption, but there seems to be corruption in almost any human endeavor.
- alistairSH 3y agoThat's also largely true in Germany (the relationship between union and corporation).
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>I don't think Japanese unions would cover slackers, which is a popular view of US unions. popular =/= accurate. But yes, the most criticized aspect of unions (at least from a liberal lens) comes from its ability to rally around every worker in the union, regardless of individual productivity. But historically, unions in the US neeeded those protections because it's way too easy to fire a US employee for anything that's not illegal. Japan doesn't make termination any easier, it's just incoporated at the government level instead of corporate. To compensate, Japanese "slackers" just get good severance packages as an incentive to get out, or even move them as far out of the picture as possible.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoAKA “Window Seat.” That’s being given a job, where all you do, is stare out of a window, all day. It’s the worst thing that can happen to a Japanese employee. A lot of Americans might consider it a “dream job.”