4 ms·
GitHub: Nintendo Submit DMCA Notices to Yuzu Forks
- Sephr 3y agoI read this DMCA notice, and it's... completely reasonable. Emulators are legal. Distributing copyrighted crypto keys is not. If Yuzu devs want their emulator to stay up, they shouldn't include those crypto keys. All they have to do is provide a user interface for users themselves to provide these keys.
- LocalH 3y ago"illegal numbers"
- Sephr 3y agoUpdate: A redditor replied to this same comment (on reddit[1]) with an interesting response. > That's what Yuzu does... You have to provide your own prod and title keys. They aren't providing these for you. > Same for any Switch emulator. This reddit comment is implying that the claims in the DMCA notice are fraudulent. 1. https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/1cie1rv/github_nintendo_submit_dmca_notices_to_yuzu_forks/l2a6kwn/?context=1 https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/1cie1rv/github_nin...
- getwiththeprog 3y agoI guess this means Yuzu works really well now :)
- phendrenad2 3y agoIs this a false DMCA notice? See: https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/1cie1rv/comment/l2a7pqq/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/1cie1rv/comment/l2...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Shank 3y agoI mean it shouldn’t be a shocker that this happened. Nintendo made their case clear in court the DMCA is strongly in favor of copyright holders. Obviously people can file a counter-notice, but that immediately opens them up to a lawsuit from Nintendo, which, well, we all saw how that went with yuzu. If the yuzu developers didn’t want to risk the fight, would any rational person who forked it?
- realusername 3y ago> we all saw how that went with yuzu. To my knowledge, there hasn't been any judgement but a private settlement has been made. It's true that you can't really defend your rights against a corporation as big as Nintendo though.
- apetresc 3y agoA private settlement of paying Nintendo $2.4M. How is that not a perfect example of "we all saw how that went"?
- realusername 3y agoThe first part of the sentence is "the DMCA is strongly in favor of copyright holders". Well no that's my point, the DMCA hasn't been used in this case. Nobody knows if the DMCA would have been enough to take down Yuzu because that hasn't been judged.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoIf you read the lawsuit, Nintendo cited the DMCA laws regarding the breaking of "technological protection measures" extensively. The DMCA is broader than just takedowns. Even if Yuzu succeeded in overturning the takedown, Nintendo could prevail in the court of law on the merits of the DMCA. Overturning a takedown is easy - just file a counter notice. Expect to be seen in court if you do that, though. Edit: For the "On the technological protection measures, it hasn't been judged," look at Apple vs Psystar. A case where breaking TPMs came up, which actually was fought to the point of where a SCOTUS appeal was the last step remaining. Psystar was annihilated - and let me tell you, emulating macOS on non-Mac hardware sounds a lot like emulating Video Games on non-Nintendo hardware.
- jsheard 3y agoHas any specific Yuzu fork been established as the new standard yet? Early on there were a bunch of clout chasers announcing forks and then only making surface level tweaks to the branding, because they really had no idea what they were doing.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoNope. There was a bunch of hype around `Suyu`, even in the news, before it was discovered the developer was a minor who had no idea what he was doing. No rational person is going to fight a DMCA from Nintendo. Nintendo would in no circumstances not file a DMCA against a Yuzu fork. Additionally, the settlement required that all of the core developers, who would know it best, are never permitted to work on a Nintendo emulator ever again. Thus, Yuzu is completely dead.
- jsheard 3y agoWell, at least we still have Ryujinx. Citra getting caught in the Yuzu crossfire is worse because there isn't another mature 3DS emulator to fall back on.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- squigz 3y agoThese are the same devs who thought profiting tens of thousands off this project was a smart idea, right?
- gjsman-1000 3y agoThe profit has nothing to do with it. Bleem! was profit driven by design, for example. (Bleem! is also irrelevant being decided before the DMCA provisions came into effect.) Is it a smart idea? No; but a profitable emulator should be just as legal as an unprofitable one. But where it involves breaking digital locks, as Nintendo may successfully demonstrate, the DMCA makes both illegal.
- codedokode 3y agoCan this problem be solved by having 2 independent projects: one emulator that doesn't deal with decryption, and a convertor that allows to remove encryption from a legally obtained game?
- Sephr 3y agoEven easier: just don't include the keys. The algorithms are likely fine to include.
- ijxjdffnkkpp 3y agoYuzu is on archive.org https://archive.org/details/yuzu-windows-msvc-20240304-537296095_20240305_1340 https://archive.org/details/yuzu-windows-msvc-20240304-53729... .
- deaddodo 3y agoIt doesn't include the offending keys. This is the portion Nintendo is using as an excuse to strike the GitHub projects.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoAh, the destruction of property rights by contract law. Sprinkle in some "technological protection measures" and all of a sudden exercising consumer rights is now a felony offense. As Cory Doctorow says, felony offense of business model. See Mark Lemley's two decade old Terms of Use, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm I love technology because I think it enriches & enhances individuals. Our ability to impact the local & broader world goes hand in hand with our tool-making & tech (often is the same thing). Technology is amazing & great. But layer in Intellectual Property law & suddenly technology is the infernal machine, is the anchor sinking humanity & tyrannizing the spirit. I feel a religious obligation above that of my state's requirements to smash this hell.
- maxglute 3y agoAre there any jurisdictions where emulators can be worked on without Nintendo having legal leverage? I'm surprised Russians aren't all over this.
- throwaway74354 3y ago>I'm surprised Russians aren't all over this. Mind share issue. Russia, as most of Ex-USSR, is a PC gaming country. To have an active emulation community, there has to be a massive following around the certain console in the first place. The most successful Nintendo items in the region were Chinese NES clones.
- EMIRELADERO 3y agoI'm surprised GitHub honored these requests as they aren't valid to begin with. DMCA takedown notices can only be used for traditional copyright violations, not allegations of protection measure circumvention.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoNone of the big copyright distributing sites really play by DMCA. DMCA is just the formal, legal process. Most sites are putting some sort of self-managed process in front of DMCA. They can remove anything they want because their terms allow it. It in turn makes copyright holders happy without any of the risk of false DMCA complaints.
- zamadatix 3y agoGitHub seems to prefer and recommend circumvention compalints be submitted through the DMCA takedown form https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/content-removal-policies/guide-to-submitting-a-dmca-takedown-notice#complaints-about-anti-circumvention-technology https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/content-removal-polic...