3 ms·
I think Dawkins' narrow concept of "the gene" is outdated, and he does not realize it because he is an old biologist, not an information scientist. A "gene" wa
by snowwrestler 14y ago
I think Dawkins' narrow concept of "the gene" is outdated, and he does not realize it because he is an old biologist, not an information scientist.
A "gene" was never a physical object, it is an information object--a mental placeholder for the smallest chunk of genetic information that determines a physical trait. But as our understanding of the nature of information has advanced, it seem like the gene is ultimately an obscuring concept, not a revealing concept.
A "gene" is not a specific, standardized DNA sequence. As a concept it is not physically specific enough to tie into the stack of rigorous scientific knowledge that starts with quantum mechanics and ascends through physics, past chemistry, to biology. As a result it cannot be treated wholly mathematically, which leaves open the risk of storytelling vs. actual rigorous hypothesizing and testing. The last few chapters of "The Selfish Gene" are filled with fuzzy, untestable storytelling for instance.
On the other hand, as a unit of information it is far too specific and limited, because of course a gene is not the only way that information can be passed from one generation to the next. Information is also passed through society and culture--and yes, that can lead directly to physical traits. For instance my wife has pierced ears, and so does my mother-in-law. This hole in the ear is a physically measurable trait of both those humans, and it was caused by the direct passage of information from one generation to the next. That chunk of information just does not happen to meet Dawkins' conception of a "gene". But why does he get to define which information "really matters", and which doesn't, when it comes to physical traits and survival of the fittest?
When I read this book review I see Dawkins attempting to defend an early, fuzzy conception of an information theory. Evolution is an information process, and information is information is information, regardless of whether it is coded in DNA, in societal behavior, or in the printed word. I have not read the book in question, but Wilson might be better equipped to break down old distinctions because of his focus on social behavior--which carries information.
Ironically Dawkins started down this road with his idea of the "meme" but has not been able to make the mental leap to a fully realized information-centric vision of life and evolution.
Biologists are in for a hard time in the next few decades. A lot of fuzzy concepts that they take for granted--like "gene"--are going to be broken down and reformulated rigorously by mathematicians and computer scientists. It is already well on its way--a friend who started his Ph.D. in evolutionary biology in the lab now spends the vast majority of his time at his laptop, coding hypotheses and tests against a deep data set of sequenced genomes.
Warning: the preceding has been the ravings of an interested amateur and should not be considered Real Authoritative Science.
edit: fixes
- madhadron 14y agoA gene was not conflated with a DNA locus until the 1960s. Classical genetics treated 'gene' as any trait that could be stably isolated and transmitted in breeding experiments. I agree that a lot of the broken ideas are going to be revised, but in many cases they're going to be revised back to the original meaning before someone better at marketing than science forced a broken meaning on it.