3 ms·
(Disclaimer: never played Hell divers 2, not a shooter fan, and I have had PSN since near the beginning) I'm surprised they cancelled it. Sony finally had thei
by johnnyanmac 3y ago
(Disclaimer: never played Hell divers 2, not a shooter fan, and I have had PSN since near the beginning)
I'm surprised they cancelled it. Sony finally had their popular GaaS, one that released under their helm, and it seemed to be their big portal into getting more sign-ups from a platform they were starting to experiment with. I guess they didn't want to risk the PR hit in this tumultuous year, especially after having to layoff so much talent not even a few months ago.
That said, I'll still make my hot take here and say how I hate how gamers will praise review systems to help organically inform each other if products, but then abuse it (and likely bot it) whenever any slight inconvenience makes it way in here. Review bombs are a tool that get weaker the more it is utilized, and we've already seen them being used previously to protest political decisions tangentially attached to the game. Or even review bomb unrelated games who simply have the same publisher.
The tumultuous user review system with little oversight makes me understand why Epic was hesitant to put that into their storefront roadmap for years, and why Sony/Nintendo (AFAIK) don't make it easy to change your reviews retroactively.
- OtomotO 3y ago> especially after having to layoff so much talent not even a few months ago. Excuse me, this is a sincere question, as I am not too familiar with Sony's numbers. Why did they have to? Did they write red numbers?
- johnnyanmac 3y agoProbably not the best of phrasing. They probably didn't have to (they can definitely keep people employed for years to come if push came to shove), but to give some official details: - Sony lost some valuations due to needing to lower their PS5 hardware sales projection from 25m to 21m for 2023 - Sony's YoY operating margin fell from 9% to 6% The reasons for these are a topic of its own (and I'm sure I can dig up a HN post on that very subject), but in a nutshell: the number did not go up, and as usual these "low" numbers are made up for by letting go of labor, the highest expense in any given company.
- wakawaka28 3y ago>That said, I'll still make my hot take here and say how I hate how gamers will praise review systems to help organically inform each other if products, but then abuse it (and likely bot it) whenever any slight inconvenience makes it way in here. Your "slight inconvenience" is someone else's dealbreaker. Everyone has a right to an opinion. If many people are pissed off, especially about legitimate gripes like privacy-invasive accounts and subscription schemes being sprung on them, then they deserve to be heard. If they bought the game (or someone bought it for them) then they deserve to give a review, even if it's a review that you'd rather not hear.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>Everyone has a right to an opinion. I'd hope it wouldn't be a hot take to suggest that not every opinion is equal. And that's my core issue. In spirit, you make a review to inform others of a product (many of whom have not experienced it), not to act as your personal mouthpiece for whatever political issue (unless your audience is in fact a political one. e.g. You have a review site based on LGBT friendly content). As such you need to keep an audience in mind for a review. I wouldn't make a review for Pokemon in the same way to someone who maybe played one game decades ago, compared to a fellow fan who's played nearly every main entry. Different audience, different content. I appreciate different lenses, but for these general platforms your audience is often "interested in game, is it good?". I don't think making a PSN account is enough to say "game is bad, don't buy". So I wouldn't put that in a general user review anymore than I would complaining about some small story inconsistency from an Easter egg in a game (even if it itself is a controversy in the specific community). But I'll admit this is a very personal quirk, perhaps outdated from a bygone era when communities were tight knit and you learned to talk differently with newcomers vs other regulars. General user reviews aren't very useful to me because there is simply so many ways to get the raw footage and see for myself if it has what I like. But I appreciate deeper comparisons and retrospectives after I played a game.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atomicfiredoll 3y agoThey should mention inconveniences in the review, those are relevant. My take is that while reviews can be weaponized (and Steam does attempt to flag that,) companies are throwing the phrase "review bombing" around to try and undermine legitimate reviews and concerns from paying customers. Epic's choice to avoid reviews, despite the resources they have at hand, is pretty squarely anti-consumer and part of why they struggle to gain consumer trust with their store.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>companies are throwing the phrase "review bombing" around to try and undermine legitimate reviews and concerns from paying customers Well, the companies won, given it's an official entry in the dictionary: https://www.dictionary.com/browse/review-bomb https://www.dictionary.com/browse/review-bomb > to manipulate an online rating system with a semiorganized campaign of unfavorable user reviews, often as a general statement of disapproval for a creator, a publisher, or other business, rather than a genuine opinion about a specific product or experience And yeah, that's not a bad definition. This situation seem to meet that definition. It's all relative, but I don't think needing to make a free account completely ruins the experience for 99% of modern online gamers. >Epic's choice to avoid reviews, despite the resources they have at hand, is pretty squarely anti-consumer and part of why they struggle to gain consumer trust with their store. I think it's simply a "lose more" scenario. The sentiment changed on Epic very quickly when they had a game people wanted on Steam, so it's a pile on reason to justify their reason to love/hate. It could be spun one way or another based on mood.
