5 ms·
> we started searching for a tool specifically built for complex discussions. We found none This was basically solved in Usenet, more specifically, in news rea
by layer8 3y ago
> we started searching for a tool specifically built for complex discussions. We found none
This was basically solved in Usenet, more specifically, in news reader software. You had a clearly arranged threaded view (you could see the thread structure of as many as 50 postings on a single screen), with unread threads and unread postings highlighted, and pressing Tab jumped to the next unread posting. Unread status was per posting/comment, not by time. Many more conveniences for quick navigation, filtering, and so on.
All newer discussion platforms have been a step back in terms of efficiency of use and ability for deep, long running discussions. Initially due to web browser limitations (though nowadays that shouldn’t be much of a problem anymore), and later due to mobile touch interfaces (still poses some difficulties).
- shsbdncudx 3y agoYou’re right. We shouldn’t try to improve what we are doing now.
- layer8 3y agoI’m saying it’s worth looking into what worked in the past, and why. It’s not uncharted territory.
- loceng 3y agoSo why do you think Usenet is not the mainstream status quo for conversations then?
- layer8 3y agoUsenet died due to spam. Newsgroups were unmoderated by default, and moderation wasn’t built into the protocol. Then PHP web forums took over because they were discoverable by web search and only required the web browser that you had anyway. They also added support for popular features like posting images and using emoticons graphics, instead of only text (though the latter hasn’t hurt HN).
- jll29 3y agoWe may distinguish between USENET the public network that is part of the Internet (considerd "out of date" by many because it is not Web based, and indeed suffering from spam) and the USENET protocol, which you can use to set up your private version of USENET-like discussion groups. In fact, many organizations had (and some still may have) inhouse groups, often prefixed "local." e.g. "local.events", "local.jokes" etc. Advantage: threaded discussions, open standard (many existing open source readers e.g. Emacs: M-x gnus)
- wolverine876 3y ago> Usenet died due to spam. Newsgroups were unmoderated by default, and moderation wasn’t built into the protocol. Doesn't that make Usenet unfit for complex public discussions, at least?
- layer8 3y agoIt worked quite well with a mostly-academia audience. For the general public, of course, moderation is indispensable. The spam in Usenet began when businesses and scammers discovered Usenet. My point in the root comment is that Usenet clients contained all the ingredients for efficient, structured, long-running, deep discussion, and those are orthogonal to moderation, which you nowadays need in any case.
- aeternum 3y agoThe problem with Usenet style interfaces isn't just spam, it's low value comments. Comment voting somewhat solves this but most people vote based upon how much they agree rather than the comment's discussion value.
- layer8 3y agoThis should be solved by moderation when necessary, like in traditional web forums. I agree that voting is a bad mechanism, because people then start posting for likes and reaction stats, and also involuntarily judge posts by their like count instead of only by their own judgement. Flagging/reporting to moderators is fine.
- TranquilMarmot 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- layer8 3y agoEternal September lowered the average quality of Usenet content, but it’s not what ultimately lead to its demise. I actually only started using Usenet around the mid-90s, and continued for a good decade. The problem later was spam, and web forums being much more discoverable, and somewhat easier to get started with, so that’s where new users went.
- wmf 3y agoMost people don't want to have truth-seeking complex discussions because it's hard and boring.
- smallmancontrov 3y agoHard, boring, and a social liability.
- tux3 3y agoThere's a lot of truth to be found out there that is useful, technical, and utterly devoid of public attention. But if the truth-seeking you're thinking of is being a culture war truther, that'd certainly explain the woes.
- spacebanana7 3y agoA lot of technical issues are very controversial. It can be difficult to discuss inside an enterprise because everyone’s already so committed to a particular solution. People have very strong opinions about crypto, SPAs, and CDNs.
