5 ms·
The HIPPA rules on health data are fairly strict, otherwise your doctor, hospital and so on could already be doing wrong. Personally I have a dumb TV, car, door
by tim333 3y ago
The HIPPA rules on health data are fairly strict, otherwise your doctor, hospital and so on could already be doing wrong. Personally I have a dumb TV, car, doorbell and fridge so not much spying there. The phone I'm less sure of.
- chimeracoder 3y ago> The HIPPA rules on health data are fairly strict Depends on how you define "strict". They're pretty onerous to comply with, but they don't really provide patients with anywhere near the level of protection that most people think. It's better than nothing, but in reality, your data is being legally shared with an arbitrary number of entities, without your consent, and without any way for you to even know who has access to that data. If that data is breached in any way, in theory the reports are supposed to trickle up the chain eventually. In practice? If it's more than one or two subcontractors deep, you'll probably never find out (unless the breached data is posted publicly and you stumble upon it that way). Also, the cap on penalties is shockingly low: $2 million for all violations of a given provision per calendar year. And that's for willful neglect. If the cause of the violation is determined to be lower than willful neglect, the maximum violation is even lower. For a very large and well-capitalized company, that might as well be a cost of business.
- peteradio 3y ago> your data is being legally shared with an arbitrary number of entities And ILLEGALLY shared via non-conformance with federal laws and data breaches. Just look at the Boeing fiasco and the serious normalization of deviance. You think that doesn't happen when you outsource your entire IT operations offshore to a populace that literally has zero skin in the game.
- benmanns 3y agoAnd what is your recourse? There's no private cause of action for HIPAA violations.
- adzm 3y agoFinally someone uses the correct acronym
- tiahura 3y agoBingo. As a new ambulance chaser, I was having some real difficulty getting the medical records for a client - no response for weeks and weeks and weeks. Aha! I thought. HIPAA gives them 30 days(sortof). We'll sue, and surely there's an attorney fee provision in there. Easy money. GOOGLE Wait what? No private cause of action! All I can do is file a complaint with HHS! That said, depending on your state, you may be able to make some sort of colorable common-law claim.
- randomdata 3y ago> GOOGLE Maybe ChatGPT would have given you a more favourable answer?
- forgetfreeman 3y agoSeems unlikely since at it's absolute best it's merely synthesizing a mashup of the same information that feeds Google search, and that's assuming it doesn't start seeing shit. Better to go directly to the source so you can at least make an attempt at vetting the credentials/expertise level that went into the information you're viewing instead of guessing how many mommy blogs, spam mills, and reddit comments got sucked into the intake in the process of producing whatever ChatGPT just coughed up.
- randomdata 3y agoGoing directly to the source did not provide a favourable answer. Did you somehow miss reading the thread before you replied?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 3y agoThe HIPPA rules may be strict, but my most frequent breach notification for loss of personal info (averaging once every 2-3 years) is from health insurers and practice companies losing my information.
- technofiend 3y agoHIPPA rules are easily circumvented unless you as a patient are paying attention: I can't tell you how many forms I've opted out of that wanted to explicitly export my data to third parties and partners that are not HIPPA compliant. And at least for my healthcare providers that use MyCharts, they like to make it part of the echeckin workflow, with no option to refuse. So you're forced to go up to the desk to check in and explicitly reject it each and every time. It's a healthcare dark pattern. And then there are online providers like better health that don't have the option to opt out at all. So you just have to avoid them entirely.
- ipython 3y ago100% this. I just visited an urgent care center yesterday for some strep tests. I was given an electronic signature pad and told to sign for "consent to care". No documentation was given to me on what I was signing - just that I needed to sign. I had to ask for a paper copy of the form I was signing, which was handed to me. That document said that "I acknowledge receiving the privacy notice ..." Was that given to me? Of course not. Asking for that - well let's just say I think I was the first person to ever ask for any of this documentation. I'm sure my information has been shared with 30 other entities - for a strep test. It's insane and unenforceable as a patient who just wants to get shit done.
- andsens 3y agoThe fact that it is even legal to ask patients to sign away their right to privacy boggles the mind.
- hollerith 3y agoThere are already too many restrictive law and rules in the US around healthcare, and here you want to add another restriction.
- alsetmusic 3y agoOk, I’ll bite. List some concrete examples. Otherwise, I have to land on the default that regulation is good and works better than a free-for-all.
- craigmcnamara 3y agoThe law is called HIPAA and technology providers sign a BAA(Business Associate Agreement) that states they agree to handle and store your information in compliance with the relevant standards and laws. With tools like OpenAI Whisper and GPT the HIPAA mode means that the tools don't retain any memory of prior interactions. Health tech is built on 3rd party vendors AWS, Google, and Microsoft are huge in the space.
- m3047 3y agoWorking at the edge of cybersecurity and privacy, you've just stepped in it: there is no "Health Insurance Portability and Privacy Act". It's the "Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act" (HIPAA). (And I see that noone corrects you below. [edit -- actually a few people do, or the comments are continuing]) Gravity is a fairly strict law too. Maybe you should review what it covers, what it doesn't. The Act greatly expands the "sloshability" of your data, whether the sanctions are appropriate or sufficient to prevent patient harm is debatable.
- renewiltord 3y agoIt's a bit unfair since it's an easy mistake to make but I treat HIPPA as the equivalent of seeing a resume that says someone knows SAP, Bash, JAVA, GIT, Perl. The capitalization is kind of bozo-signaling. HIPPA is bozo-signaling. I wouldn't expect right capitalization of FedRAMP. But JAVA vs. Java and HIPPA vs HIPAA just seem like you're not truly familiar.
- m3047 3y agoI'm not sure what your comment is: it's a bit unfair; it's easy to make a mistake; it's bozo-signaling; [you] wouldn't expect right [correct?] capitalization; [something other than capitalization] seem[s] like you're not truly familiar. What's unfair? Are random mistakes unfair (that's a very good philosophical question)? Are we forbidden from learning about other people from their mistakes or from mistakes generally? The parent says: > The HIPPA rules on health data are fairly strict The followons variously say: > I can't tell you how many forms I've opted out of that wanted to explicitly export my data to third parties and partners that are not HIPPA compliant. > I wasn't claiming that MyCharts isn't HIPPA compliant > The HIPPA rules may be strict I'm more convinced that these people are making claims about the heart of what they presume HIPAA to be than I am about my parent poster's intent. According to part of your comment these people are "not truly familiar", but without that surfeit of "P" all over it we wouldn't know. My comment was based on an actual conversation heard in the field while working with what is potentially HIPAA data. As for the parent post, the thought in my mind was is it a mistake? is it a troll? is it a mistake and they thought it was funny so they didn't correct it? I'm willing to give them a tip o' th' hat for the inadvertent glimpse into the bland certitude of inaccuracy.