7 ms·
> That's correct and IMHO [censorship is] the right thing to do when shooting begins it's been a common observation since aischylos that the truth is the first
by kragen 3y ago
> That's correct and IMHO [censorship is] the right thing to do when shooting begins
it's been a common observation since aischylos that the truth is the first casualty of war
it's quite different to assert that the truth should be the first casualty of war, which seems to be your position
- dlubarov 3y agoFew questioned Ukraine's decision to ban RT's operations. This doesn't seem terribly different - Al Jazeera has very deep ties to Hamas, the enemy Israel is at war with, and has arguably been acting as their mouthpiece for propaganda.
- kragen 3y agoi did and do. banning your citizens from reading the 'propaganda' of your enemy reduces them to subjects and foments further armed conflict. it's also a power invariably used to avoid accountability for petty corruption such as beria's garden full of young, beautiful women
- twixfel 3y ago[flagged]
- kragen 3y agoif it was abject shite nobody wanted to read or watch, they wouldn't bother to ban it
- _djo_ 3y agoPropaganda is still dangerous, and a country at war has no obligation to allow the country it is at war with to continue to openly spread it. Banning RT makes sense in that context. I don't see the banning of Al Jazeera in the same light, as it's not like it's a Hamas-run outlet.
- twixfel 3y agoA country at war has no moral or legal obligation to publish its enemy’s propaganda. This should be very obvious. And yes RT was always complete shite for gullible morons, though it is rather beside the point in this case actually. The British government had no moral obligation on free speech grounds to allow the spread of nazi propaganda in the United Kingdom during WW2, either. Again, obvious stuff.
- raxxorraxor 3y agoPropaganda in war times is very often directed at a domestic audience. Examples are stories like the Ghost of Kyiv on the "western side". There are examples on the Russian side too.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoSure, but it's still lies. Somehow we act as if our lies are better than their lies.
- twixfel 3y agoYes: A lie to boost the morale of a country fighting a defensive war against a genocidal dictatorship is unambiguously a better lie than the lies of the genocidal dictatorship to rile up its populace to more effectively execute the genocidal war. My country lied to its populace during WW2 to boost morale in its fight against Nazi Germany. Nazi Germany lied to its populace to more effectively execute the holocaust. They are not the same. So it's true, not all lies are equally bad, hope that helps. Most learn that as children.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoSo we should lie that israel is losing hard, so good morale brings more and more people to fight for hamas?
- twixfel 3y ago
- dTal 3y agoI would love to live in the universe where popularity was a good indicator of quality.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoYes, they should read about how putin has only thre days of supplies left and not worry about the war, because it'll be over by the weekend. Oh wait, those articles were from 2022: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/russia-food-weapons-shortage-ukraine-b2041181.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/russia-food-... Why not ban Independent too?
- twixfel 3y agoIt's arguably not propaganda to publish an article quoting a member of the Ukrainian military. It's even in the headline right there: "Ukraine military claims". If you think the output of RT and the Independent are indistinguishable then yeah I guess we just will never agree. Still, glad my country banned RT nevertheless. If the only downside is the odd anti-west tankie on HN crying about "hypocrisy", then, it's not so bad ;)
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoSo trust the propaganda side, don't verify and publish such propagnda? I mean... you can still not read RT, I don't know why you feel the need to forbid others from reading it? What if others want to ban something you wish to read? I mean...i'm glad you admit supporting censorship, but you can't complain then when some other country bans lgbt materials, harry potter, books on sexuality, books about satan, etc.