- atomicfiredoll 3y agoI'm not claiming that review bombing doesn't exist, if it didn't Steam wouldn't need systems to counter it. I'm saying that certain companies try to save face by falsely claiming that legitimate negative reviews, sometimes left in mass, are part of a coordinated campaign or stem from illegitimate intent/sources. Often the root cause of mass negative reviews is that the business legitimately prioritized the wrong thing, made some bad/anti-customer decision, or communicated poorly with their community. In regards to Epic, I'm not sure which game you're referencing. I don't really get the sense that the sentiment has changed and last I saw the Epic Games store still wasn't profitable after 5 years [0]. Anecdotally, the people I know using the Epic Store either do it for Fortnite/Rocket League or just to claim the free games (and some of those people never go back to play them.) As an aside, I think the Fortnite store may have some dark patterns, but overall Epic actually does a good job of knowing who the customers are and giving them what they want, to great success. (Apologies if I'm not using the correct terms for the Epic stuff, but I just don't use it.) [0] https://www.ign.com/articles/the-epic-games-store-still-isnt-profitable-nearly-five-years-after-launch https://www.ign.com/articles/the-epic-games-store-still-isnt...
- no_time 3y ago> I hate how gamers will praise review systems to help organically inform each other if products, but then abuse it (and likely bot it) This is the genius thing about Steam reviews. You can’t bot it unless you are ready to spend thousands of $$$. This plus the playtime tag next to the review arguably makes it more valuable than the often bought out “gaming journalist” crowd’s opinion. Youtube removing the dislike indicator in a similar vein wasn’t done to “protect against review bombing”. It done to shield certain very sensitive people from rightful criticism.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>You can’t bot it unless you are ready to spend thousands of $$$. By this point I wouldn't be surprised if some did. It's a pretty tiny price to sway an entire public's opinion. But i think the more realistic issue here is brigading. Gamers can easily coordinate together and use their accounts to post/change their reviews simply because "[social media] told me to" >This plus the playtime tag next to the review arguably makes it more valuable than the often bought out “gaming journalist” crowd’s opinion. As long as people don't read the actual reviews and they simply look at a number or blue/red text, the core issue doesn't change. Review bombs wouldn't work if people weren't so shallow about how they research their purchase. But I suppose that's a bigger can of worms.
- klabb3 3y ago> and it seemed to be their big portal into getting more sign-ups from a platform they were starting to experiment with What’s the point of forcing people to sign up? Some form of coercive marketing opportunity? Or just number go up for shareholders? Because it seems like they’re literally providing 0 value to HD2 gamers. Like both now, and in the future. It’s beyond useless, no?
- jonhohle 3y agoThe claim, based on the reporting I heard, was that it had to do with managing in game abuse. Sony likely has lots of tools to tracking and managing PSN account behavior and banning bad actors.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoSame as Gamepass, I assume. Larger numbers of PSN, more people to advertise to for stuff like PS Now, easier monitoring of accounts for cheaters. The one piece of value I heard was that you can earn both Steam achievements and PSN trophies at once for those that care about that. >Because it seems like they’re literally providing 0 value to HD2 gamers. If we're being blunt, Sony provided value by giving money to Arrowhead to make a game they sold at half the price of a AAA release. I am predominantly single player, but it seems to be a tiny "cost" to make a free account to help support for a continual service, one whose only MTX seems to be a non-expiring battle pass (and maybe some cosmetics?). I'm mostly saying this for the future rather than present. I think the only change they'll make next time is to make super sure PSN works at launch to prevent this kerfuffle.