- tux3 3y agoIt can be difficult to discuss technical issues inside an enterprise, but if it turns into a social liability, either you enterprise culture is extraordinarily corrosive to the soul, or what you're doing is culture war. The words they used are social liability, not merely controversial. It's a pretty high bar for how wrong a discussion in an enterprise has to go that it turns into a social liability.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoMaybe they're thinking about what they said, which is seeking out truth about issues that happen to be thrown around in culture war? Anyway, you don't have to go all the way there for knowledge to become a social liability. The more you understand about the universe and the human world - hell, the more permission to think you give yourself - the more you realize just how much utter bullshit regular people believe about everything. Homeopathy, weird coaching stuff, fitness and dieting and cosmetics. This supplement will help your health, that fruit will stop some ailment, looking at a microwave when it's cooking will ruin your eyes, etc. Most of this bullshit is fed by content marketers, through magazines, shows, radio, podcasts, and social media. I have a whole rant about ethics of advertising, but that's for another day; point here is: it doesn't take much truth-seeking before it gets incredibly cringe to talk with most people. You either let them keep believing in bullshit and suffer inside, or speak up and end up being pushed out of the group.
- lmm 3y agoNo-one has found a funding model that works for it.
- chrisjj 3y agoDisproved by subscription-based www.cix.co.uk.
- lmm 3y agoI don't see anything about Usenet service on there. More generally, while a few people are willing to pay for access to a discussion service, most aren't and it's not clear that the people who are are a big enough market to be viable.
- chrisjj 3y agoI was referring to the paradigm but sorry yes you are right the parent was specifically about usenet. > More generally, while a few people are willing to pay for access to a discussion service, most aren't Agreed.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoNo need for anyone to still have their own artisanally bespoke thoughts on "why": the reasons for the decline of Usenet are well-documented and easily found. It's a fascinating part of internet history worth reading up on.
- tptacek 3y agoBecause it sucked, and people fondly remembering it have blotted its manifold failures out of their memory. Imagine HN or Reddit, but virtually every post in every thread quotes huge chunks of preceding posts, often many layers deep. Randomly remove comments from threads; remove different comments from different servers at different times, to make sure nobody sees the exact same content. Eliminate search. Eliminate all but the most blunt-force moderation. Eliminate user profiles, or following particular users. Divide the universe into a global taxonomy of discussion topics, then allow people to cross-post from one to the other, starting firestorms of confused argument and complaint. Wait 2-12 hours for your discussion partners to see your as they move peristaltically through the store-and-forward NNTP system. Expire all history after a week or so. Every once in awhile, just for fun, drop a 50-comment-long chain of uuencoded binary chunks into the middle of your debate about Lisp. Usenet was one of the first systems of its kind, and it's no wonder people look back on it wistfully. It was wild, being able to talk (or argue, or flame, or troll) people all around the world at every hour of the day. Usenet was amazing. So was the Sony Vaio. You wouldn't want to use it today, though.
- kazinator 3y agoI don't know what you're talking about. I use Usenet daily. Usenet is the best forum system out there; everything web thing is just a ghetto/silo.
- hollerith 3y agoAnd yet you have 29622 karma points here. To accumulate those points, how many hours did you spend reading and writing on what you'd presumably call a ghetto/silo?
- kazinator 3y agoHowever, I've never been able to actually discuss anything substantial here beyond two or three exchanges at most, usually. Where is the equivalent of the Usenet three-month-long thread? The karma points are not transferable, which ticks off the checkbox under the silo column.
- patwolf 3y agoPeople mention the spam, but the decentralized nature also makes it plain harder to use than the web. It's like the difference between Mastodon and X. Your experience was largely dependent on the server and client you happened to use. I mainly ended up reading threads on Deja News (later Google Groups) because you could at least search for messages that were outside of the retention period of most servers.
- makeitdouble 3y agoYes. The only critical issue I'd see with Usenet's client interfaces would be linking cross threads. At some point a thrrad becomes irrelevant because of parallel discussions in other threads, being able to easily redirect to a specific point in another thread helps a lot. But that requires an URL, and messages ids weren't used for that purpose.