- twixfel 3y ago>So trust the propaganda side, don't verify and publish such propagnda? ? > What if others want to ban something you wish to read? Somethings things get banned even in democratic societies, that's never not been the case. Given that Russia is attacking Europe and has carried out numerous executions of private citizens on European soil, I struggle to see why we are obliged to let them air their propaganda in our countries. Maybe suck cuckholdery is appealing to you, but not to me or us. > but you can't complain then when some other country bans lgbt materials, harry potter, books on sexuality, books about satan, etc I don't complain. Russia is a shithole, we know this, it's established fact at this point, if it wants to cry about Harry Potter and LGBT rather than finally install toilets in peoples houses and help brings its people into the 21st century, then that's their choice. But invading a sovereign country like Ukraine and committing genocide against Ukrainians, that's not really acceptable, sorry.
- kristiandupont 3y agoIs the fact that you put "propaganda" in quotation marks an indication that you don't consider RT to be that, or that you don't think propaganda even exists?
- AlecSchueler 3y agoI think the point is that one side's propaganda is another side's information.
- kristiandupont 3y agoAs in "there is no such thing as true or false, only opinion"?
- AlecSchueler 3y agoIn a post truth society, certainly. If you can't verify it yourself it's all a leap of faith.
- mistermann 3y ago"Verifying it yourself" is often if not usually also a leap of faith, because how shall a single mind error check itself in a confirmably reliable manner, especially if it's received no specialized training in the domain?
- AlecSchueler 3y agoIt comes down to the relative stretch of the leap you take.
- mistermann 3y agoAnd to know that, you need (just for starters) a means of discovering what is True...so you are back to the problem I noted. Luckily, all of this complexity can be wallpapered over by cultural conditioning, making the problem essentially vanish (depending on the frame of reference one is observing from, or if one even knows what that means).
- OfficeChad 3y ago[dead]
- dTal 3y agoAn important distinction must be drawn between suppressing distribution, and "banning your citizens from reading". In fact it is not illegal to possess or read RT content, nor even for that matter to share it on social media. It is not secret. All that has been done is to remove a propagandist with a megaphone from the town square.
- int_19h 3y agoIt should be noted that Ukraine has banned far more than just RT. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_the_press_in_Ukraine#Banned_journalists,_media,_websites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_the_press_in_Ukrain...
- mrtksn 3y agoI don’t say that the truth should be this or that, all I say is that information flow is part of the warfare and the parties at war will want to control it for their advantage. After all, they are literally killing people.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoSure, but why should we be subjected to only our own propagandists lies and not be able to hear the other side? Why are our lies better?
- twixfel 3y agoRT is not truth though. When a country is fighting for its very survival against a genocidal foe, I'm not about to start clutching my pearls that they've banned their genocidal foe's propaganda. Seems reasonable to me.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoIt's no worse than CNNs take on iraq and weapons of mass destruction, or (to go to the ru-ukr war), all the "putin has 3 days of supplies left" articles from 2022, 2023 and this year. You just prefer your own propaganda.
- twixfel 3y agoI don't think that "putin has 3 days of supplies left" propaganda is just as bad as the kind of genocidal propaganda pumped out by the Russian media, no, sorry. Not all propaganda is born equal. Antisemitic propaganda pumped out by the Nazis in WW2 was absolutely worse than "keep calm and carry on" propaganda pumped out by the Brits during WW2. Hope that helps.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoBut if you truly believe that putin is losing due to propaganda, you'll go and fight a war you believe you'll win... and then die, because the media lied to you. How is this good for you? I mean sure... you, as an outside observer want more "other" people to die for a cause you believe in, but for an individual it's better to know the truth and decide according to that, than to be mislead by lies and propaganda.
- twixfel 3y agoUkraine seems pretty intent on continuing to fight, I'm not forcing them to do anything, indeed I have no power over Ukrainian policy whatsoever. If Ukraine wants to fight then I believe we should support them. Hope that helps. > fight a war you believe you'll win... and then die I can't imagine any sane person is going to blame the Ukrainian media for Russia invading Ukraine, killing Ukrainian soldiers and committing genocide in Ukraine. I imagine they would, you know, blame Russia itself. Lol. Thanks for the hot takes though, amusing, if not also a little bit sad.