6 ms·
How much time should you spend sitting versus standing?
- Brajeshwar 3y agoI feel happy that I now can start a scientifically backed mental model that I should sleep 8.3 hours, and work for 6 hours or less.
- shermantanktop 3y agoFollowed by unhappiness comes when you can’t stick to it, followed by happiness when you realize it was stupid. Unfortunately some people never get to step 3.
- Brajeshwar 3y agoAh! That phenomenon where you leave a problem as it is because you get anxious and procrastinate. Then, it began to solve on its own. I love those.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- joelthelion 3y agoWe could totally design the world around that. For now, we just lack the will to do it.
- cko 3y ago2.2 hours of moderate to vigorous activity per day? Lifting only takes like 5 minutes of actual movement per day. Guess I need to go play some basketball because walking one hour a day plus calisthenics just won't cut it.
- bcrosby95 3y agoThat's defined as a brisk walk, or over 100 steps per minute. I probably get an hour per day alone walking my kids to and from school.
- IncreasePosts 3y agoTheir little legs must be so tired
- tuatoru 3y agoI can't tell if this is serious or ironic. Do kids still play running games at school? Football--uh, soccer? Tag? British bulldog[1]? A half-hour walk each way should be negligible. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_bulldog_(game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_bulldog_(game)
- IncreasePosts 3y agoHalf and half, but really - it depends how old the kids are. 110 steps/min might be 180 steps/min for a smaller kid. Also, kids frequently play by sprinting and then relaxing, and then sprinting, relaxing, etc. It's only boring adults who do steady state cardio like a long walk.
- uoaei 3y ago> It's only boring adults who do steady state cardio That's an interesting observation, I'd never noticed that but you're right. There was always something uncanny to me about high school teams for cross-country running but I could never put my finger on it.
- mathgeek 3y agoThat’s partially the competitive aspect as well. High school is peak “everyone can find something to compete in” for a lot of communities. Before that sports are usually more about play and afterwards tend more to recreation or exercise. Again, just generalities.
- jltsiren 3y agoThat feels intuitively right. Humans are not particularly strong, fast, or agile. But given enough time, we can outrun almost every other animal. If endurance is what we are good at, it makes sense that we need more physical activity than most animals.
- louthy 3y agoBut there is a difference between need when it comes to endurance (so that we can tire an animal enough that we can catch it and eat it) and the need to benefit from the physiological effects of movement. It isn’t a given that endurance exercise is good for us (I mean, it probably is, but no more good than any other form), it is a given that humans have good stamina because we needed to eat though, that’s surely the only real conclusion we can extract?
- lm28469 3y agoYou're fighting millions of years of evolution here, you're definitely more adapted to walk a few hours per day than to sit in front of a computer. Your entire body was designed for something we don't do anymore, which we replaced by things it was never design to withstand (lack of exercise, bad diets, bad posture, &c.)
- louthy 3y agoI’m not fighting anything. You can’t prove that I need to walk more than two hours a day to stay healthy. You can’t prove that humans haven’t evolved, at all, over that period of 1 million years. Saying that we need a minimum of two hours walking per day is not based in any kind of fact at all. It is entirely assumption. Exercise, yes, exercise for two hours or more per day, who knows?
- lm28469 3y agoAll I know is that I follow my rules and I'm healthier than 99% of people I meet
- tuatoru 3y ago[flagged]
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoIn general, this is going to include things like sweeping the floor, vacuuming, and walking a dog. Putting groceries away can be a moderate activity. You might have a job that covers it, too. It doesn't need to be all at once nor does it need to be dedicated exercise. You probably get some of this in your week as it is. If it helps, the link lists a slew of moderate and vigorous activity. https://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dnpa/physical/pdf/pa_intensity_table_2_1.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dnpa/physical/pdf/pa_intensity_t...
