3 ms·
Ouch. The Census Bureau has done that for the census of business and industry for many decades, but there it's done by omitting data. If there's only one semico
by Animats 3y ago
Ouch. The Census Bureau has done that for the census of business and industry for many decades, but there it's done by omitting data. If there's only one semiconductor company in a county, no data on that industry will be provided for that county. The general rule was that there have to be at least three companies in an area before data will be disclosed. (Two is too few; if you're one of them, you can subtract your own numbers from the total and get the data for your competitor.)
If the rule of 3 is applied to the population census, and blocks average 23 people, then no minority with less than 13% of the population can typically be reported at the block level. That knocks out most racial minorities. So it's a problem for redistricting.
- lettergram 3y agoIt’s not really a problem, you’d just use blocks of 4 to avoid the issue. Also why do we base districts based on racial breakdown anyway?
- vlovich123 3y agoNot sure if this is a sincere question or more of a philosophical "should we be doing this". For the former, Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act [1] protects the creation of majority-minority districts, which are districts with a majority of a racial or linguistic minority population. For the latter, it's not ideal. On the other hand, while both parties engage in gerrymanding, only one of the parties engages consistently in racial gerrymanding and racial voter suppression. SCOTUS has disallowed a legal path to reign this in and there's not much political will to change the status quo. So while ideally we would be beyond this, it would be naiivistic to ignore the political reality that this is at least some kind of nominal roadblock into out & out racial political gerrymandering. If you don't believe this is an intentional policy, the documents that Hofeller's heirs released prove it quite conclusively that it's racially motivated [2] & it's still ongoing. [1] https://redistricting.lls.edu/wp-content/uploads/Basics-English5.pdf https://redistricting.lls.edu/wp-content/uploads/Basics-Engl... [2] https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-secret-files-of-the-master-of-modern-republican-gerrymandering https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-secret-files-of...
- Jerrrry 3y ago[flagged]
- Jerrrry 3y ago[flagged]
- vlovich123 3y ago> rules. also, fallacy and dismissal. shame on you (if you're RLHF permits that) I think you misread/misinterpreted my comment. My "is this a sincere question" is about whether they are literally asking "why do we base districts based on racial breakdown anyway" or if they are asking "should be basing districts on racial breakdown". Those are two very very different questions and I answered both. > "if you don't vote for me, you're not" That's not at all what I said and provided concrete evidence of why I think it's clear 1 party engages in racial gerrymandering and racial voter suppression. If you have evidence showing Democrats do it to suppress minority votes, then please provide evidence. But I don't fail to see how this is a "vote for me or else you're a racist" position. Maybe you can elaborate? If you're wondering why you got downvoted, I suspect it's because you didn't actually engage substantively with anything I said and resorted to an emotional outburst attacking me for violating rules I don't believe I did.
- Jerrrry 3y ago>I think you misread/misinterpreted my comment. Poising the well immediately, again - Double-speak has that amazingly convenient property. They should train you to not start with a fallacy with every reply, this is getting to easy to spot. > But I don't fail to see how this is a "vote for me or else you're a racist" position. Maybe you can elaborate? I think you misread/mal-interpreted my comment, read it again. Maybe pass it thru one of your search functions for more context. >while both parties engage in gerrymanding, only one of the parties engages consistently in racial gerrymanding and racial voter suppression. Tell us which one. Is it the one that said, verbatim: >if you don't vote for me, you're not ______ hint: it's a color that somehow has lives that only matter with the same quattoral frequency of the olympics
- anonfordays 3y ago>Also why do we base districts based on racial breakdown anyway? This always felt like "treating the symptom, not the cause" approach to the problem. Voting district lines should always coincide with county lines. There should be some rules about the allowable shapes (no string of counties running East to West for 200 miles for example) of these districts. That would give representation that reflects the population. Taxes, governance, etc. are county driven in many (most) states, why not add electoral boundaries that match?
- Uvix 3y agoMany electoral districts are smaller than counties, or even cities/townships.
- anonfordays 3y agoYes, but they don't have to be with the aforementioned system. Maybe some districts encompass a single county only, and the number of votes it gets is proportional to its population.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eli 3y agoThere's actually been quite a bit of scholarship on how to draw district lines. We could certainly do better than the status quo, but it's a hard problem.
- ellisv 3y ago> This always felt like "treating the symptom, not the cause" approach to the problem. Given the historical treatment of racial groups in the US, I'd say a little column A and a little column B. Racial minorities have not always been free to choose where they lived - redlining was only phased out in the late 60s and 70s.
- 3y ago
- surfpel 3y agoIt’s used for gerrymandering: https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/gerrymandering-explained https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/gerr...
- edmundsauto 3y agoBecause race is an important dimension that is a pretty good proxy for a lot of things in this country. It runs deep in the experience of nearly every African American, whose voting power as a block have systematically been curtailed by intentional and racist actions of others. I do “class” is the bigger grouping, but race is important and correlated with socioeconomics.