6 ms·
Disinformation is on the rise. How does it work?
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoMake unsubstantiated subjective assertions like "disinformation is on the rise"? Just a guess... =3
- hiimshort 3y agoIt's important to remember that 70% of the statistics on the internet are fake.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- m3kw9 3y agoHow does it work? Make it look like a consensus
- taneq 3y agoI mean, these sock puppets can't ALL be wrong.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoReading Twitter, or YouTube comments, or FT comments or any comments section, is pretty much the most pointless thing to do these days unless you want to marinate your brain in Russian/Chinese/Israeli/far right wing disinformation. There is far left disinformation too but that is usually the Russians or Chinese co-opting the political left, which seems to be really effective. For instance Jill Stein more or less parrots Russian propaganda. To me it's fairly obvious but I know some people just look at whats the most prevalent view and put weight in it. The paid trolls are not very sophisticated, they're rigid and repetitive, make numerous cultural mistakes, even as they claim they are American/European/the victim/the perpetrator, but they are legion. Comment sections should have a warning these days: "For entertainment purposes only, do not base anything important on what you read here".
- stronglikedan 3y ago> Russian/Chinese/Israeli/far right wing Did you omit "far left wing" out of cognitive bias? Or was that just an accidental omission?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoIt's in the brackets, which I'll remove for clarity. The political left don't really seem to indulge in disinformation, they just don't seem to be that aggressive in that respect.
- earthnail 3y agoThis is also true historically if you, for example, look at the 1920ies in Germany and the rise of the Nazi party.
- YugyDugan 3y ago[dead]
- stronglikedan 3y agoThat's literally all the Bolsheviks (political left) indulged in and it aided them in committing one of the worst atrocities ever, if not the worst. And, yes, the political left is demonstrably still participating.
- altruios 3y ago> demonstrably still participating Care to show a demonstration then?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoAlthough correct, totalitarian political movements all look much the same, left or right. I was going to post something about communist uprisings but they seemed in a different category, ie openly violent and oppressive, rather than the insidiousness of disinformation. > And, yes, the political left is demonstrably still participating. Unless you're talking about China or something, that's a bit rich.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- derelicta 3y agoIronic considering The Economist is a major source of warmongering disinformation
- shortsunblack 3y agoBy mainstream media losing credibility in an online age and being unable to reinvent itself, thus grasping for correct-sounding thought terminating cliches such as "disinformation is on the rise", with no substantiation? And, published by the outlet that has claimed China is near about collapsing just soon since 1990. The most credible MSM outlet there is.
- atlgator 3y agoHow does it work? Reach out to media and technology platforms to silence competing narratives.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jan3024 3y agoWhy don’t it get through whenever I support a certain media company on HN?
- b112 3y agoYou don't directly spew disinformation. Instead, you find the craziest but sane sounding nut you can, and donate anonymously, or via proxies, to whatever funding methods they have. Then when they start a nonprofit, or grow in other ways you donate there too. You give the crazy cat lady a super loud voice, and all the freedom and time to express it. Disinformation isn't as important as just "crazy".
- tbrownaw 3y agoHow odd, there's no mention of the campaigns to falsely deny that hunter biden's laptop was real and that there was us-funded gain-of-function research on coronavirises that had been farmed out to the Wuhan lab.
- mrkeen 3y agoWhy is that odd?
- tbrownaw 3y agoIf you're trying to examine how disinformation works, it ought to make sense to start with a couple of the examples with major widespread impact.
- mrkeen 3y agoI think we're up to 3 laptops now. [1] [1] https://www.foxnews.com/us/hunter-biden-laptop-repairman-john-paul-mac-isaacs-home-swatted https://www.foxnews.com/us/hunter-biden-laptop-repairman-joh...
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoSo standard right wing conspiracy theories. Odd indeed.
- DaSHacka 3y agoThe irony...
- hattmall 3y agoThe current Whitehouse is actually a great source of misinformation. My favorite being the tweet to push back on inflation that a conspicuously arranged 4th of July cookout was $0.16 cheaper than last year. https://twitter.com/WhiteHouse/status/1410709115333234691?lang=en https://twitter.com/WhiteHouse/status/1410709115333234691?la...
- aszantu 3y agoYesterday and today I was battling two guys who think that viruses are fake, held my ground until one gave up and the other one switched to insults, then an actual scientist showed up. It's annoying and really hard work to keep asking questions until they don't make sense anymore. The first one said viruses don't exist. 4 Million+ papers on google.scholar are completely dismissed as evidence. The second one say, viruses are just poison and can be treated as such. What I've noticed is a tendency to just replace the meaning of words itself. Like Virus means poison in greek, so that's what it is. The sources of their stuff are usually some anti-semitic right wing-websites, seemingly and it's the same thing that the left does with all that inclusive language.
- hattmall 3y agoWhere are you are that you are battling people about something like that and why?
- aszantu 3y agoTelegram channel, it just feel like it's important to hold ground when meeting someone like that. I'm German and in 1940 the nazis took over because the majority stayed silent and whatever battle was going on politically, they just stood with the victor back then.
- zer00eyz 3y agoDisinformation... Looking at the rotting tail of the fish when then head stinks is missing the point. Sicence, the temple of truth, has rotted its own foundation. The reproducibility crisis that started in psychology turned into the President of Harvard being caught plagiarizing. Meanwhile we have plenty of fair science that gets swallowed by ego, or stolen from its creators by their "betters" (In a shock to no one, a bunch of marginalized women are mixed in there). Disinformation will flourish as long as the foundations of information is built on a marsh.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThe irony of all the comments here is just wild. Makes it all feel a bit futile. Why bother discussing anything?
