3 ms·
I'm going to be honest with you. You have me at something of a loss for words. I think I have given you all the tools you need to understand this issue at thi
by jlgreco 14y ago
I'm going to be honest with you. You have me at something of a loss for words.
I think I have given you all the tools you need to understand this issue at this point. Remember that thing I wrote about the null hypothesis? Well people who disagree with you do so because they have yet to see that null hypothesis convincingly falsified.
If you want to disagree with that, then knock yourself out. It requires absolutely zero expended effort on your part to disagree; I disagree with uncountable things in this world every day for a grand total of zero calories burned.
If you want to disagree and convince others of your point of view, then you are going to need to put some back into it. Rationally and methodically state your case for the falsification of the null hypothesis. Write it up on your blog and post it to HN. If the community considers it worthy of discussion, they will address it.
You seem to be attempting some sort of 'know thy enemy' nonsense. Stop. You are clearly unable to or unwilling to wrap your head around concepts you disagree with, so stop wasting your time. Understanding why people think what they do is unimportant, just state your case. I've already told you how.
And do make an effort to post it as a new discussion when you do so, instead of attempting to hijack another discussion looking for a flamewar.
tl;dr: Our case: the null hypothesis has not been falsified. Your case: ???
I eagerly await your blog posting; I think we are done discussing this in this other person's article's comments.
- Tycho 14y agoContradicting the null hypothesis is easy: any time a potential investor has asked a small company with a bright idea 'but what's to stop someone else just copying your idea after i've paid you to develop it?' and the developer replies 'well, we have patent protection' to reassure him/her, patents have been useful and supportive of innovation. The problem is that the argument will immediately move on to the net benefit/detriment to the industry, at which point we need to establish the principles on which people object to software patents. You are clearly unable to or unwilling to wrap your head around concepts you disagree with, so stop wasting your time. Less condescension maybe?