3 ms·
But this is exactly what I mean. People don't even agree on what "reasonable" is. The map you're calling unreasonable is the one where both parties have an even
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
But this is exactly what I mean. People don't even agree on what "reasonable" is. The map you're calling unreasonable is the one where both parties have an even chance at all three of those seats.
Someone else will be telling me that the map where the 60% majority gets 100% of the seats is unreasonable because they should only get half of the seats since 60% is closer to 50% than 75%, much less 100%. Then someone will say that the map where each party always gets half the seats is unreasonable because then it's four safe seats and none under contention, which removes democratic accountability from the representatives in both parties.
The actual problem here is first past the post voting, which results in a two party system. You can't gerrymander STAR voting because drawing a moderate district would result in a moderate candidate instead of the district going to whichever extreme gets 51% of the vote in a two horse race.