3 ms·
As much as I enjoy mocking tech bros, that's not really a thing unique to them. I see it everywhere -- including in myself. People in general (and particularly
by JohnFen 3y ago
As much as I enjoy mocking tech bros, that's not really a thing unique to them. I see it everywhere -- including in myself.
People in general (and particularly in business) tend to overemphasize the role of talent/work and underemphasize the role of luck in the successes they have. They also tend to overemphasize (bad) luck and underemphasize talent/work in their failures.
It seems to be a basic part of human nature.
Pretty much all significant success requires both skill and a lot of good luck. Skill and good work is what gets you the lottery ticket, but you still need fortune to smile on you for it to hit.
- jprd 3y agoThis is a really great comment, and I second what you are saying. I'd love if there was a way to quantify this in some manner. Nerdy of me to say, but I wish this could be measured. The whole "hustle culture" vibe feels like it has been a distraction/cult? I am probably projecting, so forgive me if so. The idea of people trying to vibe off of Gary V. and replicate that success by replicating the _personality_ and _habits_ seems like a dead-end. Everyone is different. Elon Musk has been successful thus far, that doesn't mean he has anything to teach you on how to you can optimize your own life? I may eat some points for this, but I'm being genuine in asking, not trying to make a cultural stand.
- JohnFen 3y ago> The whole "hustle culture" vibe feels like it has been a distraction/cult? I would characterize it as a fad (and one the has recurred throughout history). But there are things in it that I think are true -- namely, the idea of persistence. If you roll the dice enough times, sooner or later the number you want will come up. This is why there are so many truisms like "you've only really failed if you stop trying again." Statistics is how you leverage luck to your advantage. > The idea of people trying to vibe off of Gary V. and replicate that success by replicating the _personality_ and _habits_ seems like a dead-end. Everyone is different. I think this is exactly right. You don't replicate someone else's success by trying to be like them. It rarely works (and seems a bit cargo-cultish to me). The path to your personal success will always wander differently than others, because you are different from others. That difference, by the way, is a strength. It's the real value-add that you have to offer.
- gary_0 3y agoI think it should be noted that talent/work (sometimes hard bloody work) is often essential to success--but without luck, the only output you get is failure at worst and mediocrity at best. And extreme outliers can get away with lots of talent/luck and not notice that they put in far less work (and they often give terrible advice about how to replicate their success).
- rsynnott 3y agoI think the odd thing in tech is that people seem to be particularly willing to extent this same delusional courtesy to _others_. Quite a few commenters on this very website have serious difficulty with the idea that a very rich person might be an idiot; they are very rich, therefore the stuff they say must be treated as received wisdom, even if it is transparently nonsense. I think that is less common, though certainly not non-existent, elsewhere. But, for instance, take Michael O'Leary, billionaire founder of Ryanair, who is a fan of saying stupid things in public. The general media response is "haha, Michael O'Leary has said something stupid again". This is _really_ different to the response to tech billionaires who are prolific sayers-of-stupid-stuff; a large portion of the tech world treats stupid stuff said by tech billionaires as specially privileged because of who said it, even if it's far outside their area of expertise, if any.
- JohnFen 3y agoYes, this is a thing that I've found bizarre for my entire life. I don't think it's a tech thing, I think it's an American thing. We seem to think that there's a correlation between wealth and being good/wise/smart/etc, even though that doesn't appear to be supported by evidence. I think it comes about in part because being wealthy in the US is directly correlated to being powerful, and in part because of religious undertones (prosperity gospel) that assert that wealth is a sign of God's favor. There's also the related problem of people thinking that because someone may be a genius in one thing, that means what they have to say about things outside of their field of expertise has weight beyond what any other random person says.