4 ms·
>but is there anyone that actually defends these DEI statements with a coherent argument, or can you point me to one online There was a recent debate on this[1
by gruez 3y ago
>but is there anyone that actually defends these DEI statements with a coherent argument, or can you point me to one online
There was a recent debate on this[1] and even the debater for the pro DEI statement side (that they could find) admitted that DEI statements that were just ideological pledges were wrong, and he was only in favor of statements about concrete things you did to advance the DEI agenda (eg. "I did a, b, and c in my previous position to enhance DEI in my department"). He argued that was justified because DEI (at least the principles, not necessarily the specific policies like affirmative action or whatever) were ostensibly things that the university cares about, and therefore they were fair game to ask for.
[1] https://opentodebate.org/debate/are-dei-mandates-for-university-faculties-a-bad-idea/ https://opentodebate.org/debate/are-dei-mandates-for-univers... (it's a podcast but there's a transcript tab on the page)
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThanks very much! I haven't watched this yet, but this was exactly the kind of honest discussion I was looking for that I didn't previously find, so much appreciated.
- skrowl 3y ago[dead]
- Aurornis 3y agoI’ve heard this same argument for DEI statements every time the topic has been debated: They sidestep arguments about DEI statements and instead retreat to safer arguments about how advancing DEI is a good thing. On one hand, I get it. Arguing for DEI in an abstract sense is much easier than arguing for specific interventions. On the other hand, this is the textbook example of a Motte-and-bailey fallacy, where the debater conflates two topics and then retreats to the safer position while hoping that the audience will accept it as an argument for the more difficult position. DEI statements have been quite unpopular as specific interventions, as noted in the article by the way that the majority of staff disagreed with them when polled privately. However, speaking out against them publicly was viewed as a very risky move and serious career mistake, so they slowly slipped into mainstream acceptance. It’s interesting to see how they’re now quietly being removed from processes with as little attention as possible. Nobody wants to be known as the person who campaigned against them publicly, but I suspect there are a lot of people feeling relief in this case as they’re being quietly removed from the process.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cogman10 3y agoFeels a little bit like making people take anti-theft pledges. I don't think anyone could reasonably expect that theft would be prevented by someone pledging not to engage in it yet it might be tricky to publicly remove because "what are you, pro-theft!?!" Similar to DEI training in general which doesn't appear to do too much. It should be argued that "we shouldn't do these trainings" yet you also don't want to be the one saying that. What does appear to work is a company actually hiring and promoting skilled diverse individuals and not just their buds.
- listless 3y ago> “feels a little bit like people making anti-theft pledges” Slate Star Codex covered this so well on https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/06/21/against-murderism/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/06/21/against-murderism/
- beerandt 3y agoImo it's very different bc the ideology pledge itself is mostly distracting from the real purpose of the dei statement (again imo), which is to provide a way to select employees based on race, etc, without it being the explicit reason. A better comparison would be if instead of an anti-theft pledge, there were a ten-commandments plus beatitudes test/ statement, without referencing the source religion. Maybe call it a morality pledge. It's essentially a religious test hiding behind another name and terms, and even if it doesn't explicitly discriminate based on religion, it's obviously designed so that people of certain religions do better. And filters people not from those religions by boosting those who essentially share the same values, or can fake it. In the same way, dei doesn't explicity select for diversity applicants, but for people who are explicitly pro-diversity-applicant. Which doesn't sound quite as pure of you replace "diversity" with any of the approved / included groups... 'I'm not picking applicant based on them being black, but based on them having an ideology that is pro-black-applicant.' Although sadly we've normalized it to crossing that line as well, with the last SCOTUS nominee.
- spacemanspiff01 3y agoWould it make more sense to have a generic statement, where one could do more dei side or it could be reaching out to undergraduates. Basically, a "aside from your teaching and research ability, what have you done to improve your campus that would make us want to hire you" It's much more ambiguous, on what is valuable. (I have no idea what the hiring process is like, just a random thoughts)
- eru 3y agoThe exact question doesn't even matter that much. They could just as well give you a blank page. What's more important is how they grade and rank you and make decisions. Eg imagine they only hired you if filled that blank page with a picture of the Pope, even if there are no explicit instructions or questions asking for it.
- ugh123 3y ago> (eg. "I did a, b, and c in my previous position to enhance DEI in my department") What if they worked for a dept. that didn't promote these things and may have had policy against them? Why should a candidate need to please yet another committee or reviewer of their "body of work" to now include and require certain achievements in an area that isn't even understood by many and all but squashed now by the supreme court as a tool to recruit students?
- dmurray 3y ago> What if they worked for a dept. that didn't promote these things and may have had policy against them? Then they lack experience relevant to the job, right? That's like asking "what if the applicant has no experience teaching computer science because he previously worked in the history department", except they can still make up something about feeling oppressed or fighting back against a culture they disagreed with. This seems like the least problematic thing about mandatory DEI statements: if you value DEI, you should value candidates with some previous experience of working in the DEI industry.