3 ms·
> It seems to me to be far better than a company which simply gives 0.1% of US GDP back to shareholders in the form of dividends or stock buybacks, which is a v
by eru 3y ago
> It seems to me to be far better than a company which simply gives 0.1% of US GDP back to shareholders in the form of dividends or stock buybacks, which is a very common occurrence given the size of companies nowadays.
The whole point of investing in companies is for those companies to eventually give the shareholders more resources back than they put in. [0] Those shareholders can then consume those resources, or invest them in something else; like eg startups that pursue new technologies.
Returning capital to shareholders is exactly how investing works and how it has to work. Otherwise it would be charity, which is also fine, but it's something different.
Are you also against companies paying back debt, instead of endlessly rolling over one loan into another loan and paying interest only with money from new loans? (If not, how is that different?)
[0] On average, and in expectation. Investing in risky endeavours means that sometimes they fail, and you get less or no money back.
- mlsu 3y agoNo, I don't have a problem in general with returning capital to shareholders. I'm not making an anti-capitalist argument here. I'm saying. For humanity, net good. Facebook could do a stock buyback with all of that H100 money. It's a significant amount of money. As a human, complete non facebook shareholder except in ETFs, I would rather they buy H100's and train huge neural nets and then release them for free. Maybe I've bought the kool-aid but I think I believe that Zuckerberg genuinely wants to move humanity forward with this one (of course, it's also a business move). A lesser chairman of the board would have not spent huge capex on GPUs, and instead simply issued a fat dividend or what have you to shareholders who eventually would buy a newer nicer house in Marin or whatever. And indeed, it's only Zuck's unique position with preferential shares that allows him to do this; at a different company, he'd have been shot down and dividends it would be. On the whole, which is better? What moves the needle in terms of bringing humanity forward? And this is kind of true of companies in general. "Returning money to shareholders" is not created equal, even though it's all money in the end. Sports betting companies are also returning basis points of GDP to shareholders. Is that a worthwhile thing to do? Net good? (Please, dear reader, do not make the argument that sports betting is actually a good thing because hey we all make free market choices.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eru 3y agoWell, I don't particularly like sports betting, but it doesn't seem worse than any other form of entertainment. Titanic had a 200 million dollar budget in the 1990s to produce about 444,600 movie frames and a bit of sound. Was that a good use of resources? Though to come back to the main argument: you seem to be comparing Apples to Oranges here? So the first thing is: how are those companies making money? That could be via Facebook ads, or via sports betting, etc. The second question is: what are those companies doing with the money. That could be investing in eg training neural nets, or returning it to shareholders. When you invest money, that's the same as spending resources. That's only worthwhile, when in expectation you get sufficiently more resources out later than you put in now. In contrast, when you return money to shareholders, no resources have been spend. It's up to the shareholders what they want to do with their 'resource-coupons' (ie their money). From the point of view of Facebook, dividends vs investment both look like spending money. From the point of view of the economy, the former is a mere transfer of resources, the latter is spending of resources. (You could argue that it's better in some sense for Mr Zuckerberg to control these resources than for the average investor to have that control. I'm sympathetic to that argument, especially if you carefully state what sense you have in mind.) > On the whole, which is better? What moves the needle in terms of bringing humanity forward? Dividends only move money around. They don't move the needle one way or another. It depends on what the shareholders are doing with the money. Btw, Amazon and Tesla show that 'the markets' can be extraordinarily patient with companies that they believe in. It's just that most managers don't have nearly as much charisma. Anyone can (and does!) say they have great long term plans, but it's hard to tell the charlatans from the true visionaries. So as a safe default, markets often prefer hard-to-fake signs of progress, like dividends.
- piva00 3y ago> Well, I don't particularly like sports betting, but it doesn't seem worse than any other form of entertainment. Titanic had a 200 million dollar budget in the 1990s to produce about 444,600 movie frames and a bit of sound. Was that a good use of resources? Sports betting is non-productive, money goes into a sink and gets absorbed without production. The production of Titanic had to hire hundreds to thousands of professionals through multiple companies to produce something, those people and businesses get paid and spend it back in the general economy (both to produce their product and the surplus that gets generated goes back into investments for the next project). Productive activities are always much better for society than non-productive ones like sports betting.