6 ms·
2 years after UK poop-engulfed beaches became national scandals, it's even worse
- throwaway888abc 3y agoThe real time map mentioned in article: https://www.sas.org.uk/water-quality/sewage-pollution-alerts/ https://www.sas.org.uk/water-quality/sewage-pollution-alerts... (crazy, TIL)
- nightowl_games 3y agoIsnt a sewer system one of the first indicators of a civilization? What does the collapse of that sewer system indicate?
- eesmith 3y agoThe Great Stink did not mark the end of the British Empire.
- praptak 3y agoIt's kind of the opposite. The cesspits that predated the sewer system were relatively friendlier to waterways. See this article on how changing to pipes caused the great Dutch stink: https://www.archaeology.org/issues/327-1901/letter-from/7205-letter-from-leiden https://www.archaeology.org/issues/327-1901/letter-from/7205...
- Htitjtj5859 3y ago[flagged]
- CaptainMarvel 3y agoI’m not sure about that, but I can tell you that the UK has been regressing in: healthcare, policing, education, road infrastructure, rail infrastructure, immigration control and social care for the last 10-15 years amongst other things. The median disposable salary has also been decreasing.
- YugyDugan 3y ago[dead]
- praptak 3y agoBristow attributes blame to “massive underinvestment by private water companies who’ve failed to do their duty.” UK water services were privatized in 1989. Welcome to the free market, where actions of rational agents produce the optimal result: cutting corners while getting paid the same and pocketing the difference.
- anonzzzies 3y agoWhat I have seen in UK on other and several other countries with some utilities (not sure if these sewers apply) is that privatisation happened, which was supposed to be good as we learned from the US (… right …), however, if that happens without competitors, it just means that there is one public now turned private company with money and shareholder pressure and 0 competitors will simply up the pricing, cut corners and do less and less over the years until things break enough to get into the news papers and questions to responsible gov agencies.
- praptak 3y ago> if that happens without competitors It does almost by definition. Sewers are a natural monopoly, it's physically infeasible to switch providers.
- gambiting 3y agoWell no, we actually have this model in the UK with internet, electricity and gas - you have one infrastructure maintained by a national operator, but you buy your services from any provider you wish, so there is competition in for example who provides your gas, even though obviously no one comes to your house to change your gas pipes every time you change providers.
- praptak 3y ago> you have one infrastructure maintained by a national operator Yeah I know this model but here the one infrastructure is the service.
- madaxe_again 3y agoThey call it an outrage, they talk about public outcry - yet this is the democratic will of the British people. This was not an accident - this was a choice. It was a manifesto promise by the conservatives to privatise water companies, and so they did. It was a manifesto promise by the conservatives to cut environmental regulations, and so they did. This is not a scandal. This is what Britain wants. Yes, like other British political decisions it might seem peculiar, but it’s their choice to make. Those complaining are a minority, or else they would have representation in parliament that would have lead to a different outcome - and yes, you can wring your hands about how FPTP makes for an unfair democracy - but they voted for that too when given the choice to switch to STV, recently.
- ggm 3y agoYou do know the odds of a significant labour victory at the next election are high? "Those complaining" are probably now in the ascendency. They just won most regional council elections. Renationalisation is not impossible. Which of course implies taxation to fund investment for capital works.
- switch007 3y agoI think the number of people who even read the manifesto is tiny. And within that group, those who realised privatisation was going to result in something other than individually (and temporarily) saving some money, even smaller. A minority you might say... And given our low turnouts and small proportion of the country that voted for that party, saying it's what Britain wants is disingenuous.
- madaxe_again 3y agoOk, well let’s say it’s what Britain voted for, even if they were generally wilfully ignorant as to what they were actually voting for. For what it’s worth, I remember ecological campaigns against privatisation of water - I remember a greenpeace chap giving a talk at school saying it would result in sewage on beaches and in rivers - and here we are. Information was available. A choice was made. We reap the consequences.
- 3y ago
- neglesaks 3y agoBritish innit!
