4 ms·
Unfortunately, this article explains nothing. It says that you need 2,500-3,000 newtons to break concrete, which a hand can produce: > the hand of the karatek
by crazygringo 3y ago
Unfortunately, this article explains nothing.
It says that you need 2,500-3,000 newtons to break concrete, which a hand can produce:
> the hand of the karateka, or practitioner of karate, can… exert a force of more than 3,000 newtons
But then fails to explain why this doesn't shatter the hand:
> Human bone is five times stiffer than concrete and fifty times harder to break (successfully karate-chopping a femur would take more than 25,000 newtons’ worth of force). The bones in the hand are easily able to absorb the stress of the impact.
I mean sure, but karate chopping is done with the hand, not the femur. The femur is the largest bone in the body, in the leg!
And if it takes 25,000 newtons to shatter the gigantic femur, it seems entirely reasonable that it would take only, say, a hundredth of that to shatter one of the tiny carpal bones in the hand, for instance. Which would be 250 newtons, far below what it takes to break wood or concrete.
And even if bone is 50 times harder to break than concrete, the bone that absorbs impact first is tiny compared to the piece of concrete.
So even after reading this article, I have no answer whatsoever on why the tiny hand bones don't shatter.
Is it something about the bones' arrangement? Their flexibility? Something about the properties of the ligaments that connect them? Something to do with our skin? The level of compressibility of water?
- adrian_b 3y agoYes, from the title I have also expected a much more complete explanation about how to hit for a successful tameshi-wari (test of breaking). In the martial arts there are 5 or 6 traditional rules for how to hit for a maximum effect, and all of them can be explained by modern physics. The most important 3 are the following. To achieve maximum acceleration, you need maximum force. For maximum force, you need as many muscles as possible to participate in striking. The most powerful muscles are those of the legs, so they must also participate when hitting with the hand, by rotating the hips, whose movement must be transmitted through the abdomen and thorax until the hitting hand. To achieve maximum final velocity of the hand, the hitting arm must not move like a rigid stick, but like a flexible whip (more accurately like an articulated flail), with a wave propagating along it so that the extremity will achieve a maximum speed, much higher than the speed of the extremity of an arm-length stick that would rotate around the shoulder. For this, all the muscles that do not contribute to the acceleration of the hand must be as relaxed as possible. To achieve a maximum transfer of energy into the hitting target, it is necessary for the body part used for hitting to have a maximum equivalent mass. For maximum equivalent mass, the ideal is for the entire body to behave as a rigid body. This can be achieved by a contraction of most muscles. So in contrast with the time before the hand reaches the target, when most muscles should be relaxed, during the very short time of the impact most muscles must be contracted. In many Japanese martial arts this is somewhat confusingly explained by some mumbo-jumbo about "kime".
- amatecha 3y agoYeah! thank you! this comment is better than the whole original post! Very well-worded. You must practice some martial art? (no obligation to disclose, just curious)
- adrian_b 3y agoI have practiced for many years some Okinawan styles and also Japanese judo and aikido when I was young. Unfortunately later when I became much busier with my profession I have never found again some place close enough to my home to be able to go there regularly within the little available time. Nowadays I only practice solo exercices for preserving health, but this is still a very important benefit of what I have learned when young.
- amatecha 3y agoAh nice! I'm glad you're still doing some regular exercise/practice. I learned a bit of aikido when I was young too, and more recently have had some very nice 1:1 instruction in shotokan from a VERY experienced practitioner. I can see how mastering even just one or two kata can be a valuable practice throughout one's life, outside of the self-defense benefits. I like that there's always more to learn, and greater subtlety to understand and ingest. Very rewarding and mentally/spiritually powerful. (not to mention great exercise haha)