2 ms·
> A good way to think about constant expressions is that `constexpr` is a hint that lets the compiler know that the variable or function CAN be evaluated at com
by WalterBright 3y ago
> A good way to think about constant expressions is that `constexpr` is a hint that lets the compiler know that the variable or function CAN be evaluated at compile time, but it is not required
In D, CTFE (Compile Time Function Evaluation) is guaranteed to run at compile time. CTFE happens whenever there's a constant-expression in the grammar, such as the initialization of an enum:
enum A = func(3);
func(3) evaluates at compile time.
- bingo3131 3y agoCalling it a hint is very much over-simplifying things as there are also restrictions on what a constexpr function is and is not allowed to do, although those restrictions become fewer and fewer as time goes on as compilers are so advanced that they can emulate more system level things at compile time. Also, constexpr on a variable is not a hint - it must be evaluated at compile time, where-as a constexpr function will be evaluated at either compile time or runtime depending on the context and arguments passed to it. For a function that you either want to work at compile time or not at all (compile error), consteval is the hardened version. Yes, sadly this means "constexpr" variables and "consteval" functions must be calculated at compile time, while "constexpr" functions can be used both at compile time and runtime. An annoying distinction.
- WalterBright 3y agoIn D, any function can be used to evaluate at compile time. If it is used for a constant-expression and cannot be evaluated at compile time, it is a compilation error. Also, the entire function needn't be evaluatable at compile time - only the path taken through it. Simply no need for tagging them one way or another.