- pdntspa 3y agoIt's a crude tool but most developers aren't particularly responsive to anything save for what the moneypigs... I mean publisher... wants
- sh79 3y agoThis is not a hot take, but uninformed one. They sold a game with PSN requirement in the countries where PSN was not available at all. You would just lose access to your game after 4 months, how is that a slight inconvenience? It's a pretty big legal mess they almost got themselves into. There are probably times when you could make an argument like this, but this isn't one of them. A company pulled something very anti-consumer, and the review system was instrumental in holding them accountable.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>You would just lose access to your game after 4 months, how is that a slight inconvenience? Unless you were physically unable to make a PSN account, this is the exaggeration I fear from such review bombs. And yes, I know PSN supports less countries than Steam, but how many people on the internet really reside in one of those non-supported areas? I would bet it is less than 84,000 people. >There are probably times when you could make an argument like this, but this isn't one of them. I don't think it's a good thing to only point out a systematic issue when it's inconviient. That's how these "but it worked here" sorts of issues become abused. I'd rather point out how this snowball is rolling before it becomes a boulder later on, especially when boulders have already formed and gone not nearly as mentioned. >A company pulled something very anti-consumer, Pet peeve: "anti-consumer" has lost all meaning. Paying $10 more was "anti consumer", downloading a store of your own preference is "anti-consumer". Now making an account you don't like is "anti-consumer"? You see how this word has gotten diluted in the gaming community, no? I miss when inconveniences were just that, inconvient. Not a declaration of war for capitalism.
- zettabomb 3y ago>And yes, I know PSN supports less countries than Steam, but how many people on the internet really reside in one of those non-supported areas? I would bet it is less than 84,000 people. It was delisted from 177 regions [0]. This apparently includes the CIS region [1], which has a population of nearly 240 million. You might be underestimating a bit. [0] https://www.pcgamer.com/games/third-person-shooter/sony-doubles-down-removing-helldivers-2-from-sale-in-177-countries-and-territories-that-cant-access-psn-while-arrowhead-ceo-says-i-dont-have-the-final-say/ https://www.pcgamer.com/games/third-person-shooter/sony-doub... [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/1ckd0w7/sony_removed_helldivers_2_from_sale_in_countries/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Steam/comments/1ckd0w7/sony_removed...
- osobo 3y agoThere really is no such thing as 'gamers', any more than there are 'movie-goers' or 'streamers'. Everybody does it. Some demographics will love to tribe up just for the sake of it. Some will just shrug and move on. One of the saddest things about game marketing is how it's still hyper-focused on horny teens. That said: As long as companies can change their TOS, content or even the availability of their game, the review system should be equally flexible.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>There really is no such thing as 'gamers', any more than there are 'movie-goers' or 'streamers I do think there are such things as movie-goers and streamers. There is a difference between "I watch a marvel movie a few times a year" and "I watch a few different kinds of movies a month and discuss them at movie club meetings". We can bikeshed the name but I'm really just talking about enthusiasts who do more than popular consumption within a hobby/medium.The stereotype doesn't matter much to my main point. >As long as companies can change their TOS, content or even the availability of their game, the review system should be equally flexible. My point was that review systems are not the place for "flexible" reviews, unless the game itself fundamentally changed. You can make petitions and post on social media and make videos and all that. But I don't think a user review platform is the place for the aforementioned tribalism. The only reason I'm not fully against it is because consumers shouldn't just base their purchase of products on how popular it is (a literal fallacy in debate). They should be able to read some reviews, see that it useless or tribal to your opinon, and find proper reviews or ways to evaluate media. But that's a bigger societal can of worms to open.