- layer8 3y agoI actually remember using message IDs to reference other postings. Newsreaders had commands to jump to a certain message ID. You had to copy the message ID from the posting, but on Unix that was just a double-click, and a middle-click to paste, so quickly accomplished.
- uoaei 3y agoZulip has many of these features I believe. Anecdotally it seems to be great for running an online discussion forum for a high school or college level class.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoI used Zulip last week to ask a question on Lean on their community. I only sent like 3 messages, but it was awfully slow. Didn't come away with a good impression.
- tabbott 3y agoI'd be curious to investigate this; do you have many tens of thousands of unread messages in the Lean community, or is it a new account? I ask because we have a known issue in Zulip that the first minute or two of using the product is quite slow for folks with 100K for unread messages because it the web app's client-side data fetching system ends up fetching them all in order to make clicking around the app afterwards extremely snappy. We've reworked that system over the last few months, and it'll be deployed to Zulip Cloud next week if all goes well. But if you don't have a lot of unread messages, I'd very much like to understand why -- I'd love for you to stop by chat.zulip.org and debug with us a bit if you can spare a bit of time. (It could be that the Lean community Zulip involves rendering a LOT of LaTeX, for example)
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoI didn't spend a lot of time. It is a new account. I logged in again just now to check. You are right. Lean community had about 3K unread messages for me. After I marked a whole bunch read, and clicked around a bit, speed is now good. Thanks for making me check. My only other feedback would be that there is a new user "tutorial" or rather the interface highlights certain aspects of the UI for the new user. The bubbles that pop up for this, are too small and not noticeable on a dark theme. Make them bigger and different color.
- 3y ago
- dontdieych 3y agoYou only think in yours UX world. That site shows quite different UX for same logical structure as you said. I would say backend core logic is almost same as usenet reader or mail client for mailing list. But the real value is quite different.
- saurik 3y agoFWIW, many email clients -- before Gmail dumbed down email forever and no one seems to understand that email replies form a tree anymore -- also had (and maybe some still do?) that way of viewing the world.
- hvis 3y agoThunderbird is still alive and developing.
- alberth 3y agoOr like the HN comment system :)
- xyzzy_plugh 3y agoThe HN comment system discourages depth as there is a relatively shallow limit to threads. There also is no in-built concept of an inbox to monitor replies.
- alcover 3y agoThis baffles me so much. It would be so simple and valuable to add.
- krapp 3y agoHacker News prefers quality over quantity and signal over noise. Deeper threads tend to result in uninteresting, low quality comments as the subject matter diverges from the topic at hand, or flamewars, so long-term engagement is discouraged.
- cubefox 3y agoI think the main reason for flame wars isn't the depth of threads but the users. Usenet had no such depth limits, LessWrong doesn't have them today.
- 3y ago
- tptacek 3y agoI have a very hard time connecting this to my lived experience of Usenet, which was full of top- and bottom- quoted posts, broken threads, and routine missing posts that sometimes left people talking past each other for days. I dearly loved Usenet; it started my career. But I don't miss it. Even before you get to basic affordances like posts, moderation and sorting, and following specific people, the basic nuts-and-bolts experience of discussing topics on Usenet was worse than it is today on Reddit, Usenet's rightful heir.
- skrebbel 3y agoThis must've differed a lot between usenet groups then; the ones I was on strictly followed a bottom (or infix) posting pattern and would chastise people who did it differently.
- navane 3y agoSo the culture enforced the discussion format, not the technology. Technically we could be all writing in a giant Notepad file, and adhere to any discussion format.
- straight-shoota 3y agoThat's basically how discussions work in Wikipedia (and other MediaWiki projects). Discussion pages are just a giant text file which anyone can edit fully. The only extra feature over Notepad is an implicit edit history.
- The_Colonel 3y agoWhat made this workable was that discussions were rarely "hot" - typically you discussed with one or two users over a span of many hours / days. Once you got many people editing the discussion page at the same time, you got conflicts which were solvable but annoying. (My experience is more than 10 years old, though)
- regularfry 3y ago