- naveen99 3y agoLifting time includes rest between sets, so you are probably at 2hrs already including the walking, calisthenics and lifting. 2.2 hrs lines up pretty well with surveys I have seen on r/fitness. I just started doing about that much (half walking, half weights) 2 months ago, and the results are pretty amazing.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y ago2.2 every day of the week is really a lot. I do 1 to 2 hours 5 days a week, but on the weekend I want to do whatever I want
- throwaway22032 3y agoThis is the point that is missed so often in discussions about physical fitness. Hundreds of millions of people, if not more, have been brainwashed into considering spending 8 hours a day at a desk to be normal whilst 1 hour a day of relatively sedate exercise is somehow "too much", when in reality that's actually still very low.
- rubicon33 3y agoBorn to move, paid to sit.
- n4r9 3y agoAlthough this is broadly true, I suspect that ancient humans (as well as those in modern hunter gatherer tribes) still spent a good deal of each day sitting. Whether it's by the fire in the evening or next to the river waiting for something to get caught in the nets. There's a lot of talk about standing more, but I wonder if a key difference is the sitting posture. Humans are born with the ability to sit into a deep squat and stay there for protracted periods. Core muscles engaged, knees apart, hips hinged. In the modern world we lose this ability at some age - maybe between 5 and 10? - and become accustomed to sitting in chairs. Core muscles lax, knees together, hips unhinged. Even so-called "ergonomic" desk chairs do not really help much I think, since it comes down to whether the sitter is really trying to engage and flex particular muscles. Since learning to squat with barbell many years ago, I sit very differently in desk chairs. Knees apart and seat low, and leaning slightly forward (no use of backrest) so it somewhat mimics a squat. It looks weird, but I've never cared much about looking to fit in. Edit - after writing the above I thought I should Google around,it turns out some modern hunter gatherers spend as much as ten hours per day in relative inactivity: https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/03/modern-hunter-gatherers-are-just-as-sedentary-as-we-are/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/03/modern-hunter-gather...
- kyleee 3y agoDoes anyone have a squatting desk setup?
- akira2501 3y agoI would think "time outside" vs "time inside" is more important than "standing" vs "sitting."
- henry2023 3y agoYou could make your own research and publish it. Actually the methodology of this one is pretty straightforward
- akira2501 3y agoThe research already exists. In either case I don't believe any methodology could possibly reveal the "perfect mix for optimal health." The headline belies the problem I have with this type of nonsense being posted on HN.
- mathgeek 3y agoI would assume that those spending equivalent time sitting or standing outside end up with more vitamin d, seasonal issues with sunburn/frostbite, and tend to get rained on more often.
- freitzkriesler2 3y ago"moderate-to-vigorous physical activity time might seem a quite high, at more than 2 hours a day, we defined it as more than 100 steps per minute. This equates to a brisk walk." The scale here made me laugh. So does actually going to the gym to break a sweat make it extreme physical activity?
- Swizec 3y agoI feel like all these articles/research are written from an extreme American perspective where people never move unless it’s from the couch to the car. You basically can’t exist in a European (and many others) lifestyle without getting this much exercise every day.
- Dunedan 3y agoNothing prevents somebody in Europe to stay at home without significant exercising all day, especially now as a lot of jobs are work-from-home.
- eastbound 3y agoI live in an area in France where the car reigns, and if I don’t do conscious exercise every day, I can end up with fewer than 1000 steps a day: Bed to kitchen, to the car, to meetings, then back home.
- kortilla 3y agoMost people in Europe would not qualify. The standard getting around the city paces are not fast enough for the threshold defined in this paper.
- OJFord 3y agoIt's right there in the comment above, 100 steps/minutes. Just over one and a half steps a second. It's not ambling around window shopping, but that's not really that brisk at all if you're going somewhere.
