5 ms·
Until one of them shoots down one of his satellites and ruins LEO for everybody. Space as a shared resource (as opposed to e.g. airspace) only works if countri
by lxgr 3y ago
Until one of them shoots down one of his satellites and ruins LEO for everybody.
Space as a shared resource (as opposed to e.g. airspace) only works if countries (and corporations) respect each others sovereignty.
- CamperBob2 3y agoHow is Musk responsible for what amounts to a terroristic atrocity committed by an evil regime?
- talldayo 3y agoBecause people like me pay for his service, and if his service stops working we'll stop paying for it.
- CamperBob2 3y agoBecause people like me pay for his service, and if his service stops working we'll stop paying for it. That doesn't make a whole lot of sense, so I'm probably missing your point. Can you clarify?
- talldayo 3y agoI am a Starlink customer. I don't love or hate Musk particularly, but when he makes bold claims that foreign leaders are helpless to stop LEO internet I hope he's ready to back that up. In light of recent developments[0] I don't think it's appropriate to assume all adversaries are helpless, and terrorism or not I'd assume Russia feels they have casus belli on Starlink after Musk's clashes with Russian governance and cooperation with NATO allies. [0] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/pentagon-official-warns-russian-anti-satellite-nuclear-weapon-devastat-rcna150314 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/pentagon-official-warns-r...
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoSure, go ahead, shoot down a Starlink satellite. There will be another along in a few minutes. Shoot down every one that passes over country X? Hope you've got a few thousand antisatellite weapons, and you're willing to burn them on this...
- DoktorDelta 3y agoMight only take one shot to give us a Kessler Syndrome scenario and trap mankind on the planet.
- Helmut10001 3y agoI thought Starlinks are below geostationary orbit, so I assume any debris should burn sooner or later.
- lxgr 3y agoWhat government are you talking about? That of Botswana, Ghana, or South Africa?
- lupusreal 3y agoOne satellite wouldn't "ruin LEO for everybody" and even if enough were shot down to cause a problem it would be a short-lived problem because most of the debris would decay within a few years. Furthermore, "ruin" is relative, "Kessler syndrome" doesn't mean instant satellite death, it results in an increased attrition rate which can be addressed by simply launching more of the highest value satellites and leaving the others on the ground until the situation clears up in a few years. SpaceX is in a good position to do this since they can replace satellites in LEO very cheaply. Also, the countries most likely to do something this stupid are the ones the US government is giving him permission to defy, particularly Iran or Russia. If something happens, it will be more on the US government than SpaceX.
- lxgr 3y agoI didn't say "ruin forever". "Elon-exclusive for a couple of years" honestly sounds bad enough. There's not only Starlink in LEO. Some of the existing constellations there are safety-of-life relevant (e.g. Iridium for polar flights or shipping routes), and Iridium doesn't have a stockpile of spares sitting on launchpads for an "Elon poked the bear one too many times" scenario.
- aaronblohowiak 3y agoIridium is 140 miles further away from earth than starlink, though..
- lxgr 3y agoI could imagine that in a head-on intercept of an Iridium satellite, some of the debris might make it into higher or lower orbital shell, but to be fair I don't know how realistic that actually is.
- jcims 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_satellite_collision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_satellite_collision