5 ms·
Even Mullvad?
by stavros 3y ago
Even Mullvad?
- actionfromafar 3y agoMullvad complies, but they go out of their way to keep very little information. If you don't have the information in the first place, you can't surrender it.
- sigmoid10 3y agoBeware that despite all marketing statements, VPN providers can easily be forced to store logs using court orders, even if they don't do it by default.
- carbotaniuman 3y agoYou can always shut down rather than do so - it's happened in the US.
- sigmoid10 3y agoThis also happened with providers in Europe. So you can safely assume that any VPN provider who is still doing business in Europe is compromised in some way or another by the government.
- yaris 3y ago"Compromised" is a wrong word to use, unless you consider any obedience to the law "compromise". VPN providers who are still doing business in EU (not Europe) do obey court orders - that would be more correct wording. Any non-compliance is a one-time occurence: either you decide to cease operations or you are forced to cease operations by LEA, as in vpnlab.net example.
- sigmoid10 3y agoIf you actually look at the vpnlab example, you'll find that the government got access to all their data, not just for specific cases. So you can assume that all remaining providers have yielded the same level of access.
- alexey-salmin 3y ago> VPN providers can easily be forced to store logs using court orders It's not grave if the provider is allowed to notify the user that logs are being collected from now on. Is there a country where gag orders are unconstitutional or something of that sort?
- actionfromafar 3y agoThat still has value, it's much harder to do drag-net style surveillance if you need court orders to collect new information and can't scoop up old information.
- sigmoid10 3y agoYou can answer the question yourself for any provider using this simple test: Can you legally buy access to it from inside the EU? If yes, they will suffer from the same problem as all other providers.
- stavros 3y agoWhat are these problems, exactly?
- sigmoid10 3y agoAs I said above, a simple court order can destroy any attempt at privacy. All (serious) VPN providers claim they don't store logs. But that does not mean that a court can't force them to do so. When combined with a gag order you can have someone collecting all your traffic without you even realizing it. And that's just the VPN provider, which usually doesn't own any datacenters. The datacenter providers can also receive the orders to either monitor traffic or even install hardware to do so. If you want any hope of privacy, you steer clear of all big commercial "privacy" providers, because they are very high on every government agency's list. And you just need one component in the entire chain to be compromised.
- lillecarl 3y agoYou're spreading FUD, the Swedish government can't do shit to Mullvad but take their servers offline. Possibly if it was a matter of national security, at which point our recommendations are useless either way.
- sigmoid10 3y agoFalse. Like all member states, the Swedish government has officialy ceded jurisdiction and enforcement of certain laws to the EU. Only VPN providers who do not comply with such international court orders get shut down. Look at what happened to vpnlab: The police literally write on their seized domain that they have forcefully attained access to everything, because the provider would not give it away freely: https://vpnlab.net/ https://vpnlab.net/ Consequently, you can assume that all other VPN providers who are still doing business in Europe are freely giving away their data to government agencies.