4 ms·
Wasn’t the Centaur upper stage pressurised. I remember an incident where one collapsed under load because the tank lost pressure.
by rbanffy 3y ago
Wasn’t the Centaur upper stage pressurised. I remember an incident where one collapsed under load because the tank lost pressure.
- GuB-42 3y agoWell, rockets are essentially bombs we try to make explode in a controlled manned. The "controlled" part is not always successful. Fueled rockets are treated like live bombs. No one around except for people who really need to be (like astronauts).
- dylan604 3y ago> The "controlled" part is not always successful. I'm assuming you're referring to the unnominal situations resulting in the unscheduled rapid disassembly procedures? I wonder how many people watch launches with similar intent as NASCAR races where they're just looking for the crashes or hockey games looking for the fights?
- GuB-42 3y agoI must admit I tend to watch SpaceX test flights for the potential fireworks. But for, say the JWST launch, it really wasn't with the same intent. In the former, it is just SpaceX way of doing business, no big deal, no significant payload being destroyed and the next rocket is on the line. The latter is the result of billions of dollars, many years of work and great scientific promises that could be blown to pieces. And of course, for manned flight, who in their right mind wants astronauts dead?
- dylan604 3y ago> And of course, for manned flight, who in their right mind wants astronauts dead? Which begs the question, who wants to fly Starliner?
- rbanffy 3y agoOr Orion’s heatshield for that matter. Orion 2 should have the attachment mechanism redesigned, most likely as arms attached to the upper side of the reentry vehicle rather than in holes in the shield itself.
- rbanffy 3y agoEven on SpaceX launches I’m rooting for the rocket.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoThat was in fact an innovation that followed the German V2 — dropping the framework structure of the rocket in favor of relying solely on the skin of the tank under pressure to give structural integrity of the rocket. "The tank of the Atlas consisted of stainless steel which was no thicker than a dime at any point. Generals, and later congressmen, worrying about what would happen if somebody dropped a wrench on such a tank were conducted to a test version of the "stainless steel balloon" that was stiffened by pressure and offered a choice of assorted mallets to see whether they could dent it. In each case the general or congressman grew tired before he had even succeeded in producing a mark that could be seen." Willy Ley's "Rocket's, Missiles and Men in Space" https://archive.org/details/rocketsmissilesm00leyw https://archive.org/details/rocketsmissilesm00leyw
- icegreentea2 3y agoYes, the Centaur upper stage was and still is using balloon tanks. I think this is the failure you're referring to: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=imkdz63agHY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=imkdz63agHY And here's a picture from ULA/Tony Bruno showing a Centaur tank in their factory, being supported by a rig: https://twitter.com/torybruno/status/1435553806792728579 https://twitter.com/torybruno/status/1435553806792728579
- xattt 3y agoI believe that the Apollo LM also depended on pressurization for structural strength.
- euroderf 3y agoAtlas too. Thin aluminum shell.