- henry2023 3y agoI’d be nice to know which wearable the subjects used during this study. I’d wear one just to have an accurate assessment of my own 24hrs
- cinntaile 3y ago"Thigh-worn activPAL" according to the methodology section of the actual study the article is based on. You can find the company's website here, although they don't seem to sell to consumers. Price should be around $400-500 I'd guess, some study published the price from 2021 which was 348 usd apparently. [0] https://www.palt.com/pals/ https://www.palt.com/pals/
- drgo 3y agoToo many important missing details, so it is hard to assess the validity of the results. Generally, observational studies of this kind are hotbed for false alarms and false hopes. The difficulty is that on average the people who sleep well and are physically active are also the people who eat well, have higher incomes and better access to healthcare. So it is hard to isolate one factor as the most responsible for the observed outcomes (the problem of confounding). Also, even if the observed average effects are real, it is hard to predict how that would translate into an effect at the individual level because the effect may depend on age, gender, genes, frailty, environmental factors etc (the problem of effect modification or interaction). Finally, because no actual data is shown, we do not know reliable and reproducible the results are (the problem of random error). Be careful of drawing any conclusions from observational studies especially studies of unknown methods and no published results. Edited for typos
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- uoaei 3y ago> The difficulty is that on average the people who sleep well and are physically active are also the people who eat well, have higher incomes and better access to healthcare Truly effective causal studies are still in their infancy, relatively speaking, and are still prone to the same correlation//causation fallacies. For instance, it's no fun studying things that may be the root cause of those behaviors but is hard to quantify, like "go-getter-ness" or something similarly illegible to scientific methods. You don't really know the structure of the problem so you can't put useful priors on it and focus in toward a reasonable inference. It's much easier to run t-tests and ANOVA by writing a couple lines of R so that's where we've settled as a community.
- drgo 3y agoThis is a very important point. It sounds obvious that the proxy for something should be treated as if it was the thing, but research is a business and researchers are people subject to peer pressure and social desirability bias. So the proxy becomes the thing.
- Havoc 3y ago4 hours of activity a day is a big ask for most I suspect.
- lm28469 3y agoIf people walked even a single hour per day they'd be much better off. With a typical office job you can easily get literally 0 minute of activity in your day. A decent diet, one hour of walk every evening and 30min of heavy lifts every other day and you'll be the fittest person in the room 90% of the time, such a small price to pay
- dzhiurgis 3y ago> fittest person in the room 90% of the time Shifting goalposts, just like x% of richest controlling y% of wealth.
- keybored 3y ago> the fittest person in the room 90% of the time, such a small price to pay Such a small price to pay for what? The median person has notoriously bad diet, bad exercise/movement habits, etc. so what does being in 90th percentile even tell you? And what does it tell you to be > and I'm healthier than 99% of people I meet Because apparently this just says that you are more fit than a seal with pneumonia in the middle of a desert. It seems more natural to ask what concretely you will be able to do. Because if I just wanted to get the Xth percentile bragging rights—which a lot of fitness bizarrely boils down to, with all the health benefits just being eh—I would just hang out with my father’s friends more.
- alamortsubite 3y agoThe irony is the typical American devotes more time than that each day to driving and paying for their automobile [1], the same device that robs them of a ton of physical activity they'd otherwise get without ever really thinking about it. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mUJFptzkdh8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mUJFptzkdh8
- gregwebs 3y agoSeems like the wrong question if you believe in evolution. That is humans did not evolve to sit as we sit today. I am trying to regain my ankle mobility and be in a squat position more. We also didn’t evolve to stand still at a standup desk for hours.
- jajko 3y agoCompletely agree. If I look at apes definitely more sitting than standing, which still tells next to nothing about what is best for humans. We know the answer - all kinds of movement, every day, not too intense but tons of it and not some 30 minute effort mixed with 12 hours of sitting. And bodybuilding as such has really nothing with evolution or whats good long term, just fashion and chasing women / childhood issues.
- __egb__ 3y agoThis is why I have such high hopes for AR for work. I can keep my job but still return to the hunter-gatherer lifestyle of my distant ancestors…only I would be hunting bugs and gathering requirements.
- croes 3y agoBy that logic we shouldn't walk on two feet either. Our ancestors didn't evolve to.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoI do all my work from bed, I'd say 99%. Remaining 1% is odd meetings. Does that count as sleep?