3 ms·
>i don't even know where that sentiment comes from. I introduced when I said I dont know anyone who expected to be in a rental for the rest of their lives. Thi
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
>i don't even know where that sentiment comes from.
I introduced when I said I dont know anyone who expected to be in a rental for the rest of their lives. This is support for the idea that the contracts in the US are expected to be terminatable by either party at will. You then countered with stories of family that never left and statements like the following:
"most people who rent have no intention to move out but expect the contract to be renewed."
"we'll stay here until life circumstances force us to move, which may well be never."
>the original argument was about the claim that a tenant wanting to renew a lease is unilaterally changing the agreement with the landlord. and that is simply not true.
If the agreement is that renting continues as long as both parties are happy, and either party can end it after a minimum time, for no special cost. If someone agrees to that contract, then refuses to let the other party terminate after the minimum time, that is changing the contract.
If someone signs a contract saying they will leave whenever asked, then later refuses to leave without a payment, that is clearly changing the agreement.
- em-bee 3y agoIf the agreement is that renting continues as long as both parties are happy, and either party can end it after a minimum time, for no special cost. If someone agrees to that contract, then refuses to let the other party terminate after the minimum time, that is changing the contract. ok, putting it explicit like that i kind of agree. but i don't see the example from the story in that way. the tenant had a clear expectation that they could stay, and the landlord knew that. they got blindsided by the landlord wanting them to move out because regardless of the actual contract they signed, the tenant clearly wasn't in the position to be able to simply move. situations like this are the reason why this is actually illegal in germany. being forced to move always creates a hardship for the tenant, and the laws are made to protect against that.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think the difference in emotional responses you and I have is largely dependent on the backstory that we are filling in. I'm more biased to believe or assume a malicious or incompetent tenant, and you are more inclined to assume a malicious landlord. You think they are being blindsided, and I think they've been given a minimum of 2 months notice. There are no facts about the reason for non-renewal in the article. Maybe the tenant is knocking holes in the walls or the owner is moving in. Like I said, our differences is probably colored by our experiences. I've seen people making 200k a year extort 50K cash for keys simply because they can and it's cheaper than an eviction. I've seen other tenants demand similar amounts to move out because they are doing 100K of damage per year and they know it's cheaper to pay them off.
- em-bee 3y agoactually, i am not assuming that anyone is malicious here, and i am observing that even without anyone being at fault, the lack of tenant protection puts the tenant at a disadvantage. and that disadvantage is what i intended to address. if a tenant is malicious then none of this discussion is even relevant, because we no longer need to consider the expectations of the tenant. if they damaged the property, sue them to get them to pay for the fix, or do whatever you need to make the problem go away. but if they are just a harmless nuisance, well then, tough luck. until the landlord provides a good reason for the eviction, i'll side with the tenant. have you had to find an apartment to rent on short notice before? two months is not enough. i'd need half a year.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoMost tenants are judgement proof, so there is no legal remedy. That is to say, there is no legal recourse and compensation avenue available. landlords are lucky if they can get possession of their property back intact. However, I agree that this is a distinct topic than no-cause eviction. The two intersect in that cash for keys is a common remedy for both situations. I think there are valid practical arguments that can be made for legally barring no-cause evictions or extending notice. The main point I was attempting to debate was the reasonableness of demanding cash-for-keys under a legal framework that explicitly allows no-cause eviction, and both parties have contractually agreed to no-fault eviction (and no-fault move out). This is largely because I believe in honoring my commitments, even if I could profit through breaking them or lying.