- jplrssn 3y agoI really hope the kind of conspiratorial thinking on display here isn't representative of HN readers in general.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 3y agoThe way it works is that the government or a billionaire (or both in partnership) completely though indirectly fund a dozen nonprofits that push their own current agenda. They also pump money into universities, or into individual projects run by people important within universities, in order to endow "The Freedom Chair for Injustice Studies" or some equally vapid shit. They then generate papers through the universities to support their agenda, and use the nonprofit to write press releases, that then are published in media outlets that will publish any rich man's claim, such as the NYT or WP, and other outlets that they have partial or complete ownership of. This generates enough bullshit smoke to nominally justify a federal investigation, which they use to harass anyone who disagrees with them, and threaten their businesses or jobs. The combination of active investigations and 10 different stories in every paper every day about "potential dangers," and 24/7 coverage of the non-issue, gives politicians enough cover to pass laws against expressing opinions against the interests of the people who pay, and other laws for more surveillance to make sure no one has a wrong opinion secretly. Eventually you get an Economist article explaining how the Chinese are poisoning America's youth against clean coal through Tiktok.
- javajive 3y agoI do wonder how many of these comments are disinformation bots trying to undermine the tech communities faith in established media
- DaSHacka 3y agoThe media did that just fine themselves.
- tivert 3y ago> I do wonder how many of these comments are disinformation bots None. HN is too small for that to make any sense. > trying to undermine the tech communities faith in established media I'm usually in the media's camp, but like a sibling comment mentioned, "the media did that just fine themselves." It's too temping for them to try to use their power to try to tip the scales in politics, and every time they do that, people loose a little faith in them (though weighted to the side they're acting against). The long-term end result of things like Rathergate, the stuff around Hunter Biden's laptop, innumerable more subtle things, and a frequently hectoring tone, is that too many people will not mourn the passing of the media (as they should), or are actively rooting for its destruction.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hunglee2 3y agoMedia outlets reporting on disinformation, as if they were neutral observers rather active propagators, is another method on how disinformation really works.
- teh_infallible 3y agoSurely everything in the NYT is true? What incentive would they have to promote an agenda? /s
- hunglee2 3y agosimilar to 'fact checkers' - as if simply adopting the moniker is enough to confer authority.
- infinghxsg 3y ago[dead]
- infinghxsg 3y ago[dead]
- switchbak 3y agoOur information ecosystem is truly poisoned at this stage, certainly not helped by a parade of "journalists" that see it as their job to correct the thinking of the unwashed masses versus delivering the truth as best they can approximate. Not that it was perfect years ago, but many folks see their job as that of an activist or even an agent of power. Mix in a dying media business model, and that desperation can get pretty ugly and have real negative effects on society. And there is a real benefit to be had (for some) when no one can trust what they hear or think. It seems like a great time to be a bad actor.
- pessimizer 3y agoThe new part is the lack of shame. Nobody is withdrawing stories that have been proven beyond a shadow of a doubt to have been incorrect. The transition from professional to propagandist has meant that admitting mistakes isn't a point of pride, but a point of weakness. They just move on, and act like the thing that they were haranguing the country about 24 hours a day last year is old news that you should get over in order to pay attention to the new thing that they demand you trust them about but offer no evidence or argument for, other than "anonymous administration officials", quotes from politicians and ex-generals, statements from lobbyists, and insane-sounding spokespeople for nonprofits indirectly funded by the government or entities that have a direct interest in the outcome. edit: The NYT has always been somewhat of an exception to this, because they actually did think of themselves as "the" newspaper of record, and know that they will be graded retroactively on actual lies. But the only person punished for Iraq was Judith Miller. The lesson was that there are no consequences for lying continuously, the consequences come from admitting it.
- brevitea 3y ago[dead]
- raincom 3y agoThe issue is not about disinformation as such. Who controls the flow of disinformation? Media, of course. When media moans about the rise of disinformation, it says that they can't control the disinformation the way the-powers-that-be want to.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- liquidpele 3y agoBullshit, I’ve seen far more disinformation in “free” online places than even Fox News as of late.
- hollywood_court 3y agoIt's hard to imagine a place that has more disinformation than Fox News. I'm sure they exist somewhere, but Fox News really takes the cake when it comes to straight up lying and disinformation.
- rascul 3y agoI watch both Fox News and CNN from time to time and I see about as much from one as the other.
- DaSHacka 3y agoCNN is honestly just as bad as Fox and the only reason they get away with it is a significant portion of the media also has a heavy left bias so it's less noticeable. The world is always ending, $CURRENT_THING is the most important thing ever, of the week. I have a family member obsessed with CNN, has it streamed on multiple televisions around the house at all times. Its quite funny watching his viewpoints flip-flop depending on the current news cycle and what CNN is focusing on at any given time. Pretty soon here he's probably gonna hassle me about getting another booster, (nameless) experts say they're so safe and effective after all.
- 3y ago
- taneq 3y agoPaywalls, mostly. A juicy hot take followed by greying text and a 'subscribe' button. Or am I just telling you this because I have some deeper agenda?
- unglaublich 3y agohttps://archive.is/3idV1 https://archive.is/3idV1
- ckorhonen 3y agoI was thinking the same - high-quality content from across the web is increasingly paywalled, while low-quality free content flourishes. Only being able to afford to subscribe to a small number of sources keeps you inside the same echo chamber.