- 8A51C 3y agoThere are government resources available which give also give daily pollution forecasts and all bathing water quality testing data, overflow locations etc. The testing is pretty good, I've seen them don a wetsuit and swim or wade out a bit to get samples. environment.data.gov.uk/bwq/profiles/ Storm overflow outputs are pretty predictable atm, for around 24hrs after ANY rainfall, it will advise against bathing. The situation is dire. What personally annoys me is the very disrespectful behaviour of the seeming majority of english residents who are perfectly happy to pave, tarmac or concrete their entire front garden to fill with cars, then replace the rear lawn with 'artificial grass'. Add this to the general transport development culture of builing bigger and wider roads, and any development in general, it all creates greater and faster run off. Something needs to be done. Support SAS.
- pixxel 3y ago> What personally annoys me is the very disrespectful behaviour of the seeming majority of english residents who are perfectly happy to pave, tarmac or concrete their entire front garden to fill with cars I disagree with your “disrespectful” label. Modern families might have 2-3 vehicles which can’t be parked on the streets as there’s no space. People have taken to parking two wheels on pavements so as not to block traffic. Concreting front gardens is a _necessity_ in this modern world in many towns, not an act of malicious disrespect. It is awful, though. Truly. I sometimes look at historic street photographs of the 50s/60s/70s. Well-manicured front gardens with very few cars on the road. Those days are all but gone… for now.
- 8A51C 3y agoAcknowledge the use of disrespectful as not ideal language. And I've nothing against moving cars into front gardens, living in a car dependant society is not any individuals fault. I'm strugling to describe the behaviour well. It's perhaps a cultural attitude where this is just the thing to do, without having a heavy heart and without thought of any compromise even where people posess the means and nouse to acomplish something different. I guess this applies to so many things though...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- SCdF 3y agoIt's so wild to me that anyone thought this would be successful. Perhaps this shows my ignorance of business and the stock market works, but water utilities are a service with a fixed set of customers, so there is neither a pressure to be good (because you can't gain customers from your competition so why bother) or a deterrent against being bad (because you have no competition so why bother). So the only way to make line go up is to do your job worse (to save costs), overcharge customers (to bring more money in) and do random dodgy accounting (to bring even more money in). Was the argument that they would save costs by doing it more efficiently? Why, when they have a captive customer base with no ability to lose or gain customers, would they bother with that!? Just mad.
- ssklash 3y agoI think you understand the situation perfectly. I'm similarly at a loss to explain why anyone thinks it was ever a good idea to privatise, unless you're one of the few directly profiting from the situation.
- euroderf 3y agoI remember reading about a UK water privatization. The first act of the new board of directors was to raise their compensation by 85,000 UKP each.
- tim333 3y agoThe problem isn't privatisation. You can fine companies that pollute: >When the UK joined the EU in the 70s, it was known for its dirty beaches. But by 2016, 96.5% of UK beaches met EU standards But then something glorious happened in 2016 and here we are. (quote from https://www.aquaread.com/blog/post-brexit-water-industry/#:~:text=When%20the%20UK%20joined%20the,here%20would%20reverse%20with%20Brexit https://www.aquaread.com/blog/post-brexit-water-industry/#:~....)
- nojvek 3y agoBrexit may have been most self own votes by British. They didn’t realize what they were exiting from. They went straight into corporate greed fuckery.
- librasteve 3y agoAccording to a recent post, UK regulators (the EA and OfWat in this case) are far less likely to implement fines or criminal sanctions against these blatant abuses than their US equivalents. Feargal Sharkey, a big supporter of SAS, states that the existing regulations are sufficient, just that our politicians are cowed by the lobbyists and party contributions. Thames Water was asset stripped by McQuarie bank who have extracted £bns in profits and dividends under OfWat noses. Not least is the revolving door of recruitment in this back scratching world.
- thefz 3y ago> Bristow attributes blame to “massive underinvestment by private water companies who’ve failed to do their duty.” UK water services were privatized in 1989. Yet another example of why essential services must be public. Privatisation for the sake of it is bad. Private companies will seek maximum profit and cutting costs, they don't care about anything else.
- thebruce87m 3y agoThe keep interchanging “UK” and “England” so much I can’t tell if this article is really only about England or not.
- alecco 3y agoThere's a massive "super sewer" tunnel project going on since 2016. https://www.tideway.london/the-tunnel/ https://www.tideway.london/the-tunnel/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJ3ipd9pDCA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJ3ipd9pDCA
- pauby 3y agoThis article flip flops confusing "England" and the "UK". England is not the UK. This article discusses England and its privatisation of water services. The author should pay better attention to these specifics.